🗳️ Votes
Thursday, 24 May 2012
Taxation (Budget Measures) Bill
24 May 2012
·
Clauses 1 and 2
·
Party vote
That clause 2 be agreed to
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, Māori Party, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
64
Aye
–
55
No
2 absent
24 May 2012
·
Clauses 1 and 2
·
Party vote
That the motion be agreed to
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, Māori Party, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
64
Aye
–
55
No
2 absent
24 May 2012
·
Third Reading
·
Party vote
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, Māori Party, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
64
Aye
–
53
No
4 absent
Thursday, 24 May 2012
Social Security (Long-term Residential Care—Budget Measures) Amendment Bill
24 May 2012
·
First Reading
·
Party vote
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, Māori Party, New Zealand National
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
64
Aye
–
54
No
3 absent
24 May 2012
·
Second Reading
·
Party vote
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, Māori Party, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
64
Aye
–
54
No
3 absent
24 May 2012
·
Part 1 Applicable asset thresholds: Indexation
·
Party vote
That Part 1 be agreed to
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, Māori Party, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
64
Aye
–
53
No
4 absent
24 May 2012
·
Part 2 Applicable asset thresholds: General
·
Party vote
That Part 2 be agreed to.
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, Māori Party, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
64
Aye
–
54
No
3 absent
24 May 2012
·
Clauses 1 to 3
·
Party vote
That clause 1 be agreed to.
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, Māori Party, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
64
Aye
–
54
No
3 absent
24 May 2012
·
Clauses 1 to 3
·
Party vote
That clause 2 be agreed to.
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, Māori Party, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
64
Aye
–
54
No
3 absent
24 May 2012
·
Clauses 1 to 3
·
Party vote
That clause 3 be agreed to.
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, Māori Party, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
64
Aye
–
54
No
3 absent
24 May 2012
·
Third Reading
·
Party vote
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, Māori Party, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
64
Aye
–
54
No
3 absent
Wednesday, 23 May 2012
Crown Entities Reform Bill
23 May 2012
·
Part 2 Mental Health Commission Act 1998
·
Party vote
That Part 2 be agreed to
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, Māori Party, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
61
Aye
–
59
No
1 absent
23 May 2012
·
Part 3 Charities Act 2005
·
Party vote
That the question be now put
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, Māori Party, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
61
Aye
–
58
No
2 absent
23 May 2012
·
Part 3 Charities Act 2005
·
Party vote
That Part 3 be agreed to
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, Māori Party, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
61
Aye
–
58
No
2 absent
23 May 2012
·
Schedule 1
·
Party vote
That schedule 1 be agreed to
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, Māori Party, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
61
Aye
–
58
No
2 absent
23 May 2012
·
Schedule 2
·
Party vote
That schedule 2 be agreed to
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, Māori Party, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
61
Aye
–
58
No
2 absent
23 May 2012
·
Schedule 3
·
Party vote
That schedule 3 be agreed to
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, Māori Party, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
61
Aye
–
58
No
2 absent
23 May 2012
·
Schedule 4
·
Party vote
That schedule 4 be agreed to
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, Māori Party, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
61
Aye
–
58
No
2 absent
23 May 2012
·
Schedule 5
·
Party vote
That schedule 5 be agreed to
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, Māori Party, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
61
Aye
–
58
No
2 absent
23 May 2012
·
Schedule 6
·
Party vote
That schedule 6 be agreed to
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, Māori Party, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
61
Aye
–
58
No
2 absent
23 May 2012
·
Schedule 7
·
Party vote
That schedule 7 be agreed to
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, Māori Party, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
61
Aye
–
58
No
2 absent
23 May 2012
·
Schedule 8
·
Party vote
That the amendments be agreed to
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, Green Party, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Mana, Māori Party, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
73
Aye
–
46
No
2 absent
23 May 2012
·
Schedule 8
·
Party vote
That schedule 8 as amended be agreed to
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, Māori Party, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
61
Aye
–
58
No
2 absent
23 May 2012
·
Schedule 9
·
Party vote
That the amendments be agreed to
