Social Security (Modernisation) Amendment Bill
on behalf of the Minister for Social Development and Employment: I move, That the Social Security (Modernisation) Amendment Bill be now read a first time.
The bill makes practical changes to modernise how our welfare system operates. At its heart, this bill is not about changing who gets support; itās about making sure the system delivers that support properly and sustainably.
The Ministry for Social Development (MSD) makes millions of decisions every year. Many are, of course, routine and rules based, but the legislation that governs it has not kept up. That means unnecessary manual processing, duplication, and inconsistency. It also means staff are spending less time supporting people into work and more time on administration, and thatās not good enough for the clients of MSD or taxpayers. This bill fixes that.
New Zealanders expect a welfare system that is fair and accurate, and too often the current system falls short. The use of automated decision-making has increased in recent years to improve efficiency, free up resources, and improve services so the welfare system can be faster and more effective at meeting peopleās needs. In simple terms, business processes are automated when systems are used in place of people to complete actions. These processes are automated decision-making where decisions are made without substantial human involvement. These systems can range from straightforward business rules through to more advanced tools, but the systems in this bill are rules based. They apply clear legislative settings consistently and do not rely on discretion. These are straightforward, common-sense changes aimed at improving efficiency and clarity while maintaining fairness and accountability.
The Government is intent on delivering efficiencies in the public service, both for the taxpayer who pays for it and for the end user who interacts with it. Through public service reform and bills like this one, the Government is ensuring the public service keeps pace with modern innovations, ensuring taxpayers benefit from technological advancement. Itās about public service that grows smarter, not larger. It means a public service that is modern, productive, financially sustainable, and focused on front-line delivery.
The bill has four key objectives: it will, firstly, enable a more efficient and modern welfare system through appropriate use of automated decision-making; secondly, it improves consistency and accuracy through updated mandatory reviews; thirdly, it requires medical evidence where appropriate for medical benefits; and lastly, it will clarify the process when a child turns 18 and is included in a caregiverās benefit.
Iāll now turn briefly to each of those four points. MSD already uses automated decision-making in limited areas, but there is no explicit general authority to use it across the system. This bill introduces that authority. The bill is about using technology sensibly. Automated decision-making will be used for simple rules-based decisions and human judgement will remain where it is needed. Clients will be advised of any decision and will be able to seek review. This is about freeing up staff so they can have high-value conversations with people about getting off the benefit and into work. Importantly, this bill strengthens automated decision-making safeguards in law, requiring MSD to ensure these systems address risks such as bias and discrimination, legal and policy compliance, fraud, transparency, human oversight, and assurance. It will mean, also, that MSD is required to consult not only the Privacy Commissioner but also the human rights commissioner and other relevant groups to ensure the interests of vulnerable communities are properly considered. The bill enables MSD to use automated decision-making where appropriate, with safeguards in place, and that means faster decisions, more consistency, and a system people can trust.
I want to now turn to the mandatory reviews. Mandatory reviews play an important role in checking that people receiving assistance remain eligible and are paid the correct rate. They help maintain confidence in the welfare system and support its financial sustainability, as well as reduce over or underpayments to people, avoiding the unnecessary creation of debt. The bill expands the range of benefits that are subject to mandatory reviews, including certain domestic and overseas benefits and childcare assistance. It also updates and refines review settings to ensure they are applied consistently and in keeping with the intent of income support. In a number of cases, the bill introduces clearer expectations around the information that must be confirmed, and these changes help ensure that the assistance is targeted to those who are genuinely eligible, while streamlining the process for clients.
The next area I want to raise with the House relates to medical reviews. For medical benefits, eligibility depends on up-to-date medical information. Over time, existing settings have not always provided sufficient clarity about when medical evidence must be provided or renewed. This bill clarifies that where appropriate, clients must provide a medical certificate or other medical evidence before a medical benefit is granted or continues when existing medical coverage ends. At the same time, the bill recognises that peopleās circumstances can be complex. It allows for extensions or deferrals in exceptional circumstances, ensuring the system remains flexible and responsive. MSD will also continue to have discretion to require an assessment by a prescribed health practitioner if a personās eligibility is unclear.
