🧪 EXPERIMENTAL / ALPHA — this is an independent prototype, not an official record. Data may be incomplete or wrong - always check the linked Hansard source before relying on it.
Hot Air

Thursday, 28 May 2026

Regulatory Systems (Internal Affairs) Amendment Bill

Third Reading
HansardID: acfb2120-3dc9-f71e-8387-901227e15cc9
Back to debates
āœļø Hansard still marked this day's transcript "Draft" as of our last import - it may since have been corrected or finalised upstream. Check the official transcript if anything here looks off.
šŸ—£ļø Speech Karen Chhour (ACT New Zealand — List Member)
Time unknown

on behalf of the Minister of Internal Affairs: I move, That the Regulatory Systems (Internal Affairs) Amendment Bill be now read a third time.

I’m pleased to be here today on behalf of Minister van Velden to present the Regulatory Systems (Internal Affairs) Amendment Bill. This is an omnibus bill that deals with the regulatory systems overseen by the Department of Internal Affairs. The bill’s primary objective is to improve the effectiveness and efficiency of those regulatory systems. The bill addresses not only minor errors, gaps, and inconsistencies across legislation; it also addresses the overly prescriptive and out-of-date provisions.

On behalf of the Minister, I thank the Governance and Administration Committee for its work on the bill. This was a significant undertaking. The breadth of the bill meant the committee had a wide variety of topics to consider, with amendments across 30 different Acts. It covered topics from boxing and wrestling to reproductive technology, passports, and charities, as well as many others. I thank the select committee for their recommendations, which have helped us focus and improve the bill.

On behalf of the Minister, I would also want to acknowledge everyone who took the time to submit on the bill. The committee received 46 submissions, including from the New Zealand Law Society, the Office of the Ombudsman, the Insurance Council of New Zealand, Fertility New Zealand, and the New Zealand Mixed Martial Arts Federation. There are too many amendments to cover what all of them do, but I’d like to give an overview of some of the key provisions of this bill.

Changes to the Births, Deaths, Marriages, and Relationships Registration Act 2021 will clarify how overseas marriage dissolutions are recognised, as well as when the name changes should be publicly adopted. The bill will strengthen privacy by amending this Act to allow sensitive information to be removed from birth certificates. It will also be amended to improve access to historic records. Amendments to the Citizenship Act 1977 and the Passports Act 1992 will make it easier to issue, cancel, and revoke documents, and will update language to align with modern drafting standards.

The Electronic Identity Verification Act 2012 is being refined to simplify the process for approving participating agencies that wish to use RealMe. The bill will also make a range of changes to the Films, Videos, and Publications Classification Act 1993. The bill will amend this Act to enable the Chief Censor of Film and Literature and the Deputy Chief Censor to delegate some administrative powers and functions under the Act to classification officers. Doing so will help improve efficiency by preventing bottlenecks and administrative duties during busy periods. Other changes will see updates to the names of the Classification Office and the Classification Review Board, removing ā€œFilm and Literatureā€ from their titles to better reflect their broader roles. Changes to the Act that provide for information sharing with overseas law enforcement agencies will enable faster direct information sharing with overseas partners to improve cross-border efforts in combating online harm.

Other amendments will reduce compliance burdens and address outdated provisions. For example, amendments to the Fire and Emergency New Zealand Act 2017 simplify levy administration for insurers, while changes to the Gambling Act 2003 will support harm minimisation by restricting those under 18 from purchasing tickets for lottery products.

An update to the Human Assisted Reproductive Technology Act 2004 will enhance donor information, and registering and sharing. It will do this by allowing a personal representative of a donor to provide updated medical information to a donation clinic. This will enable important medical information to be passed along to genetic relatives. Another update will enable the registrar-general, upon request, to tell a provider of the number of donor offspring births recorded for a particular donor, which will help prevent potential relationships between donor siblings.

I want to acknowledge the time and effort that the Governance and Administration Committee put into considering this bill. The committee has provided sensible recommendations, taking into account submitter’s suggestions. The committee’s unanimous support for the progress of the bill shows a consensus that the regulatory systems managed by the Department of Internal Affairs will be improved and will benefit Kiwis who interact with those systems. I also consider that the committee’s recommended changes to the bill are reasonable and will improve clarity, privacy, and legal certainty across the legislation and regulations under consideration. Thank you, Mr Speaker. I commend this bill to the House.

