🧪 EXPERIMENTAL / ALPHA — this is an independent prototype, not an official record. Data may be incomplete or wrong - always check the linked Hansard source before relying on it.
Hot Air

Thursday, 28 May 2026

Social Security (Modernisation) Amendment Bill

Third Reading
HansardID: 8d9fb96d-02de-076a-0649-bdb14c97cd3c
Back to debates
✏️ Hansard still marked this day's transcript "Draft" as of our last import - it may since have been corrected or finalised upstream. Check the official transcript if anything here looks off.
🗣️ Speech Hon Louise Upston (New Zealand National Party — Member for Taupō)
Time unknown

I move, That the Social Security (Modernisation) Amendment Bill be now read a third time.

This bill amends the Social Security Act and the associated regulations to improve the way the system is administered, introducing changes that support more efficient processes and more consistent decision making. It delivers a system that better reflects how services are expected to be delivered in a modern environment.

The bill enables the Ministry of Social Development to use automated decision making, where appropriate, to make routine decisions. It strengthens key administrative settings, including mandatory reviews, clarifies requirements for medical evidence, and sets out a clearer framework for the treatment of a caregiver’s benefit when a dependent child turns 18.

These changes are expected to improve the overall operation of the system, reduce administrative burden, and allow staff to focus more of their time supporting more people to move from welfare into work. These changes will come into force in stages, allowing time for systems and processes to be updated to support their implementation.

This is a practical and measured set of improvements. It strengthens the administration of the system while maintaining its core purpose. I commend the bill to the House.

🗣️ Speech Helen White (New Zealand Labour Party — Member for Mount Albert)
Time unknown

Thank you. It has been a long day, and this bill has taken a long time to get to this stage. It is late at night, and I want to get to the guts of what I have learnt about this bill in the interim.

I started by reading the regulatory impact statement (RIS), and I was dismayed by seeing something I’d never seen before, which was the redacted contents regarding the problem that we faced. I just want to explain why that concerns me. What we had was a RIS that says the problem, and then it says, “There are two aspects of the problem.” Then there are nine lines redacted, so I have absolutely no idea what aspect No. 1 is. It then goes on to say, “Options to address the issue of clear legislative authority with appropriate safeguards are covered in Section 2.1 of this RIS.” I can only guess what aspect No. 1 of the problem was, because it has got to be something that was legally privileged in order to be redacted.

It then goes on to talk about, “Secondly, MSD is currently using ADM for some processes that contain discretionary decisions.” And then we have another redaction. It’s another four lines of redaction on what the second aspect of the problem is. I simply get told, “Officials have categorised these processes covered in this RIS into three groups: Mandatory Reviews, End of School Year process, and Medical Reviews”. Then, guess what, more redactions, so I am not very much wiser.

It then talks about an opportunity to deal with this two-part legislative solution, but then we have two paragraphs of redactions. I start at a real disadvantage in the Opposition doing my job. How can I do my job when I don’t understand the problem? I appreciate there have been officials sitting here all night, and they have been sitting here, hopefully, with more information on that than I have got, but people’s time has been wasted because we can’t do our job properly. I am concerned that something is awry here—that something of legal concern is the reason we are here tonight—and I have no idea what it is, and that is of concern to me.

Now, I want to talk about what I saw as the day went on. I saw the impact it might have on certain groups—these decisions that were being made—and the Minister was happy to tell us over and over again that nothing was happening here, that it was simply an automation of what was already there, but that didn’t square with what I heard in the evidence and what I read in the various sections. The first thing I noticed was with regard to people who will be sole parents on benefits, because, when their children turned 18, they were going to automatically drop off having any benefit for that child. While that has actually been the case in the case of a child who has not been in education, there has always been a safety net there for that child until now. That child who is looking for work at 18 has been able to get support from this Government, and they can’t anymore.

I realised that one of the things that is happening tonight is that we are ingraining the idea that someone on a benefit who has very little to start with is now going to be responsible for a child if they are unemployed. We know that unemployment is through the roof. It is not the fault of that family or that student or that solo parent that it is so hard for that particular age group to find work at the moment. We know that’s true. We know—we all know—kids at that age who have been looking for work, and they’ve applied and applied and applied and they haven’t got it. There are often reasons for that. They’re good kids. Some of them might be difficult kids—teenagers are—but they’re good kids, and what we’re saying to parents who have got so little financial ability to support those children is, “Tough, you will be doing that from now on. In addition to the other poverty that you have to face, you will be responsible for that 18-year-old, because they’re going to have nowhere to go.” This piece of legislation was, I realised, related to the other one, and that was being skated over—absolutely skated over.

Then what I noticed was the issue about medical certificates. What I saw was a system where medical certificates could be demanded. Now, we heard that what we’re going to do with those is that we can do them any time but, actually, the person involved will help choose the person who does that. Medical examinations are actually extremely invasive of privacy; they’re quite a big deal. They’re quite often really intimate, and I don’t want just anybody to do them. I would be pretty careful about that, but we’re told, “The taxpayer has got this right.” What that system looks like it does is say that, ultimately, MSD gets to choose who is going to be the person who examines you. You may get a list, and there may be some element of choice, but if MSD doesn’t like your choice, they will decide.