The next area I want to focus on is the end of school year review process. The bill clarifies the process for when a clientās dependent child turns 18. MSD will be required to exclude a child from a caregiverās benefit when the child turns 18 unless the caregiver confirms, and MSD is satisfied, that the child is still financially dependent and in school or tertiary education. MSD will continue to support caregivers who have 18-year-olds in their care who are still in education. In those cases, the child can continue to be included until the earlier of: them becoming financially independent, leaving education, or 31 December in the year they turn 18. The bill includes clear notice requirements, so caregivers have time to respond and provide information before changes take effect and this improves transparency, certainty, and consistency.
In conclusion, some aspects of mandatory reviews, medical reviews, and the end of school year processes will be supported by automated decision-making. This is only for established rules-based processes where automated decision-making reduces delay and administrative effort without compromising fairness. Taken together, these changes support a welfare system that does what itās meant to do: provide help to those who need it, while being financially sustainable, efficient, and consistent. They also support MSD staff by reducing unnecessary manual processing and allowing more time to be spent supporting people with complex needs who have barriers to work or who are in challenging life circumstances.
We in the Government believe that people who genuinely need support should receive it, and, equally, we believe the system should be clear, consistent, and modern so it works well for clients, for staff, and for taxpayers alike. Thatās what this bill is designed to achieve, and therefore I commend it to the House.
ASSISTANT SPEAKER (Greg O'Connor): The question is the motion be agreed to.
Mr Speaker, thank you, and I want toāIāve just heard a shout-out from Ricardo MenĆ©ndez March and heās going to talk about, I anticipate, the Australian example here of automation, and so is Priyanca Radhakrishnan. So Iām going to leave that alone, but Iām going to talk through my concerns as they are at this point, and again, I point out this is coming through a system where we just wonāt have proper scrutiny of this bill.
I went to the regulatory impact statement (RIS), which weāve all got, and it told its own story. This is what it says when you get to the bit which says, āWhat is the policy problem or opportunity?ā Paragraph six says: There are two aspects of the problem. Paragraph seven says: This has been deleted due to legal privilegeāis the basic gist. So Iām not allowed to know what the two aspects of the problem are. And eight is also largely redacted. It just has one single line and then it has a line saying: officials have categorised these processes covered in the RIS into three groups: mandatory reviews, end of school processes, and medical reviews. Everything else is absolutely locked out.
Now, I used my imagination and I thought, what could the possible legal privilege be around not telling me what the problem was? I thought, well, it could be that perhaps the Ministry of Social Development have been acting in this way without the law behind them. That is the only thing that I can think of that would allow that to be privileged; that thereās been some illegal act or some risk of one. Other than that, I really donāt know. I genuinely am not informed by the RIS as to what the nature of the problem weāre fixing today is. It puts us in a terrible position. It continues, by the wayāthereās a whole lot of grey in this. It is very, very difficult to know what is going on here.
Now, I can tell you what people are saying and it puts this in perspective, because what we have here is a bill that automates, but it also requires medical examinations, and it requires them of people who are quite vulnerable. It has an ability to do that withoutāwhere, really, theyāve got no choice. If weāre real, they have got no choice. Those things, for ordinary people, are quite frightening because they lose the autonomy they have over their own life. They do worry about automation in this day and age because they lose the human connection that we all rely on instinctively, because there will now be automated decision-making.
We know that we associate that with a sort of George Orwell - style world. We know thatāthatās not like hidden wisdom; thatās the reality. Thatās how people feel. They feel totally overwhelmed in a society where they cannot connect with another human being to talk through an issue in that way. People do have a lot of distrust around these things, and theyāre right to. Theyāre right to expect human contact to be part of our system.
So while I see enormous advantages in the technology thatās comingāthis sea change of technologyāIād be cautious about this. Iād be absolutely cautious about this because youāre talking about the very group of people who are most disconnected. Itās very, very important that we safeguard that connection between the people who are most vulnerable and the systems we put in place, which either provide a safety net or further alienate them. That is my concern here, that we are looking at a movement that is dehumanising, and we donāt even know what the problem is, do we? Because no one will tell us. Thank you,
Thank you so much, Mr Speaker. This is a Government handing out the power to an automated decision-maker to effectively make decisions over peopleās livelihoods, over peopleās ability to survive, and over peopleās ability to keep a roof over their headāand you donāt need to believe me, Mr Speaker; you can just read the bill. In fact, in the explanatory note, it says, āThe Bill enacts a general authorising provision that enables MSD to approve the use of an automated electronic system by a specified person to make any decision, exercise any power, comply with any obligation, or take any other related action under any specified provisionā. Now, weāve had the Government telling us previously that, you know, automatic decision-making was only going to be used for very narrow things. Yet no matter what the Government says, if you look at this bill, thereās a carte blanche expansion to basically allow a robotāa machineāto have power over peopleās lives.