ASSISTANT SPEAKER (Teanau Tuiono): The question is that the motion be agreed to.

šŸ—£ļø Speech Lemauga Lydia Sosene (New Zealand Labour Party — Member for Māngere)
Time unknown

Thank you, Mr Speaker. I’m very pleased to take a call on this Regulatory Systems (Internal Affairs) Amendment Bill, but I do question that should this bill be used and be submitted and discussed and debated on in urgency time, given that it’s a tidy up bill. However, I will continue.

Thank you to the Minister for her comments in terms of this amendment bill. It’s an omnibus bill; it’s a tidy-up in terms of the Department of Internal Affairs. It is to improve the effectiveness and the efficiency within Internal Affairs, giving them clear direction of their operational role. In the bill, there were unnecessary provisions, outdated references, redundant provisions, and technical inconsistencies that were received by the Governance and Administration Committee. I do acknowledge the members of the committee and the officials, but I really want to thank the submitters. There wasn’t a lot of submissions, but they provided very good submissions that the select committee discussed, and we were able to make recommendations. So in terms of the submitters—I do want to focus my contribution on the submitters, because we got the opportunity to raise it in the first reading, in the second reading, and through the committee stage. It was important to hear from New Zealanders that have very strong views with regards to this tidy up of regulatory systems that is operated by Internal Affairs.

I want to focus my first opening comments on the amendments to the Births, Deaths, Marriages, and Relationships Registration Act 2021. We received a submission from Matua Rāti and his concern was: what is the commitment of this bill towards Te Tiriti o Waitangi? He was asking the committee, in terms of the provisions that were not clearly included in terms of making amendments to the amendment bill. He said: ā€œThe Bill has no Treaty clause, no Māori oversight, and no data sovereignty protections.ā€, and he questioned what the committee’s work was doing in recommendations. And in Matua Rāti’s written submission, he was questioning the ā€œWhakapapa and historical information [that was] altered or shared without Māori consent or cultural assessment.ā€ In my view, that is quite valid, and it was put forward to the committee, but the committee chose otherwise.

I want to just quickly reflect on some of the figures. In Aotearoa, the population is now 5.3 million, just under 45 percent; you either come from Māori or you are ethnic or Asian, or you are Pasifika. That reflects that the New Zealand demographic is changing quite rapidly because of immigration policies and the like, and it will be important as we go into the future. For example, the next 10 years of legislation that is operated or administered by Internal Affairs to reflect that the information in births, deaths and marriages is (a) correct, and (b) it reflects some of the new New Zealanders who are not from this country but who have adopted our laws and legislation. So I just want to leave it there.

Another submission that came to the select committee was from the New Zealand Mixed Martial Arts Federation, who provided a submission with Part 2, the repeal of the Boxing and Wrestling Act 1981 and the revoking of that provision. It was important, and they were putting forward that it’s a good thing to repeal and for the select committee to review, but (a) what is going to replace it, and (b) in terms of New Zealand’s slightly growing sports in this combat area, they wanted to have input into the system. Even though we heard their submission, only some of those things were recommended.

Labour does support the sensibleness of these changes through the committee, but we do want to highlight that through the public process of public submissions, our communities will want to still have their say. That is important, because it’s important for us to hear from New Zealanders that care about the laws of this land.

Another written submission that was put in was by the New Zealand Property Council, who had real concerns about the fire and emergency levy that was described in the bill. They wanted fairness about the increasing costs to New Zealanders around the apportionment of that levy and how things are calculated. So the work that the select committee carried out was valuable. It was helpful to hear the different recommendations and then through the legislation we were able to review that.

Another submission that was put through was by members of our disability community, and I don’t recall that I actually raised this, but they were very keen for the select committee to understand the issues that are faced by many of our disability community by way of certification and by way of clunky documents when you’re actually sometimes physically impaired and you need to provide, like, your passport or your birth certificate. Through the written submission of these two individuals, Ms Liu and Mr Faville, they were asking would the Department of Internal Affairs consider a photo ID as opposed to a clunky thing like a passport, etc. Because the physical challenges that they have with sometimes having to produce documents when you need to—be it through Customs, if you’re travelling, be it through different Government departments, we need to sometimes think about those physical challenges. They were just some of the issues that were brought before the select committee.