Carmel Sepuloni stood up and asked some really good questions about that. She asked, “Where is the criteria? Where are we making sure that (a) you’re being reasonable about when you want those medical certificates, and (b) that there is criteria around who can do those examinations, and why?” Where are those things? And we were told nothing, crickets; we don’t have a good indication of safeguards around something that is a big deal. It is a big deal to do medical examinations on people, and it needs a whole process of caution around it. It needs that. That’s got nothing to do with modernisation, by the way, has it? Nothing at all. This bill might be called a modernisation, we might be told there is nothing to see here, but none of the things I have talked about tonight has to do with modernisation. It’s not about that; it’s about making things more difficult for people going through the process.

I also noticed that there was an absolute prohibition on staff creating solutions in difficult situations—temporary amounts of money. Temporary granting couldn’t happen—temporary grants—even if you could see there was a problem in front of you. Say you’ve got someone with mental health issues in front of you and you clearly know they’re not going to be able to work, but, no, you’ve got to send them off to some specialist before you can say yay or nay, and, in the meantime, what do they do? Do they, by any chance, sleep in their car? I think that’s the likely outcome.

If you take away the humanity in the system and if you take away the discretions, don’t come and tell me that this is just simply a modernisation. If people are doing that, then they need to accept that that’s what they’re doing. If Ministers are making those decisions to reduce the number of people that are able to, actually, access our safety net, then that at least should be an honest conversation. We should know that, and people should know that. They shouldn’t just bump into the barriers as they’re put up in front of them—a solo mother who has an 18-year-old child and who’s looking for work in an economic recession—yes, let’s face it—where her kid is very unlikely to even be able to get a job at McDonald’s. That solo mother should know that she’s not facing a modernisation; she’s facing a cruel Government that’s made some decisions that are based on judging her harshly and telling her that she has got to be more responsible, rather than accepting that responsibility belongs to us all. I’m proud of the safety net. I’m sorry about this piece of legislation.

ASSISTANT SPEAKER (Maureen Pugh): The question is that the motion be agreed to.

🗣️ Speech Ricardo Menéndez March (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand — List Member)
Time unknown

This bill is brought forward under urgency with no public scrutiny by the same Government whose Prime Minister called beneficiaries “bottom feeders”; by the same Government who has left thousands of low-income homeowners $42 a week worse off; by the same Government who is leaving 14,000 people who have boarders $100 a week worse off, in some cases; by the same Government who is leaving thousands of State housing tenants on average $32 a week worse off; by a Government that boasts about a record number of benefit sanctions, and by a Government that is entrenching debts for sexual violence survivors who needed a benefit before receiving ACC payments.

This is a bill that does damage, and I always can tell what a bill does by what the Minister has chosen to omit. This is not the first time that the most problematic components of a bill have been left out in the Minister’s speeches. I remember when we were discussing the bill, that I mentioned earlier, that left 14,000 people worse off. The Minister didn’t mention that once in her contribution. You know what else the Minister didn’t mention in her contribution about this bill? One of the key paragraphs in the explanatory note in front of us says that this bill allows “MSD to approve the use of an automated electronic system by a specified person to make any decision, exercise any power, comply with any obligation, or take any other related action under any specified provision,”.

This bill is a massive expansion of the powers that automated decision-makers have over our lives. It gives powers to machines to make decisions over whether people can survive. The Minister has not adequately justified why this bill needed to be brought under urgency as part of the Budget legislation. We are none the wiser about why there is a rush to give the Ministry of Social Development (MSD) such sweeping powers, but what we do know, from the regulatory impact statement that we have had, which is one of the few documents in front of us that we have to scrutinise this bill, is that there’s an admission that MSD was already using automated decision-making for requesting a subsequent medical certificate for disabled people, despite actually not being allowed to do so under the law. The regulatory impact statement was assessing whether anything would change by expanding automated decision-making powers to be able to do this and, basically, said, “Well, the ministry’s already doing it.”, and then it has a bunch of stuff redacted in it.

This leaves me wondering whether MSD has been acting unlawfully and using automated decision-making for things that it wasn’t legally allowed to do. It wouldn’t be the first time—not even in this year—that MSD was found to be acting unlawfully by putting, for example, debts on people, like sexual violence survivors who needed benefit before requiring ACC, as I mentioned earlier. What is extremely problematic about this bill is that it got brought forward as part of the Budget under urgency and, as I said, with zero public scrutiny. We didn’t even get to hear from the ministry why the Privacy Commissioner had concerns about this bill. I think it’s actually such an essential part of this. If we’re giving such huge powers to machines over people’s lives, I would like to know why the Privacy Commissioner had concerns about this bill.

In a working and adequate democracy, we would have afforded this bill the select committee process so that the public could give their views about whether they actually want to hand over their ability to make ends meet in the welfare system to a machine. We didn’t even get reassurances from the Minister as to whether she would be allowing, in the future, MSD to actually make decisions on things like food grants and on things like granting other types of emergency assistance that allows people to keep all the roof over their head, to have access to prescription medicine, and to have access to the things that they need to do well in order to survive. We did not get adequate engagement from the Minister on any of this. All we got told, in a patronising manner, was that this is not changing any benefit entitlements and that this dismissal—and, I would say, almost pretending—that this bill isn’t doing anything significant. Well, if it is not, then why the rush? Why the rush? We were never told or given adequate justification of this.