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, Māori Party, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
61
Aye
–
58
No
2 absent
23 May 2012
·
Schedule 9
·
Party vote
That schedule 9 as amended be agreed to
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, Māori Party, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
61
Aye
–
58
No
2 absent
23 May 2012
·
Clauses 1 and 2
·
Party vote
That the question be now put
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, Māori Party, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
64
Aye
–
55
No
2 absent
23 May 2012
·
Clauses 1 and 2
·
Party vote
That clause 1 be agreed to
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, Māori Party, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
61
Aye
–
58
No
2 absent
23 May 2012
·
Clauses 1 and 2
·
Party vote
That the amendment be agreed to
Aye:
Green Party, Mana, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
—
No:
ACT New Zealand, Māori Party, New Zealand National, United Future
✕ Failed
55
Aye
–
64
No
2 absent
23 May 2012
·
Clauses 1 and 2
·
Party vote
That clause 2 be agreed to
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, Māori Party, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
61
Aye
–
58
No
2 absent
Thursday, 3 May 2012
Immigration Amendment Bill
3 May 2012
·
First Reading
·
Party vote
📋 Group detention powers for mass arrivals
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, Māori Party, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
63
Aye
–
57
No
1 absent
3 May 2012
·
First Reading
·
Party vote
That the Transport and Industrial Relations Committee consider the bill
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, Māori Party, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
63
Aye
–
57
No
1 absent
3 May 2012
·
First Reading
·
Party vote
That the motion be agreed to
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, Māori Party, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
63
Aye
–
57
No
1 absent
Wednesday, 2 May 2012
Prisoners’ and Victims’ Claims (2012 Expiry and Application Dates) Amendment Bill
2 May 2012
·
First Reading
·
Party vote
📋 Restricting prisoner compensation payouts (redirect to victims)
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, Māori Party
✓ Passed
103
Aye
–
17
No
1 absent
2 May 2012
·
First Reading
·
Party vote
That the Justice and Electoral Committee report back to the House on or before 11 June 2012, and that the committee have authority to meet at any time while the House is sitting (except during oral questions), during any evening on a day on which there has been a sitting of the House, on a Friday in a week in which there has been a sitting of the House, and outside the Wellington area during a sitting of the House, despite Standing Orders 188, 190(a), and 191(1)(b) and (c)
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, Māori Party, New Zealand First, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
72
Aye
–
48
No
1 absent
Tuesday, 1 May 2012
Vote: Financial Review Debate — Clauses 1 to 10, and schedules 1 to 7 agreed to.
Tuesday, 3 April 2012
Dairy Industry Restructuring Amendment Bill
3 Apr 2012
·
First Reading
·
Party vote
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, Māori Party, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
64
Aye
–
54
No
3 absent
3 Apr 2012
·
First Reading
·
Party vote
That the question be now put
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, Māori Party, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
64
Aye
–
54
No
3 absent
3 Apr 2012
·
First Reading
·
Party vote
That the Primary Production Committee report finally to the House on or before 1 June 2012
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, Māori Party, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
64
Aye
–
54
No
3 absent
Wednesday, 28 March 2012
Student Loan Scheme Amendment Bill
28 Mar 2012
·
Part 1 Amendments to principal Act
·
Party vote
That the question be now put
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, Mana, Māori Party, New Zealand First, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
72
Aye
–
48
No
1 absent
28 Mar 2012
·
Part 1 Amendments to principal Act
·
Party vote
That the amendments be agreed to
Aye:
Green Party, Mana, New Zealand Labour
—
No:
ACT New Zealand, Māori Party, New Zealand First, New Zealand National, United Future
✕ Failed
49
Aye
–
71
No
1 absent
28 Mar 2012
·
Part 1 Amendments to principal Act
·
Party vote
That the amendments be agreed to
Aye:
Green Party, Mana, New Zealand Labour
—
No:
ACT New Zealand, Māori Party, New Zealand First, New Zealand National, United Future
✕ Failed
49
Aye
–
71
No
1 absent
28 Mar 2012
·
Part 1 Amendments to principal Act
·
Party vote
That Part 1 be agreed to
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, Mana, Māori Party, New Zealand First, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
72
Aye
–
48
No
1 absent
28 Mar 2012
·
Part 2 Transitional provision
·
Party vote
That Part 2 be agreed to
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, Mana, Māori Party, New Zealand First, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
72
Aye
–
48
No
1 absent
28 Mar 2012
·
Clauses 1 and 2
·
Party vote
That the question be now put.