It is very helpful that when New Zealanders are going through a rising cost of living in terms of day-to-day costs, sometimes when departments are trying to achieve efficiency and effectiveness through different legislation, we actually sometimes need to ensure that we are making good recommendations through the select committee process to our officials. Because sometimes it will be the language or written provisions through what we have to do, but when you’re actually a Department of Internal Affairs official, sometimes there are serious challenges for members of our community, either from the disability community or even the languages.

The languages was one of my questions to the Minister through the committee process, because there is a strong assumption that many members in our community, either everyone’s got degrees and you’ve been through quite a seasoned education in your life, or not. And sometimes people with different languages—English might be your second or third language. So there’s a sometimes incorrect assumption that when laws are put out that sometimes the language can be quite challenging. It is helpful for officials to understand because we are a growing, diverse community.

We’ve got big centres, whether it’s Tāmaki-makau-rau, whether it’s the middle of the North Island, Wellington, and further to the South Island. It is important that when the select committee and public submissions are received, people understand the diverseness of New Zealand. It’s changing. It’s a changing thing.

Through this Regulatory Systems (Internal Affairs) Amendment Bill, it’s a good bill that we’ve had the opportunity within the select committee to be able to communicate, to converse, and also to receive advice from our officials—really important advice. What we’re trying to achieve is a quality piece of legislation that, then, everyday Kiwis and New Zealanders will understand.

It was helpful to understand that through this process, 23 of those Acts, which cover internal affairs, health, local government, transport, justice, community and voluntary sector—those are important departments in our community. It is the purpose of this House to ensure that we have a robust process and that when we are reviewing, particularly through a technical regulatory systems amendment bill, we actually get it right; that it’s updated. This Government has used the term ā€œmoderniseā€. Now, ā€œmoderniseā€, on this side of the House, to us, means ā€œcut, cut, cutā€, and that’s what we’ve seen in yesterday’s Budget.

But I do thank the select committee for their work. I commend this bill to the House.

šŸ—£ļø Speech Mike Davidson (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand — List Member)
Time unknown

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Outside it’s 11 a.m. on a Friday, but in here it’s still Thursday and we’re in urgency. I was sitting in my office this morning, looking through the next bill we’re going to look at, the Social Security (Modernisation) Amendment Bill, and I was just shaking my head. It was very clear this is a Government that’s not for all of us. If you’re poor, if you’re a student, you’re Māori, disabled, this Government doesn’t care. Then I got told—

šŸ’¬ Andy Foster: That’s not true.

That’s true, Andy Foster—it’s true. Then I got told, oh, the Regulatory Systems (Internal Affairs) Amendment Bill is up next. It’s urgency, and here we are, having the third reading on a bill that’s about, really, housekeeping—a technical tidy-up—in urgency. Is this really what urgency is for? Is this really what urgency is for—this bill?

šŸ’¬ Tim Costley: Well, then, just commend it to the House. Crack on.

No. Well, this is actually important that we let people know what we’ve sat in urgency for. I think it’s really important that people realise that we’re stuck in urgency discussing a bill that’s just about housekeeping, technical tidying-up.

But what’s coming is really, really bad. What’s coming is, once again, punching down on the poor, a typical response—

ASSISTANT SPEAKER (Greg O'Connor): Having announced we’re discussing the bill, let’s discuss the bill.

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Let me get back to the bill.

Now, I’ve, obviously, come in recently, and this bill had already been introduced and was part-way through. I managed to actually sit on a couple of the hearings, but I didn’t work on, obviously, refining the bill through the select committee. I’d like to acknowledge the work of the select committee, which is very well chaired by Camilla Belich, and good work in making some changes. Obviously, this is quite a technical bill. I think it’s really important.

I did do the second reading and sat through the committee of the whole House. It, obviously, went on for quite a few hours. It’s important that we, I guess, really interrogate these bills, because we know this Government likes to slip little things in here and there that, actually, once again, make it harder for people to live. I did outline all the Acts that were being amended. We heard in the first reading there were 30, but I’m not too sure. I read in the report there were, like, 23, but maybe there were a few more that they’re sneaking in there. In the second reading, I did read out all those Acts, and I did that for the people that watch online. It’s probably important that I do that again, because for the hundreds and hundreds of people that do watch along—well, maybe it’s tens and tens, or less than ten, but there may be different ones, so it’s probably really important that they understand all the bills and Acts that are going to be amended from this. So just give me a minute while I go over them.