What this bill does do is add additional requirements on what needs to be on a medical certificate so that people who are on a jobseeker benefit can move on to a jobseeker medical or supported living payment. We had a debate about, for example, why it is that the Ministry of Social Development could, effectively, compel a beneficiary to go to a specific doctor that the ministry chooses for them, and we didn’t get any adequate answers. I find it extremely problematic that people struggling to survive could be compelled to go to a doctor of the ministry’s choice, as opposed to someone they trust, someone they have a relationship with, and someone that they believe will treat them or their family members or the people that they care for with the respect and dignity that they deserve. Why do we need to hand the power to the ministry to be able to basically choose for someone else the kind of medical assistance that they can receive to, for example, get a diagnosis to be able to qualify for a benefit that has higher income support and, more importantly, no work obligations? It’s almost as if the Minister wants disabled people to stay on the benefits that have sanctions and that have obligations so that she’s able to kick them out of income support to meet her target of 50,000 people less on the benefit.

This bill is a punch-down approach to disabled people. We need a high-trust model for disabled people. We need income support that allows disabled people to live well and to be able to fully participate in their communities. Across other fiscal decisions that the Government has made, we’ve seen how they have already deprioritised support for disabled people and done the exact opposite—create more barriers for them to do well. This bill simply continues to entrench this. This is a pattern of behaviour, by both the Minister and the members of the Government, of not supporting beneficiaries’ right to a life with dignity and also of lacking acknowledgment—for all the talk of the Minister and the Prime Minister asking young people to get a job, there’s no acknowledgment that there’s just not enough jobs out there. This is a Government that has focused on cutting jobs and then punishing the unemployed after cutting those very same jobs that, for example, graduates could have gone into.

This bill has not been given any good reason to be put forward here, as I said, without any adequate scrutiny. This does tell me that this is part of the broader narrative that the Government has of pretending like automation is the pathway to freedom. At the same time, they are not addressing the fundamental basics—like people having access to affordable housing, adequate healthcare, and the tax system that actually taxes work less and taxes wealth more, as it should. Workers are already struggling as they are, despite being the very same people who hold up the economy, and many people on the benefits are the people who are supporting our community organisations and the food banks that are actually feeding the people who do not have the means to survive.

Once again, this bill just simply does nothing genuinely to modernise our welfare system. All it does is it gives power to a machine to make decisions over people’s lives, and that is extremely dangerous. The regulation-making powers that are in this bill could allow this or a future Minister to massively expand how automated decision-making is used. Yep, right now it’s used for a relatively narrow set of issues in this bill, but, in fact, we have already heard feedback from disabled people that they have already, as I said earlier, been asked for a subsequent medical certificate despite, as it stands right now, that not being a legal thing that is allowed to be done under automated decision-making. I think this is something that members of the Green Party will be keeping a close eye on, because we suspect that there’s something extremely dodgy happening under the process of this bill, and the reasons why this bill was brought forward under urgency with no public scrutiny haven’t, I think, been genuinely and transparently communicated by omission. We hear, “There’s nothing to see in this bill; this bill doesn’t change much”, and yet we’re hearing, “We’ve got to rush it on Budget week. And hey, by the way, we’re going to save $55 million from benefit entitlements at the same time”. When I queried the fact that this will actually produce savings and will take money away from beneficiaries, the Minister was not able to give me a breakdown of where exactly that money was going to come from, and whether that money was going to come from people who are going to be put in an even more difficult position to survive.

The Green Party will continue campaigning and fighting for a welfare system that allows people to fully participate in their communities, to see the dignity in each other, and just stop treating our neighbours as the enemy. This is not a race between the left and the right in our communities; this is a fight against those at the top and the rest of us, and this Government would rather pit us against our unemployed neighbour whose job the Government just cut. It’s a race to the bottom, to create an economy that is based on low wage jobs, that is not actually about improving productivity or whatever bumper sticker the Government want to come up with next.

This is the bill that cements the approach of punching down on the people who need our support. The Green Party does not support this bill, and the scrutiny of what this bill is genuinely about is absolutely not over. We’ll be keeping a close eye on the Minister’s approach to automated decision-making for the months to come until we change this Government on 7 November.

🗣️ Speech Parmjeet Parmar (ACT New Zealand — List Member)
Time unknown

Thank you, Madam Speaker. I’m taking this call on behalf of ACT to support the Social Security (Modernisation) Amendment Bill. Actually, I’m not surprised to see that the Greens are against the use of technology. Yeah, I’m not surprised at all.

So there were just two points in that speech. One point was they don’t like technology—the use of technology. And the second point the member made is the use of the ministry’s choice of medical services to provide medical reviews, and I want to very quickly respond to these things because we have had a really good committee of the whole House.