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, Mana, Māori Party, New Zealand First, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
72
Aye
–
48
No
1 absent
28 Mar 2012
·
Clauses 1 and 2
·
Party vote
That clause 1 be agreed to
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, Mana, Māori Party, New Zealand First, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
72
Aye
–
48
No
1 absent
28 Mar 2012
·
Clauses 1 and 2
·
Party vote
That the amendment be agreed to
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, Mana, Māori Party, New Zealand First, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
72
Aye
–
48
No
1 absent
28 Mar 2012
·
Clauses 1 and 2
·
Party vote
That clause 2 as amended be agreed to
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, Mana, Māori Party, New Zealand First, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
72
Aye
–
48
No
1 absent
Tuesday, 27 March 2012
Social Security (Youth Support and Work Focus) Amendment Bill
27 Mar 2012
·
First Reading
·
Party vote
📋 Making access to sickness/incapacity benefits harder
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, Māori Party, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
64
Aye
–
57
No
27 Mar 2012
·
First Reading
·
Party vote
That the Social Services Committee report finally to the House on or before 31 May 2012, and that the committee have authority to meet at any time while the House is sitting (except during oral questions), during any evening on a day on which there has been a sitting of the House, on a Friday in a week in which there has been a sitting of the House, and outside the Wellington area during a sitting of the House, despite Standing Orders 188, 190, and 191(1)(b) and (c)
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, Māori Party, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
64
Aye
–
57
No
Tuesday, 27 March 2012
Student Loan Scheme Amendment Bill
27 Mar 2012
·
Second Reading
·
Party vote
That the amendments recommended by the Finance and Expenditure Committee by majority be agreed to
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, Mana, Māori Party, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party
✓ Passed
107
Aye
–
14
No
27 Mar 2012
·
Second Reading
·
Party vote
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, Mana, Māori Party, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party
✓ Passed
107
Aye
–
14
No
Wednesday, 21 March 2012
Employment Relations (Secret Ballot for Strikes) Amendment Bill
21 Mar 2012
·
Clause 2 Commencement (reconsidered)
·
Vote type unknown
(question not parsed yet)
🚨 Not parsed (over 14 years ago)
21 Mar 2012
·
New clause 5A Requirement for society’s rules to include secret ballots for strikes (continued)
·
Party vote
That the amendment be agreed to
Aye:
Green Party, Mana, New Zealand Labour
—
No:
ACT New Zealand, Māori Party, New Zealand First, New Zealand National, United Future
✕ Failed
49
Aye
–
71
No
1 absent
21 Mar 2012
·
New clause 5B Section 20A amended
·
Party vote
That the amendment be agreed to
Aye:
Green Party, Mana, New Zealand Labour
—
No:
ACT New Zealand, Māori Party, New Zealand First, New Zealand National, United Future
✕ Failed
49
Aye
–
71
No
1 absent
21 Mar 2012
·
Clause 6 Meaning of strike
·
Party vote
That clause 6 be agreed to
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, Māori Party, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
61
Aye
–
59
No
1 absent
21 Mar 2012
·
Clause 7 New sections 82A to 82C inserted
·
Vote type unknown
(question not parsed yet)
🚨 Not parsed (over 14 years ago)
21 Mar 2012
·
Clause 7 New sections 82A to 82C inserted
·
Party vote
That the amendment be agreed to
Aye:
Green Party, Mana, New Zealand Labour
—
No:
ACT New Zealand, Māori Party, New Zealand First, New Zealand National, United Future
✕ Failed
49
Aye
–
71
No
1 absent
21 Mar 2012
·
Clause 7 New sections 82A to 82C inserted
·
Party vote
That clause 7 be agreed to
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, Māori Party, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
61
Aye
–
59
No
1 absent
21 Mar 2012
·
Clause 8 Unlawful strike or lockouts
·
Party vote
That clause 8 be agreed to
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, Māori Party, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
61
Aye
–
59
No
1 absent
21 Mar 2012
·
New clause 9 Transitional provision
·
Party vote
That the amendments to the amendment be agreed to
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, Māori Party, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
61
Aye
–
59
No
1 absent
21 Mar 2012
·
New clause 9 Transitional provision
·
Party vote
That the amendment as amended be agreed to
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, Māori Party, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
61
Aye
–
59
No
1 absent
Tuesday, 20 March 2012
Search and Surveillance Bill