Now, the previous member referenced it, and I was going to comment on the Australian system of Robodebt. In fact, yeah, this does remind me of Robodebt or other automated systems overseas that have been an absolute failureābeyond failures; they have actually cost peopleās lives. People died in Australia because of automated systems that ruined peopleās lives and made mistakes, put people into debt, and it literally drove people to suicide.
Itās extremely concerning that we have a bill under urgency where the Minister did not make any proper announcements. All we know, though, is that this Government wants to use automation to get rid of thousands and thousands of jobs. When I see the bill, and when I see the regulatory impact statement that has most of itāor the bits that actually would make us wiser about this billāredacted, all this leads me to believe is that weāre none the wiser about the true intentions of the Minister for Social Development and Employment and the Government when it comes to automated decision-making.
I am extremely concerned that this is bypassing a select committee process. I think itās ironic that the regulatory impact statement (RIS) itself assumed there was going to be a committee process. In fact, on page 3, when it talks about limitations on consultation, thereās even a line that says, āthe Select Committee process will provide opportunity for wider consultation and input from the public.ā This is not happening. We will not have this. We will not be able to have input from the public or from officials to understand the scope and the intention from the Minister of exactly just how much he intends to use automated decision-making. For example, when the bill gives the ability for automated decision-making to have power over basically anything in the Act, I have questions about whether this will be intended to be used for things like the delivery of hardship grants for food, which is one of the lifelines that allows people to survive. Will this be used to actually replace jobs at the contact centre, and then, basically, automate those with an automated decision-maker? What exactly is the Governmentās intent? If it is narrow, why would they give the power to the ministry to use it forāand, again, I quoteāāany decision, exercise any power, comply with any obligationā. Thatās a huge expansion of powers over what automated decision-making could be used for.
I share the concerns that perhaps part of the bill and part of the reason why the regulatory impact statement is so redacted, is because the ministry may have been acting unlawfully. Again, you donāt have to believe me, you can just look at the regulatory impact statement. One of the few bits that wasnāt redacted, on page 27, is around one of the options being considered, and one of the questions was around using automated decision-making to request the subsequent medical certificate. The RIS asks, āWill this option be feasible to implement?āāshould we be doing it to begin with? The answer to it was, well, actually, āAs this option is already current practice, no operational changes would need to be made.ā OK, great. We know that the Ministry of Social Development (MSD) has already been using automated decision-making to ask people for subsequent medical certificates and this is just simply legalising operations that were already happening that quite likely could have been unlawful.
A select committee would have provided clarity from the Minister and from officials about whether MSD had been acting unlawfully. Just recently, we had a bill with a really short select committee process that was trying to address exactly that. So why is the Government pushing this through urgency during Budget week, with no scrutiny, and massively handing out peopleās livelihoods to automated decision-making under the guise of what, cutting jobs, ruining peopleās lives, making peopleās lives harder? All I know is that if a beneficiary doesnāt show up to an appointment when they have an obligation, they get sanctioned, but it seems that very same standard does not apply to Ministers that do not show up to explain what their intentions are for this bill.
Thank you, Mr Speaker. Iām taking this call to support the Social Security (Modernisation) Amendment Bill. The ACT Party is supporting this bill.
As the billās name says, itās about modernisation, and we know that technology is needed to modernise our systems. Automated decision-making is about modernisation of our welfare system. So, yes, it is already used, but we want to make sure that the Ministry of Social Development (MSD) is able to apply it broadly without any legal risks. Just to clarify for the Labour member and the Green member who spoke before: yes, it has been used so far, but we want to make sure that MSD is able to apply it broadly. Of course there will be humans there to help, and if people need any help, they can just go to any MSD office and seek help and talk to a human there. Nobodyās taking that human element out from this bill. This bill also makes it very, very clear that it will be communicated in a very, very transparent manner to the clients how automated decision-making is going to be used. There will be enough of these safeguards. This is to improve efficiency of our systems. Iāll just focus on one change in this bill because I have seen that it has been the focus for Opposition members. The Minister has already talked about the other three changes, and they are good changes. The ACT Party supports this bill. Thank you.