The first thing I want to say is this: no matter how clear the facts are, these facts don’t suit your political narrative on that side—I know that you don’t want to accept these facts. The second point: this concept of the ministry’s choice of medical review, getting the medical review done from the outlet that is approved by the Ministry, is not a new concept because the ministry of immigration already provides a list of approved doctors, those who do the medicals for people who apply for immigration. So it’s not a new concept. So it’s a good bill and the ACT Party supports this bill. Thank you.

🗣️ Speech Jamie Arbuckle (New Zealand First Party — List Member)
Time unknown

Thank you, Madam Speaker. I rise on behalf of New Zealand First to support the Social Security (Modernisation) Amendment Bill in its third reading. And today, we have taken a significant step—

💬 Dr Lawrence Xu-Nan: Tell us about “New Zealand Last”.

—a significant step, for the side opposite me—towards a more efficient, modern, wealthier system that serves both the taxpayers and those in genuine need.

💬 Dr Lawrence Xu-Nan: Tell us about how much you hate New Zealanders.

We don’t know how much genuine need there is on that side of the House.

We heard about the safeguards that are in place in the committee of the whole House stage. And on that, I will commend the bill to the House.

🗣️ Speech Kahurangi Carter (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand — List Member)
Time unknown

The “Computer Says ‘No’ Bill”. Today, we have debated this Social Security (Modernisation) Amendment Bill through all stages and now we are at the third reading. We’re nearly into 12 hours of debating, and it is really important that we highlight Prime Minister Christopher Luxton’s Government’s use of urgency.

Around the world, there are not many countries where you can pass a whole law, a whole piece of legislation in one day. It usually takes six months for us to get through this process, because there is a reason for this process. It is so we can scrutinise a bill, so that we can have people with lived experience, the people that are actually going to be the most affected by a bill, to have their feedback, to have experts to look at the reports, the analysis from all of the different ministries, from the people that are most affected.

What we have is a bill that we were given yesterday afternoon, which clearly the Government members didn’t read because they didn’t even have the respect to take more than 30-second calls on this bill. This bill is so important. It would have been great to have speeches that were more than 30 seconds that actually looked into this bill and scrutinised it. We did not have one question from the Government members during the committee of the whole House stage around how this bill actually affects the people of Aotearoa. That’s what we do during the select committee stage—a stage that we weren’t able to go through.

It is really disappointing to see that the Government is again using urgency in a way that it was never intended to be used. And so that makes us ask: what is there to hide? Because one of the only reasons that you would use this process is when you have something to hide. That’s why when we see this regulatory impact statement, it is redacted, redacted, redacted. I have never seen a regulatory impact statement that has been so redacted before. What have you got to hide and why have you not been scrutinising this bill?

When we’re in the select committee process, we get to ask questions, we get to go back to officials, we get to really look at the nitty gritty of these bills, and it’s really hard to trust the Minister when she says she’s not making any changes, when she will not engage fully in the committee of the whole House stage. She won’t engage with our questions. In fact, she continues to repeat, “Oh, I’ve been repeating myself. I’m repeating myself.”, while not even answering questions that are being asked. It is disingenuous.

We know that the use of urgency in this term has been used to slash things that benefit disabled people, disabled people whose carers have had their pay equity slashed under this Government. Just last week, we had Disability Support Services come through in response to workers getting paid because the Supreme Court hearing said that they were employees of the Crown. Why not face the people who this bill affects the most by having a select committee?

I want to take a minute to shout out to my Green MP colleagues. We take our job really seriously. When we got this bill yesterday afternoon, we dug into this bill to really understand what it means to the people of Aotearoa. And not only that, other MPs in our team of 15 worked to write hundreds of amendments that would have improved this bill. But not one of those was voted for by this Government because I doubt they even read them. I just want to say to my colleagues, I appreciate you, I’m so proud to be in the Green Party where we take our responsibility to the people of Aotearoa so seriously.

The lack of vision and hope from this Government, from this Budget, is so evident. And you know what? It just leaves space open wide for our party to come in with a bold vision, one that puts kids at the heart of every Government decision. That makes sure that children and families and disabled people who are doing it hard right now know that someone in this Government is actually here for them and actually going to make decisions that make their life better—so that they can turn the lights on, so that they can put food on the table for their children, so that they can have a nice time with their families instead of worrying about where they’re going to live, what this Government is going to bring in tomorrow under urgency that affects their lives and makes it harder for them.

Let’s talk about the child poverty action Act that came into effect and child poverty rates started to fall. But when this Government came on in, they have forced 48,000 more children into hardship than the previous three years, and that was in mid-2025. You—sorry, Madam Speaker; sorry about that—this Government is pushing more children into poverty, and the rates of poverty are greater for Māori kids, for Pacific kids, for disabled kids, for kids who live in a home with a disabled person. The rates are far higher, and this bill does nothing to address it. In fact, it actually makes it harder for disabled people to access a benefit income.

What is it like to be a child that lives in poverty in Aotearoa? A country that has enough for everybody, that has enough for every child to go to school without feeling hungry, for every child to actually have a bed to sleep in. We have enough in this country. So what does it feel like? Well, this morning, the Child Poverty Action Group told us about a survey that they did of year 9 to 12 children. I would implore the Government members to listen to this—listen to the children of Aotearoa, who should be at the heart of this bill, instead of giving power to machines to make decisions about their lives.