20 Mar 2012
·
Part 3 Enforcement officers’ powers and orders (continued)
·
Party vote
That the question be now put
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, Māori Party, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
64
Aye
–
57
No
20 Mar 2012
·
Part 3 Enforcement officers’ powers and orders (continued)
·
Party vote
That the amendments to the amendments be agreed to
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, Māori Party, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
61
Aye
–
60
No
20 Mar 2012
·
Part 3 Enforcement officers’ powers and orders (continued)
·
Party vote
That the amendments as amended be agreed to
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, Māori Party, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
61
Aye
–
60
No
20 Mar 2012
·
Part 3 Enforcement officers’ powers and orders (continued)
·
Party vote
That the amendments be agreed to
Aye:
Green Party, Mana, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
—
No:
ACT New Zealand, Māori Party, New Zealand National, United Future
✕ Failed
57
Aye
–
64
No
20 Mar 2012
·
Part 3 Enforcement officers’ powers and orders (continued)
·
Party vote
That the amendment be agreed to
Aye:
Green Party, Mana, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
—
No:
ACT New Zealand, Māori Party, New Zealand National, United Future
✕ Failed
57
Aye
–
64
No
20 Mar 2012
·
Part 3 Enforcement officers’ powers and orders (continued)
·
Party vote
That the amendment be agreed to
Aye:
Green Party, Mana, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
—
No:
ACT New Zealand, Māori Party, New Zealand National, United Future
✕ Failed
57
Aye
–
64
No
20 Mar 2012
·
Part 3 Enforcement officers’ powers and orders (continued)
·
Party vote
That Part 3 as amended be agreed to
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, Māori Party, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
61
Aye
–
60
No
20 Mar 2012
·
Part 4 General provisions in relation to search and inspection powers
·
Party vote
That the question be now put
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, Māori Party, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
63
Aye
–
57
No
1 absent
20 Mar 2012
·
Part 4 General provisions in relation to search and inspection powers
·
Party vote
That the amendments as amended and the further amendments be agreed to
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, Māori Party, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
61
Aye
–
59
No
1 absent
20 Mar 2012
·
Part 4 General provisions in relation to search and inspection powers
·
Party vote
That the amendments be agreed to
Aye:
Green Party, Mana, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
—
No:
ACT New Zealand, Māori Party, New Zealand National, United Future
✕ Failed
57
Aye
–
63
No
1 absent
20 Mar 2012
·
Part 4 General provisions in relation to search and inspection powers
·
Party vote
That Part 4 as amended be agreed to
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, Māori Party, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
61
Aye
–
59
No
1 absent
20 Mar 2012
·
Part 5 Amendments, repeals, and miscellaneous provisions
·
Party vote
That the amendments to the amendments be agreed to
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, Māori Party, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
61
Aye
–
59
No
1 absent
20 Mar 2012
·
Part 5 Amendments, repeals, and miscellaneous provisions
·
Party vote
That the amendments as amended be agreed to
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, Māori Party, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
61
Aye
–
59
No
1 absent
20 Mar 2012
·
Part 5 Amendments, repeals, and miscellaneous provisions
·
Party vote
That the amendment be agreed to
Aye:
Green Party, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
—
No:
ACT New Zealand, Māori Party, New Zealand National, United Future
✕ Failed
56
Aye
–
63
No
2 absent
20 Mar 2012
·
Part 5 Amendments, repeals, and miscellaneous provisions
·
Party vote
That Part 5 as amended be agreed to
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, Māori Party, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
61
Aye
–
59
No
1 absent
20 Mar 2012
·
Schedule
·
Party vote
That the amendment to the amendment be agreed to
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, Māori Party, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
61
Aye
–
59
No
1 absent
20 Mar 2012
·
Schedule
·
Party vote
That the amendment as amended be agreed to
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, Māori Party, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
61
Aye
–
59
No
1 absent
20 Mar 2012
·
Clauses 1 and 2
·
Party vote
That clause 1 be agreed to
Aye:
ACT New Zealand, New Zealand National, United Future
—
No:
Green Party, Mana, Māori Party, New Zealand First, New Zealand Labour
✓ Passed
61
Aye
–
59
No
1 absent