šŸ’¬ Hon Member: Well, you’ve got seven.

Oh, excellent. I probably don’t need seven to get through all these, but there’s a few that we need to talk to as well. What were they? OK: the Births, Deaths, Marriages, and Relationships Registration Act 2021; the Charities Act 2005; the Citizenship Act 1977; the Electronic Identity Verification Act 2012—it’s a long list—the Films, Videos, and Publications Classification Act 1993; the Fire and Emergency New Zealand Act 2017; the Gambling Act 2003; the Health Practitioners Competence Assurance Act 2003; the Human Assisted Reproductive Technology Act 2004; the Inquiries Act 2013; the Land Drainage Act 1908; the Legal Services Act 2011; the Local Authorities (Members’ Interests) Act 1968; the Local Government (Auckland Council) Act 2009; the Marriage Act 1955; the Passports Act 1992; the Public Records Act 2005; the Reserves and Other Lands Disposal and Public Bodies Empowering Act 1915; the Reserves and other Lands Disposal and Public Bodies Empowering Act 1917; the Reserves and other Lands Disposal and Public Bodies Empowering Act 1920; the River Boards Amendment Act 1913; the Rotorua Borough Act 1922—

šŸ’¬ Camilla Belich: I’m glad you mentioned that one. It’s a good one.

It is. As well as amending them, the bill would also repeal the Boxing and Wrestling Act 1981 and revoke the Boxing and Wrestling Regulations 1958.

It was touching on a lot of Acts, and some are very old Acts. I see one from 1908—the Land Drainage Act 1908. Some of them were actually important tidy-ups. We must state that. It was actually quite good to bring these up to speed, because some of them were quite old. I’ll touch on a couple of Acts. I think it was really important that the Boxing and Wrestling Act—we heard a lot of submissions on this one. Really, there was concern. We know there’s a lot more combat sport than just boxing and wrestling, and what we had was an Act that covered just one. It was outdated, but there was one Act. There was a lot of concern about the fact that, actually, just because we don’t have an Act to cover everything else, do we repeal the one Act that we have that covers a couple of those combat sports? It was good to know that, actually, the timing of the repealing of this would try and align with bringing in an Act that would cover everything. I think that’s really needed, and I think it needs to make sure that we follow through that process—that we don’t actually have a legislative gap there. We have seen in combat sport that there is serious risk, and we need to make sure that that is regulated properly.

Another one I just want to touch on, and I brought it up in the committee of the whole House, and I’m not too sure—I don’t really think I got a great answer from the Minister, but that’s not surprising. It was around the fire and emergency changes to that Act. I just need to find it. It was around the meaning of a dwelling. What happened is they’ve, basically, got the Natural Hazards Insurance Act, and they’ve done a bit of a carbon copy across to this bill, to the Fire and Emergency New Zealand Act, just so they can define what the meaning of a ā€œdwellingā€ is, what the meaning of ā€œmulti-use buildingsā€ā€”which makes really good sense, to have Acts that align.

When I was reading through it, it had a section where it defines a dwelling. Basically, it makes sense, right, what a dwelling is. It needs to have somewhere you can ā€œcook, sleep, live, wash, and use a toiletā€. It kind of goes through, and then it goes, ā€œA building, or part of a building, that meets the criteria in subsection (1) or the criterion in subsection (2) is a dwelling even if it is used some of the time to provide temporary or transient accommodation.ā€, which is fine. But then further on in the same section, it then goes to ā€œClarifying uncertaintyā€, and it goes, ā€œTo avoid doubt, a building, or part of a building, is not a home or a holiday home (and is therefore not a dwelling …) if it is used to provide temporary or transient accommodation, being accommodation that is ordinarily provided for periods of less than 28 days at a time (such as a hotel or motel);ā€.

Well, the other thing that would fall into that category is short-term accommodation like Airbnbs, and whether, if they’re sole use, they are actually covered by this bill. And if they’re not covered by this bill, they will not be covered by the Natural Hazards Insurance Act, and therefore, potentially, we’ve got thousands of properties across this country that may be paying the levies but legally are not covered.