That survey of young people asked about what they worried about, and what they worried about was having food on their tables. They worried about having hygiene products—things like shampoo, things like conditioner. I don’t know what it must feel like to go to school feeling smelly. That is what is happening here. The Government is giving away children’s right to dignity by saying, “Hey, you know what? We can just let a computer say no to a medical certificate.”—a medical certificate by a GP.

Now, that’s a slippery slope. If we are looking at the medical profession and we are saying, “Hmm, actually, no, computer says ‘no’. Your medical certificate, no, no, no. We’re actually going to say that you have to go to another doctor, because the computer said ‘no’—the computer said ‘no’.” But what that means for our children is that this Government is entrenching poverty for children into legislation. It is a crying shame that we have not been able to even see why this bill has been brought in, because it is redacted. There are two problems in the regulatory impact statement, and they’re both redacted. How can we actually scrutinise this bill?

We can bring humanity back into the halls of power. That is what the Green Party will always fight for: making sure that we are making laws that ensure that children in New Zealand aren’t living in poverty, instead of giving over control to an automated system. We oppose this bill completely.

🗣️ Speech Catherine Wedd (New Zealand National Party — Member for Tukituki)
Time unknown

This bill is about creating a modern, efficient welfare system that makes practical improvements and reduces administrative burden. Look, I commend this bill to the House.

🗣️ Speech Ingrid Leary (New Zealand Labour Party — Member for Taieri)
Time unknown

It’s not often that I stand up and feel really ashamed in this House about what we have done collectively to our fellow New Zealanders. But this is one of those days that on this side of the House, we have tried and tried to show the Minister and the members opposite, who didn’t engage with the bill before them, what was at stake here. I just want to apologise, really, to our disabled community, to our sole parents, to our carers of disabled people, to young people who are transitioning into adulthood, to recipients of supplementary assistance, and to families caring for vulnerable children. It must have been really difficult for you to sit and listen to the debating today, to see the disdain from the Government members, who couldn’t contribute more than 20 or 30 seconds of their time to what we were looking at before us: a fundamental shift in what we are doing with welfare in New Zealand.

Before I make my next point, I would like to refer to Speaker’s ruling 29/1, which says that although we can’t talk about members being absent from the House, we can do so where there is a suggested or real importance to do so. I would like to say that that was noted today when the Minister in charge was not here for the bill for the first reading and some of the other readings. She did come back for the committee of the whole House stage. I’m really grateful to her for that, because it must have been even worse for those at home to read in the media that the Minister who is putting through this draconian bill—dressed up as automation, dressed up as something around administrative efficiency, that takes away some of their rights and takes away their ability to thrive and takes away their ability to look after people they love—wasn’t even there for the totality of the debate. That is the level of contempt that we have seen in this House. I apologise to the people—“Nothing about us without us.” Sadly, they could not be in the House with us, and they could not be at the select committee to have their voices known and to have their voices heard.

I’m grateful to my colleague the Hon Priyanca Radhakrishnan, who brought some of those voices into the House; to Reuben Davidson, my colleague, who brought another voice of one of the constituents he has dealt with to the House—a harrowing story about somebody who was let down badly—and to the Hon Carmel Sepuloni, who asked really valid questions about what this was going to mean, because she has had the role of being the Minister for Disability Issues. But what we have seen today is just increased hoops for people to jump through in the pretence that the fundamental settings of welfare are not changing.

Instead of being transparent and saying, “Do you know what? We don’t like giving welfare to fellow New Zealanders. We’d rather give money to tobacco companies and to landlords, so we’re just going to take it away.”—that would probably be better than the callousness and the gaslighting of saying, “Oh, no, we’re not changing anything. Nothing to see here. But we’ve got this really long bill, and we are going to just pretend that it doesn’t impact on people’s access to get those benefits.” That’s exactly what we’ve seen.

It’s not just about the disabled community and the other communities I’ve mentioned but the carers—the carers—who are now dependant on the medical certification requirements. We know those carers are some of the hardest-working New Zealanders, who don’t get paid and don’t get recognised for what they do. They do it for love and they get bloody little support for what they do. Every report that has come out has said that we should be moving in the opposite direction—that we should be providing more support, we should be enabling them to navigate the system. How are these people going to be able to support their loved ones and then have to run off and make logistical arrangements and pay further costs to get more medical certificates, which can be required at the drop of a hat for no reasonable cause, just because an automated system required it, and with no apparent safeguards? Because that is what has come out of the debate today.

Everything we asked about the safeguarding was not answered adequately by the Minister. Everything we asked about the medical certificates was not answered adequately. What were the maximum number of requirements that could be made? What were the minimum requirements? Did there need to be reasonable cause? No. The Green member asked many times about the specifications for the medical practitioner or the health practitioner. Finally, towards the end of the debate, it was suddenly revealed that there is a list of Ministry of Social Development preferred providers. That is a fundamental thing for people to realise that, basically, what the Minister has admitted to is the kind of setup we see with ACC, where there are preferred health practitioners who will now be able to make these decisions unilaterally. The only response we got was, “Oh, no, it’ll be sort of a negotiation. It’ll be done in a kumbaya way with the disability people who we are scrutinising. And if we don’t like it, oh well, then we’ll require that.”