Thank you, Mr Speaker. I rise on behalf of New Zealand First to support the Social Security (Modernisation) Amendment Bill. Firstly, I just want to congratulate the fine finance Minister and Ministers for their responsible Budget that was delivered in this House yesterday. Today, we take a significant step towards a more efficient, modern welfare system that serves both the taxpayer and those in genuine need. On that, I commend the bill to the House.
Itās only right I give rise to the voices of te iwi MÄori today, specifically those who are most affectedānot the only ones affected but the most affectedāby this piece of legislation. This bill claims to modernise welfare, so letās define that based on whatās in the bill. It does modernise things. It modernises suspicion, it modernises surveillance, and it modernises poverty. The most dangerous part is that modernises the removal of humanity from decisions that determine whether our peopleāthe people of Aotearoa, including non-MÄoriāeat, and whether they survive and live with dignity.
Once again, this Government reckons that itās about efficiency. We just heard that word. My question is: efficient for who? For the ministry? For Ministers taking their terrible toki to slash public spending after cutting over 10,000 jobs? Or is it efficient for the mÄmÄ waiting on hold for three hours, trying to prove she is still disabled enough to receive support to survive? This bill expands automated decision-making, artificial intelligence systems and automated electronic systems into the lives of our people. The Minister says there will be safeguards, but weāve heard that beforeāour people have heard that before. We heard it when the ministry unlawfully targeted beneficiaries through debt recovery, we heard it when MÄori were disproportionately sanctioned, and we heard it when whaikaha, our disabled community, were forced repeatedly to prove that they were still disabled. Technology isnāt neutral when the system itself is unequal. Let me repeat that for the people in the back and in the ivory towers: technology is not neutral when the system itself is unequal. The system is biased. The system is corrupt and kino to our people.
Around the world, the evidence is very clear. Automated welfare systems disproportionately harm indigenous peoples, poor people, disabled people, and sole parents. This Government wants to expand mandatory reviews and medical reviews, and they want to expand powers that suspend supportāall while living costs explode. This bill says to a beneficiary, āYouāre guilty until the algorithm says otherwise.ā This is not mana-enhancing, itās not manaaki, and it is far from tika.
It goes without saying that MÄori will carry the burden most heavily because MÄori are over-represented in every category that this bill targets. Thatās why Te PÄti MÄori opposes this bill in its entirety. Mana motuhake cannot exist when our people cannot feed their whÄnau or house their babies or care for their kaumÄtua. Mana Årite cannot exist when Ministers, earning $300,000 a year, lecture beneficiaries surviving on less than $400 a week. Mana mokopuna cannot exist when we normalise replacing workers and case managers with machines that cannot understand trauma, whakapapa, violence, addiction, or even poverty. A computer cannot see whakamÄ. It cannot see shame. A computer cannot recognise grief. A computer cannot hold compassion. Only people can do thatāwell, some of us.
The Welfare Expert Advisory Group, already told us what dignity looks like. They said that whakamana tÄngata restores dignity to social securityānot punishment, not surveillance, and not automated suspicion. This Government ignored that advice. Instead of doubling benefits in line with the advisory groupās recommendations, theyāre building a digital gatekeeping system around survival itself. Donāt even get me started on the medical-review provisions.
Whaikaha, the disabled community of Aotearoa, are exhausted. Chronically ill people are exhausted. WhÄnau caring for disabled tamariki are exhausted, but this bill is creating more hoops, more forms, and more opportunities to lose support, because paperwork expires or because the Ministry of Social Development wants a second opinion from a preferred health practitioner. Preferred by who? Certainly not by the communities who have repeatedly told this Government that they donāt trust systems that already fail them. This bill is not reform; it is retrenchment disguised as technology. History teaches us that when Governments talk about efficiency in welfare systems, MÄori communities pay the price. We oppose this bill.