Unfortunately, the reply I got from the Minister was that it aligns with the Natural Hazards Insurance Act, which I’d already said in my question. So it kind of left a bit of a question there: have we created legislation that is leaving a lot of people exposed in the event of an earthquake? We know from the Canterbury earthquakes that there was a lot of issues and ambiguity in the Act that has caused a legacy of issues for the last 15 years. I’d really hate that actually we’ve created not just the Fire and Emergency New Zealand Act 2017 but also the Natural Hazards Insurance Act with issues there that would actually hurt a lot of people moving forward.

All in all, I think what we’ve done here is actually just tidy-up a number of Acts. It’s still very, very concerning that we’re actually using urgency for this housekeeping matter. But on that, the Greens will support this bill. I commend it to the House. Kia ora.

šŸ—£ļø Speech Tim Costley (New Zealand National Party — Member for Ōtaki)
Time unknown

This bill fixes some basics, and I want to point to clause 108 and also clause 116(2) where it makes Lotto now R18. That’s a good idea. I commend the bill.

šŸ—£ļø Speech Andy Foster (New Zealand First Party — List Member)
Time unknown

This bill is largely about minor changes to 23 Acts. I’d love to speak to several of them but in the interests of keeping it short, I won’t. I will just mention one, which is the Public Records Act. The bill originally proposed removing the requirement for organisations that were working overseas under multinational arrangement, for example the Defence Force, to be able to be exempted from complying with the Public Records Act. New Zealand First’s long-held and well-communicated view, coloured by Operation Burnham in Afghanistan, is that was inappropriate, and therefore the majority of the select committee agreed to continue to require transparency and complying with the Public Records Act while asking for further work to be done on this matter.

Finally, I would note that while we’ve had a lot of complaints about doing this in urgency, this does not change in any way the consideration of this particular bill, because it’s just the third reading. I commend this bill to the House.

šŸ—£ļø Speech Celia Wade-Brown (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand — List Member)
Time unknown

Tēnā koe e te Māngai o te Whare. I have a few points to make in supporting the third reading of the Regulatory Systems (Internal Affairs) Amendment Bill. It is non-controversial in general but there a few points I would like to raise nevertheless.

There’s the small matter that some of us went to a presentation recently about tiny homes on wheels, and I just want to draw the House’s attention to the fact that the definition of ā€œdwellingā€ in no way really covers tiny homes on wheels. I’m just putting on the record that across the House it would be really useful if we could work through the chance for housing implications, and, of course, it’s mentioned here in terms of Fire and Emergency New Zealand implications of actually creating cheaper housing for people so that they can own a house but don’t have to own the land and some of the agreements that come along with that. So that’s something new in the third reading to add.

The other area that I want to look at is the modernisation of gender. I think it’s really interesting that we agree on a bill that modernises the definition of ā€œgenderā€ for the citizenship roles. It replaces many instances of ā€œheā€ or ā€œsheā€ with ā€œtheyā€, ā€œhisā€ or ā€œherā€ with ā€œtheirā€, and that there are certain parties in this House that seem to have been exceedingly allergic to understanding the use of the pronouns ā€œtheyā€ and ā€œtheirā€. Yet today, they deem it completely non-controversial. I did raise this with the Minister in the committee of the whole House, and one point we absolutely agree on is replacing some of the references, sections 16, 17, and 19, in Schedule 1. We replace ā€œheā€ with ā€œthe Ministerā€, because, thank goodness, in 2026 we can have many Ministers who are not men.

I’m really surprised that these excellent aspects of modernisation don’t seem to have actually trickled down to a party that can put up such a divisive and unpleasant and unscientific bill that seeks to categorise human beings who are far more interesting and diverse than just a binary male or female.

I am delighted that we will be agreeing this unanimously, and I think this should provide excellent ammunition for all of those people who want to be inclusive, fair, and friendly to other human beings.

This came through a portmanteau bill, a wide-ranging bill, when I was on the Governance and Administration Committee, and I thank Camilla Belich for her leadership there, as ever, and the other members, Tim Costley, Andy Foster—a great committee. I miss it. I hope you miss me too. Also there’s the Hon Melissa Lee, Tom Rutherford, Lemauga Lydia Sosene, and myself. Again, I don’t remember Andy Foster raising any issues about those gender definitions and the lists moving ā€œhisā€ and ā€œherā€ to ā€œtheirā€ at that point at all. So maybe it’s just been a later surprise to us all. On behalf of the Green Party, I support this bill.