These are people with complex medical needs in many cases, with mental health needs in many cases, with particular diagnoses, with particular trajectories of their illness where they can circuit through wellness and unwellness, and the people that know their health status the best are the practitioners they deal with and have for years. That right has now been taken away, and instead the automated system, and then MSD, through their preferred list of suppliers, is going to make that decision. We all know—as an electorate MP, and as any other electorate MP in this House knows—what has happened with ACC and how the burden on those wanting to challenge the system and show their eligibility has played out.

It’s not about having safeguards in the bill. There are none in this bill. It’s not even a legislated standard; it’s an MSD standard. So there are probably fewer protections, I would say, than in the ACC legislation, and we are doing this to New Zealand’s most vulnerable people, least represented people in this House, and doing it callously and with the disdain of the Government members who couldn’t even engage with the material or give the time to the debates or to answer the questions.

It was also done with urgency. It was also done with the excuse of the Budget. There was no need for this to happen through Budget urgency; this could’ve been put to a select committee and done separately. It is important enough. There is no massive urgency to do this unless, as others have said, there is something happening unlawfully at the moment. That does happen from time to time, and sometimes Governments get agreement from the other side of the House, or at least it’s done transparently. Now, I’m not going to say that would’ve happened, but if that was the case and all the legal material was redacted, as was the problem definition in the regulatory impact statement, then there could’ve been some transparency about why we are doing this. But no, there hasn’t been. Instead, we have seen badly drafted legislation, the fettering of discretions; we’ve seen “Henry VIII” - type provisions that are making sweeping powers and putting them into regulation, things that can be expanded.

Really, it’s not just the communities that we’ve talked about tonight who should be worried about this; all New Zealanders should be worried, because what has happened, on the pretext of saying that this is about automating something that’s happening now, is there’s suddenly a whole lot of secondary powers available that can be expanded at any point to any power for any reason when it comes to automating decision making in welfare in New Zealand. That is an absolutely massive change, and I’m so pleased that the media have picked up on it and realised what was being done through sleight of hand under urgency under this Government.

The other thing, though, and probably the worst of it, is why we are doing this. Why are we here in urgency doing this? Really, it is because of the economic mismanagement of this Government. They are trying to dress this up as a value for money proposition. It’s not about value for money, because if people can access support at the right time, ultimately there will be better value for money. We’ve seen the argument about young people who might be pushed out to work because their parents can no longer support them through some kind of training course, some kind of less conventional training course that would upskill them. Suddenly, they don’t have access to that because they are no longer supported through this regime.

This is a Government that does prefer landlords, it does prefer tobacco companies, it does prefer corporate welfare; it doesn’t prefer human welfare. New Zealand is better than this—New Zealand is better than this. We used to be the exemplar globally of what welfare meant. Michael Joseph Savage talked about Christianity in action. Welfare was about dignity and humanity and judgment and recognising that any one of us at any point might need a helping hand from another New Zealander. This sweeping law takes all of that away, and I think that everybody in this House today needs to hang their heads in shame.

🗣️ Speech Dana Kirkpatrick (New Zealand National Party — Member for East Coast)
Time unknown

Thank you, Madam Speaker. Well, this Government is one that welcomes innovation, technology, and advancement, and we should not be afraid in this country of a more efficient, modern welfare system. I commend the bill to the House.

ASSISTANT SPEAKER (Maureen Pugh): Reuben Davidson—this is a split call.

🗣️ Speech Reuben Davidson (New Zealand Labour Party — Member for Christchurch East)
Time unknown

Thank you, Madam Speaker. I am standing to take a call on the Social Security (Modernisation) Amendment Bill and just stand in opposition, because what we have heard over the last few hours as we’ve gone through this bill and examined it very thoroughly is that we have a Government that wants to make life harder for New Zealanders. That’s what we’ve heard. We’ve heard about what the opposite side believe this bill does, and then we’ve heard, actually, as we’ve stepped through it and as we’ve decoded what’s included in the regulatory impact statement, but, more importantly, what’s not able to be seen in that—we can see exactly the impact it will have in our communities.

I spoke in my first contribution about some of the types of issues that people who come and meet with us in person in our electorate office have, and some of the challenges that they have. These are very, very distressing challenges for these people. They need to engage with and deal with people to help them through these processes. But what the Government has said and what the other side of the House have said to us is that they think that this can all be done through an automated system, that this can be done through the use of artificial intelligence (AI).

Now, other speakers have talked about some of the distressing situations that have happened overseas, some of the very real impacts this has had on people’s health, on their mental health, and, in some cases, on their lives, dealing with systems like this. But the Government seems to be intent on cutting jobs in the Public Service—real jobs going—and claiming that AI will simply come to the rescue. Well, AI might be able to come to the rescue in some situations, but you need a plan and you need to have some clues.