Thank you, Mr Speaker. This bill says where medical coverage expires, youāre required to bring a new medical certificate before Ministry of Social Development can grant a continuation of a medical benefit. Therefore, I commend it to the House.
Today is a shameful day. It is a day when, once again, this cruel Government is using urgency in the Budget process to make a fundamental shift away from the values of this country and this Parliament. In 1938, when Michael Joseph Savage brought in the Social Security Act, it was predicated on the need for Christianity in practice. It recognised that anyone in their life could experience hardship, and it recognised explicitly, in those Hansard debates, that providing that judgment of who needed help was to be done in a humane and dignified way and not subject to mathematical algorithms. The same debate was had in 2018 when there was a pulling together of the legislation. People recognised that automation was on the horizon, and yet they also recognised that there was a matter of dignity and human judgment in the ability to access welfare first and take people out of hardship and then require the compliance and evidence. That was a humane thing to do.
My family benefited from that. My father was born in 1936, and in 1942, his mum, struggling to bring up six kids on her own, had to endure the house burning down. They would have been destitute on the street, but my father and his family lived in one of the first social welfare houses. My fatherās dad tragically died when he was 14, and as a resultāluckily or, perhaps, unluckily, whichever way you look at itāmy father was able to go to university on a scholarship, which none of his brothers and sisters were able to do. My father became a doctor, and he lifted our house and our household out of poverty. He contributed taxes all his life, and he gave us the best start because of that safety net.
What we are seeing now is a turn-around that would not enable that to be possible, because of the cruel compliance and the automation that is designed to save this Government money so they can make their Budget add up. When we looked at the Budget fiscals yesterday, the large majority of the cuts to the fiscals is coming from the Ministry of Social Development (MSD). The automation is their way to replace the many, many staff that will be lost on the front line, the many staff who would be able to take into account the circumstances and make rational, intelligent judgments about what needs to happen to keep people safe and well and make sure that compliance is occurring.
That has been wiped away because this Government ridiculously thinks that automation and artificial intelligence is going to solve the problem. Well, how did that work in Australia? It resulted in a cover-up. It resulted in hardship. You know what? This Government knows that, but they donāt care because they are very, very happy to kick the disabled community to the curb. They do not have the experience or the vision or even want to see sections of our community who should not have to turn up time after time after time to present medical certificates.
What about my friend Charlotte Cleverley-Bisman, the young woman who suffered meningococcal as a baby, who has no arms and no legs, who is an outstanding young woman, and whose mother does an incredible job? Why should she have to turn up with the indignity every year of being required a medical certificate to say that she has a disability? Why should somebody, now, through an automated system, require that she go to a specialist or a doctor to prove that she has a disability? What possible function does that serve?
Letās look at what this terrible bill prescribes. It sees that people will be directed to certain practitioners appointed by MSD. Well, weāve seen what happens under ACC when that happens. Weāve seen how fair that system is. I can tell you: legislatively, with the drafting of this terrible bill clause by clause, it is a terrible piece of lawmaking. It lumps everything in together, it creates regulatory powers that are an absolute overreach of what the extension is designed to be, and I wholeheartedly agree with Helen White: the only possible explanation for the fact that the problem is redacted is because, probably, this is what MSD is already doing. We want to scrutinise this fully. Thereās been no select committee, the regulatory impact statement is damning, it says that disabled communities will be impacted, that MÄori have not been consulted and will be impacted. We need to do this for the shameful decision making of this Government.
Thank you, Mr Speaker. Look, this bill, the Social Security (Modernisation) Amendment Bill, supports a welfare system that does what it is meant to do: provide help to those who need it, while being financially sustainable, efficient, and consistent. As a result, I commend it to the House.
Thank you, Mr Speaker. This is a bill that is unnecessarily cruel. Itās punitive, and itās absolutely out of touch. It smacks of a Government that is out of touch both with the realities that those who are struggling face, but also the realities of this very move overseas that is proven to be harmful to the very communities that it aims to, or purports to, serve.