šŸ—£ļø Speech Dr Shane Reti (New Zealand National Party — Member for Whangārei)
Time unknown

The bill is to improve the efficiency and the effectiveness of the regulatory systems overseen by the Department of Internal Affairs. Again, as other members have said, thanks and congratulations to the select committee. I commend this bill to the House.

šŸ—£ļø Speech Camilla Belich (New Zealand Labour Party — List Member)
Time unknown

Thank you, Mr Speaker. Well, well, well, here we are in Budget urgency discussing the Regulatory Systems (Internal Affairs) Amendment Bill. How fascinating.

I have to say that in the lead-up to the Budget, and we are now in Budget urgency, we see the country dealing with a cost of living crisis. We heard the Government make some pre-Budget announcements about sacking 9,000 New Zealanders. So in the anticipation leading up to the Budget, although the finance Minister was very keen to lower expectations, we thought that surely there’s going to be something in this Budget, something that we’ll be discussing in Budget urgency that’s going to really set out this Government’s vision for New Zealand and really show that they haven’t been wasting the last three years and have a vision for a better life for everyday New Zealanders, with some of the issues we’re facing, like forecast record high unemployment, for example.

I have to say I didn’t anticipate that one of the bills that they would bring before the House in Budget urgency would be the Regulatory Systems (Internal Affairs) Amendment Bill. That was a surprise because not only does the Regulatory Systems (Internal Affairs) Amendment Bill have probably the least amount of urgency of any bill on the Order Paper, it is something that, by the Minister’s own words, has been being prepared by Internal Affairs for decades—decades. But, apparently, in this opportunity of Budget urgency, where the Government has their last chance to really stamp their mark on New Zealand, this is what they choose to prioritise,

It is also an interesting choice for Budget urgency for another reason, and that is because there is just so much material in here, so many Acts that are being amended and so many things to talk about. I have to say I was thinking about this bill. I think I remember every single stage of this bill. I remember the first reading. I think I was on the speaking list but unfortunately I had leave and my colleague Barbara Edmonds took a call on it. I think she said at that stage that she was surprised to see levy-setting in a regulatory systems bill, and I think that’s a fair reflection.

Levy setting, as it is for Fire and Emergency New Zealand, is slightly unusual to have in a regulatory systems bill because it would be seen as a slightly more substantive bill. A levy is very closely related—and I won’t get into the semantics—to a tax, and so having that in a regulatory systems bill was somewhat unusual. Then I had the honour of chairing the Governance and Administration Committee that looked into this bill, and we heard from a number of different submitters, and we heard about a number of different things. I just don’t think I’m going to have enough time to go through all of them in the time that I have remaining, but I will try and pull out a few highlights. I want to acknowledge, as other people have, the collegiality in the select committee and the way that the submitters brought up issues on a range of subjects. I think, actually, in many ways—probably more than most bills that we see through select committee—a lot of suggestions that submitters actually made were incorporated into the final version of the bill that we have before us today. That is the next part that I recall.

Then, of course, very, very recently—in fact, I believe it may have even been this week or last week—we had the committee stage, and we were able to go through this bill with an extreme level of attention to detail. Every single clause, or most, was scrutinised. There were a few in there—some very, very old Acts from over 100 years ago—that have been amended under this Act. Again, that really emphasises for me the irony of using Budget urgency for this type of bill when things have been able to not be urgent for 100 years, and yet the Government has decided to use this opportunity to make this change in the House.

However, I won’t labour that point too much further, but I do believe it shows a lack of ambition by this Government to make a real change in the lives of New Zealanders. This bill, as the Minister of Internal Affairs stated in her third reading speech, really looks at out-of-date matters and minor matters—so that is what the bill does. That doesn’t mean the things in it are not important, but they’re certainly not urgent, and certainly shouldn’t be of a substantive policy nature, because otherwise it wouldn’t be a regulatory systems bill. It would be another type of bill; one that we might more expect to see during Budget urgency.