Now, I’m going to revisit some of the questions that I asked just last week to the Minister for the Public Service and Digitising Government. I asked the Minister just last week which specific roles he expected to be replaced by artificial intelligence in the Public Service, and the Minister, just last week, said, “Well, that is the process that we will be working our way through over the next three years, and it would be wrong to make any predictions.” Less than a week later, there is a bill introduced to the House in urgency. Did he not know that there was a bill coming? If he did, why did he not explain or talk about, potentially explicitly, that bill that was going to be introduced just the next week?

When I then asked: does he have evidence that shows AI can safely do the roles of the Public Service at scale—and we have heard so many examples of where it hasn’t been able to in people’s contributions in the House today—the Minister said, “Well, it depends on what particular roles one has in mind.” Well, we have heard about what this Government has in mind for the use of AI in this context through this bill, and we have heard about some of the challenges and some of the terrible things that have happened in other countries and in other places when they have tried this.

I asked: does he have a coherent AI workforce plan, especially given that one of his colleagues, Minister Penny Simmonds, had stated that departments can simply work through how to use AI. He said, “Well, all of that is in the process of development.”

But most interestingly, from a Government who are claiming they will save billions of dollars but slash thousands of jobs in the public sector—real people who do important work—when I asked, “What is the roll-out and licensing cost of implementing AI technologies across the Public Service?”, the Minister said, “Well, I don’t have that exact figure at the moment.” Now, if you’re looking for a cliche this week, I would suggest to the Minister that that is a cliche, especially a week before Budget, when allegedly major savings are being made.

In closing, we tried to fix this bill. We took our time going through amendments. We went step by step and clause by clause. We highlighted what was wrong with it. The damage it does will not be unintended consequences.

🗣️ Speech Dan Bidois (New Zealand National Party — Member for Northcote)
Time unknown

This bill is all a part of our plan to fix the basics and to build a future with tech. I commend this bill to the House.

🗣️ Speech Hon Priyanca Radhakrishnan (New Zealand Labour Party — List Member)
Time unknown

Thank you, Madam Speaker. Sadly, all we’ve heard from members opposite are slogans once again about “modernising the system” and about “fixing the basics”. I’m being generous when I say that it’s just one part of what this bill is about. What it really does, though, is to make people who are struggling even poorer. It needs to be seen in the context of promises that Luxon and Willis have made time and time again about apparently working to make life better for New Zealanders, but they have only ended up making life worse for everybody. More cuts, more pain, and higher costs is all we’ve seen in the 2½ years that this lot has been in Government, and it’s all that we’ve seen from this Budget as well.

The Minister said that this is about freeing up time for front-line workers so that they can help more people into jobs. Yet 40,000 more people are unemployed after Luxon took office and this Government took office.

💬 Simon Court: Madam Speaker, point of order. For the second time, that member has failed to use the full name of another member, and I just ask that that member pay heed to Standing Orders.

ASSISTANT SPEAKER (Maureen Pugh): I did not hear the second time.

Settle, petal.

ASSISTANT SPEAKER (Maureen Pugh): A point of order is heard in silence. I didn’t hear the second time. I did hear it the first time, and I did not interrupt the member’s speech, but please refrain from doing it now.

OK—since Christopher Luxon and Nicola Willis have taken office, we have seen 40,000 more people unemployed; out of work. When this Minister says that they are so focused on getting people into work, jobseeker forecast alone is meant to be 200,000 in 2030, miles from her own target of 50,000, which is what this is, a desperate attempt to chuck people off the benefit to get to this Minister’s target, and yet the forecast is that there will be 10,000 more people on the jobseeker benefit than when even they took office.

What is this bill about, then? Well, according to the Minister, 122 pages of this bill are really about nothing. It is just about business as usual: “Nothing to see here. Let’s push it through Budget urgency when there’s absolutely no reason to do that. Let’s just all sit here from 12 o’clock in the afternoon. It’s 11 p.m. now. We’ll push it through all stages. We’ll cut out public participation because, hey, who cares about democracy anymore?” Not that Government of Christopher Luxon and Nicola Willis.

This Budget and this bill take no action to help people who are struggling with the cost of living. Let me just talk about what disabled people are struggling with at the moment since this Minister, of course, is also the Minister for Disability Issues: 82 percent of households with a disabled person are facing food insecurity—82 percent. Disabled people: 14 percent unemployment rate. That is more than three times the unemployment rate of non-disabled people. The Total Mobility scheme is being cut by 10 percent—that 10 percent makes a huge difference.

💬 DEPUTY SPEAKER: Would the member please come back to the bill that we’re speaking about tonight.

Sure. Because this bill is going to make life so much worse for people who are already struggling. In the name of modernisation, what this Government is doing is to carte blanche expand the automated decision-making (ADM) of the Ministry of Social Development (MSD). That’s what the Minister says, “There’s nothing to see here. MSD already has ADM.” What she doesn’t say is there’s a broadening of it to a point that MSD can require a medical review at any time, that they can override the wishes of the beneficiary and decide for the person who should conduct that medical review. There are no thresholds around this. We have asked the Minister in the committee stage whether there’s a maximum number of medical reviews that can be allowed. Is there a minimum interval? Can a person be asked every three months to go through a medical review and if they don’t complete within the stipulated period or if they don’t even reply to the email or letter within the stipulated period, their benefit will be cut?