I donāt understand why weāre here debating this, yet again, in Budget urgency. This is the second part of a bill that we debated under Budget urgency last year. This expands the targeted ability that the Ministry of Social Development (MSD) has had to automate decisions, and it opens it upāwholesaleāto virtually any decision that MSD is allowed to make. This is in the context of a Budget that is going to cut an additional almost 9,000 jobs, and a Government that wants to replace those social workers, support workers, and people who protect our borders, with artificial intelligence. Thatās really what this bill also boils down to. It is within the context of 82 percent of households with a disabled person facing food insecurity in the last one year. Itās in the context of cuts to the Total Mobility scheme that will increase transport costs for disabled people, and 27,000 disabled people who live in social housing who will see their rents increase. What does this Budget and this bill do? It makes life even worse for all of them.
I also want to say thatāsomething that was stark in the departmental disclosure statement was the fact that this bill will return $158 million of savings. So not only does the Budget make life worse for those who are already struggling, but theyāre making savings off the back of those people who are struggling. All of that is just from kicking off 18-year-olds from caregivers benefits. Incredibly cruel. Now, what does this bill actually do? As my colleague Helen White has pointed out, so much that should have been in the regulatory impact statement is actually redacted. So we donāt see the most egregious bits of this, but itās an absolute overreach of the State into the lives of people and into the livelihoods of people as well.
Iāll touch very quickly on this experiment in Australia, which has led to a very good letter that was written by, I think itās the chair of the Australian Neurodivergent Parents Association, where they make the point that this isnāt actually just a conversation between human intervention and automated decision-making; itās actually about improving a fundamentally flawed system that doesnāt allow for independent, genuine decision-making, just genuine discretion, on the part of decision makers, whether human or automated. The reason that this bill is so dangerous is because it takes us even further away from genuine discretion and makes the problem even worse.
Theyāve said here, and I absolutely agree, that āAutomated and highly standardised decision making systems are also recognised as potentially brittle within complex human environments involving disability, trauma, fluctuating capacity, poverty, cultural difference, and intersecting disadvantage. Unlike human decision makers exercising genuine discretion, automated or semi-automated systems may struggle to appropriately account for nuance, context, atypical presentations, or cumulative disadvantage. This creates significant risk of rigid or mechanistic outcomes that fail to reflect the realities of individual lives.ā It also goes on to make the point that it, in a very dangerous manner, ārisks entrenching bias and discrimination against specific groups of people.ā All of those groups of people who were not consulted on this change; where we are pushing through change, in all stages in urgency, that will allow MSD to reach into the lives of people, require them to get medical reviewsāby a health system that is already stretchedātime and time again, but with doctors picked by MSD.
The level of State overreach represented in this legislation is horrifying and it is disproportionate to what we need. The fact that we are debating this under all stages in urgency is particularly egregious. What is also egregious is members opposite who just stand up and say, āThis is just about modernisation. Nothing to see here. This is not going to change peopleās lives.ā as though itās not going to take away a huge amount of income from people who are already struggling.
Thank you, Mr Speaker. Look, as weāve heard in the Budget yesterday, this is all about securing our future, and a social security system needs to be sustainable. That is exactly what this bill aims to address. I commend it to the House.
A party vote was called for on the question, That the Social Security (Modernisation) Amendment Bill be now read a first time.
Ayes 67
New Zealand National 48; ACT New Zealand 11; New Zealand First 8.
Noes 55
New Zealand Labour 34; Green Party of Aotearoa New Zealand 15; Te PÄti MÄori 4; Ferris; Kapa-Kingi.
Motion agreed to.
Bill read a first time.
š¬ SPEAKER: This bill is set down for second reading immediately.
Second Reading
š£ļø Spoke in this debate (11)
- Jamie Arbuckle (New Zealand First Party ā List Member)
- Carl Bates (New Zealand National Party ā Member for Whanganui)
- Oriini Kaipara (MÄori Party ā Member for TÄmaki Makaurau)
- Dana Kirkpatrick (New Zealand National Party ā Member for East Coast)
- Ingrid Leary (New Zealand Labour Party ā Member for Taieri)
- Ricardo MenĆ©ndez March (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand ā List Member)
- Katie Nimon (New Zealand National Party ā Member for Napier)
- Parmjeet Parmar (ACT New Zealand ā List Member)
- Hon Priyanca Radhakrishnan (New Zealand Labour Party ā List Member)
- Hon Scott Simpson (New Zealand National Party ā Member for Coromandel)
- Helen White (New Zealand Labour Party ā Member for Mount Albert)