Some of the interesting things that we discussed in this bill—and I haven’t actually, I don’t think, been able to make this point and it’s been something that I’ve been wanting to discuss throughout the period of time that this has been going through the House. In this regulatory systems bill, we are making changes to the Human Assisted Reproductive Technology Act. I support those changes, but we heard a number of submitters say and come to us about further changes that they wanted to see in that Act. I just want to be really clear about an area of law that was raised with us in select committee for inclusion in this bill that we were advised could not be included in the bill due to scope; due to the fact that it’s a regulatory systems bill—it only updates details in bills and covers minor matters. But I do think that this warrants the attention of the House, and I do think this is an area that we should be looking at seriously because there is injustice that is occurring according to submitters.

The actual recommendation that I think many of the committee would have liked to have seen some action on that we weren’t able to progress was the Ethics Committee on Assisted Reproductive Technology at the moment does not have any discretion to consider applications for extension for the storage limit for frozen embryos. There’s a 10-year cut-off limit—that includes overseas time, it includes time in New Zealand. There isn’t, as we were advised, a scientific basis for making it a cut-off of 10 years, and of course, this can have huge implications for people’s lives. People have individual circumstances. They might have frozen embryos at a certain point. They may have had a diagnosis from a certain member of their family. They might have lost family members. They might be facing personal challenges where those embryos take on increasing importance for them, and there is no good scientific reason we heard that those embryos should not be able to be used at 11 years, 12 years—there’s not a reason for that, necessarily.

Of course, those of us in this House, and those of us on select committee, are not expert doctors in this area. The people who are experts are the Ethics Committee on Assisted Reproductive Technology. I do think something that this House should look at is bringing in a bill that allows that committee to have discretion to consider an extension. I think that that would be a great member’s bill and I think it would be a good Government bill to bring to the House. I think many people, including submitters to the committee on this bill, would be very pleased to see a bit of common sense and a bit of discretion being able to be put in place in this particular area. So I did want to say that and I’m grateful that I’ve had the opportunity to do that.

There are a number of other areas that have been changed by this. The Gambling Act has been mentioned—it’s raised the age of buying Lotto tickets to 18. The committee did quite a lot of good work to make sure that those purchasing Lotto tickets who are under 18, if they were to win in a transitional period, were still able to claim their winnings. That’s a particularly interesting thing that we looked at.

šŸ’¬ Tangi Utikere: Win the lottery. Maybe we can talk about that at Budget urgency.

That’s right. There’s been a bit of mention of lotteries recently, and certainly, the chances of people winning the lottery from this Budget are very, very low. Certainly, those of our most vulnerable in social housing are also not in that position, probably couldn’t afford a ticket actually—they’re quite expensive, as I understand, these days.

We also made changes to the Boxing and Wrestling Act. That was something the committee felt strongly about, that understanding that the boxing and wrestling community wanted to have a system in place and not have the regulations just simply removed, and so there’s a review happening. I would look forward to the Minister for culture and heritage, maybe during scrutiny week, being able to give an update on this review. Because 1 April 2028, it’s going to be no joke for those in the boxing and wrestling community if the review has not been completed, that they will have no regulation around that particular sport at that time, and so that’s no joke for them.

In the closing few seconds of my contribution, I just want to note that as we are in Budget urgency, it does mean that instead of being a Friday as it is in the rest of the world, it is actually Thursday, 28 May, which just happens to be our deputy leader Carmel Sepuloni’s birthday. Not only can her birthday celebrations start on a Thursday, they can in fact continue until this Government chooses to finish Budget urgency, so I send my very happy extended birthday wishes to her.

šŸ—£ļø Speech Melissa Lee (New Zealand National Party — List Member)
Time unknown

Thank you. Mr Speaker. As many members have actually said, this legislation amends 23 Acts, and it is for the Department of Internal Affairs to continue well into the future and the legislation that they oversee remains fit for purpose. I commend it to the House.

ASSISTANT SPEAKER (Greg O'Connor): Georgie Dansey.

šŸ—£ļø Speech GEORGIE DANSEY
Time unknown

Tēnā koe e te Māngai o te Whare.

ASSISTANT SPEAKER (Greg O'Connor): Five-minute split call.

Hmm?

ASSISTANT SPEAKER (Greg O'Connor): Five-minute split call.