These are people who are already struggling with food insecurity, not being able to afford to go to the doctor, making choices between food and healthcare. This bill is going to drive them further into poverty, so it is very relevant. It is also in the context of 18- and 19-year-olds with parents who earn over $65,000 being chucked off the benefit, even if they have a health condition or disability. This bill also impacts those on supported living payments who already have to jump through a zillion hoops to get that payment. This Government through this legislation is adding to the administrative burden that they face. How is that fair either?

In terms of the ADM specifically, I do want to make the point because members opposite have stood up throughout the course of this debate and said that those of us on the Opposition benches who don’t agree with this bill, who condemn this bill, are doing so because somehow we are anti-technology. That is what members opposite have said. It couldn’t be further from the truth. We’re not about being anti-ADM. In fact, ADM started under our watch because we felt that automated decision-making had a place when it came to targeted, narrow administrative decisions that MSD could make. We’re OK with that.

What we’re not OK with is the broadening that this legislation will result in. That is because it then significantly expands, I guess, the State’s power to get into people’s lives and to dictate to them what they need to do and then to penalise them when, for example, carers are already struggling to be able to keep reviews that have been extended. Jobseeker reviews were increased to 26 weeks, for example, by this Government, and now they’ll need to undergo reviews at any point in time with no justification and no triggers. That is what we are against when it comes to this bill.

One of the reasons that we are worried about this legislation is because something very similar was done in Australia not too long ago and the results there have been disastrous and have led to an entire royal commission about the Robodebt.

💬 Todd Stephenson: Nothing the same.

For some reason, when we mention Robodebt on this side of the House, members opposite get really triggered, and that in itself is rather telling.

Broad ADM is problematic because a number of these decisions around keeping medical appointments, around replying to emails and letters are much more difficult for some people. There are disabled people with cognitive issues—

💬 Simon Court: Todd-bot. Log him. Ha, ha!

—intellectually disabled people—Simon Court, you might want to stop laughing when I talk about the issues that disabled people are facing because this legislation makes it worse for them, so maybe tone down the arrogance a little bit.

💬 DEPUTY SPEAKER: The member was actually laughing at the person next to him having a private joke, which probably wasn’t appropriate either, but I can assure you he wasn’t laughing at what you were saying, so carry on.

Well, that is good. That is good to hear because otherwise it would be quite sad, really. But the point that we are trying to make on this side and the concern that we have on this side of the House is that you need a system that has genuine discretion when it comes to some of these decisions that are being made. You need genuine, meaningful, independent judgment to take into account the different circumstances that people are in. Just bringing in a broad sweep that is automatic, that takes away substantive human discretion from decisions that have such significant impacts on the wellbeing of people and the ability for people to survive is punitive.

It should have undergone a select committee process or at least the Minister should have talked to us about the safeguards in this bill and the thresholds that will mean that we won’t go down the trajectory that everyone is so worried about. The Robodebt royal commission in Australia demonstrated clearly what happens, the profound human and institutional consequences that can arise when automated administrative systems outpace lawful governance, accountability, and meaningful human judgment. That, ultimately, is the problem that we have with this bill.

When the Minister stands up and says, “There’s nothing to see here.” in 122 pages of this bill that we only got to see yesterday, that we didn’t get a huge amount of time to interrogate, where the voices of the public are not allowed to be heard, when people cannot come and share with us what impact this might have, when a Government institution can dictate when someone goes through medical review with no triggers, can dictate who the doctor is that the person needs to see, then the worry on this side, when the Government also has targets to meet, is that we will see medical practitioners that will be off the list.

We’ve suddenly learned that there’s a list that MSD will now have. If perhaps the doctor approves too many medical reviews and people are getting too many benefits, perhaps that doctor will be struck off MSD’s list. That also cuts off the genuine connection that disabled people need with their doctors, because not everyone understands the condition that they are going through or the particular disability that they have. So it is incredibly problematic when we have all of this, when the stakes are high, and we cannot get any information about safeguards for the wellbeing of people. For all of those reasons and the context within which we’re debating this bill, I do not commend this bill to the House.

🗣️ Speech Grant McCallum (New Zealand National Party — Member for Northland)
Time unknown

Thank you, Madam Speaker. On this side of the House, we believe in embracing technology and embracing a prosperous future, where, clearly, on the other side of the House, all they want to do is take us back to the coal age. I commend this bill to the House.

A party vote was called for on the question, That the Social Security (Modernisation) Amendment Bill be now read a third time.

Ayes 67

New Zealand National 48; ACT New Zealand 11; New Zealand First 8.

Noes 55

New Zealand Labour 34; Green Party of Aotearoa New Zealand 15; Te Pāti Māori 4; Ferris; Kapa-Kingi.

Motion agreed to.

Bill read a third time.

Gas (Market Transparency) Amendment Bill

Legislative Statement

🗣️ Spoke in this debate (13)