Oh, thanks. This is my first Budget urgency and I was excited about what the Government might present in urgency—real action on the cost of living for New Zealanders. I wasn’t sure where they’d go, but I can see now the direction that this Government has decided to go in is the third reading of the Regulatory Systems (Internal Affairs) Amendment Bill. The second bill up in Budget urgency is the Regulatory Systems (Internal Affairs) Amendment Bill. What an introduction to Parliament for me for my first Budget urgency. I look forward to the Budget next year, which I know will be a Labour-led Budget and will have real relief for people struggling with the cost of living in this country. Instead, for now, I’ll talk about the Regulatory Systems (Internal Affairs) Amendment Bill administered by the Department of Internal Affairs.

As other speakers have spoken to, it makes changes to multiple pieces of legislation administered by the department, and in this case has provision over 23 Acts. There are a few of the Acts that I wanted to touch on today. Following on from the comments of my colleague, Camilla Belich, around the changes to the Human Assisted Reproductive Technology Act, this is an important step for us to consider the way that we look at donors in our country.

As rainbow spokesperson, I have a lot of conversations and have a lot of friends who have been through the process of having a donor in a same-sex relationship. There’s a lot of work to do in this space because too often there are concerns—it’s a very sensitive time, it’s a very high-pressure time, it can be very stressful—and the more we can do to break down the barriers to accessing that and making it as easy as possible is good.

So I support these changes because they’re going to have long-term effects in New Zealand. I’d say that the use of donors in this country has grown considerably over the last few years, which I’m stoked to see, including single parents accessing the donor space. So I’d like to see more in this space and as part of this Act, but this is a very good step in that direction.

The second one I wanted to talk about a bit was the Boxing and Wrestling Act. I was reading through the submissions for the bill and I was really interested in the submission from the New Zealand Mixed Martial Arts Federation (NZMMAF). I think that they had some great points around protections in wrestling and boxing. This bill puts New Zealand in line with international boxing and wrestling organisations: requirements for rings, boxing gloves, rounds, and durations. Other speakers have spoken to this and the NZMMAF spoke to this about extending those provisions. We want good regulation in this space, we want good safety in this space. There is room to go further to ensure that we’re reducing unnecessary risks in combat sports. They wanted to see an enforceable, clear, regulatory framework that covers the entirety of combat sports.

The last one I’ll mention is the changes to Lotto and the submission from the New Zealand Lotteries Commission which supported that age change to 18 for all Lotto games. I really support that and it’s good to see that we have both the Lotteries Commission as well as consumers supporting this change; this is going bring more safety into our communities.

To finish up: what a time to be alive; what a time to have your first Budget urgency, to talk about the Regulatory Systems (Internal Affairs) Amendment Bill. I look forward to next year with a more progressive Government.

šŸ—£ļø Speech Dr Hamish Campbell (New Zealand National Party — Member for Ilam)
Time unknown

It is a great honour to rise in support of the Regulatory Systems (Internal Affairs) Amendment Bill. What we’ve heard across their House is support for this bill so therefore I commend it to the House.

šŸ—£ļø Speech Helen White (New Zealand Labour Party — Member for Mount Albert)
Time unknown

I guess I looked at this bill for the first time because I wasn’t on the Governance and Administration Committee when it was put on the Order Paper, and I was thinking about how we come here in urgency at the time of the Budget, and we expect to see some new vision for our communities, and then we get—on Friday morning—this, which is the rats and mice, isn’t it?

It doesn’t mean that these things aren’t important or that the Governance and Administration Committee hasn’t done a valiant job on looking at issues that are clustered in this piece of legislation. But, by its very nature, they have to be minor changes and just be the rats and mice. That’s the nature of the very bill. It isn’t just an analogy; it is a deep irony that that’s what we end up doing straight after the Budget of this Government. It shows just how little is on the table for New Zealanders today, of any great significance, that this is what we’re dealing with today.

I was quite passionate in my last speech about my concern about the degree to which working families in this country are now dependent on food banks. Nothing that I’m reading in this bill comes anywhere close to even tweaking our laws in a way that will expedite the feeding of our families or the changing of settings in a way that might mean that two people working in a family can actually feed their kids. That’s a pretty sorry moment in New Zealand, when we get to that point and we’re there. That’s what New Zealanders have to face when they open their newspapers this morning—that’s where we’re at. It isn’t funny; it’s incredibly tragic. But you could look at it in a comic way, that that’s where we’re at today. It’s deeply ironic, and by which use of the term I actually mean ironic, which the song by Alanis Morissette never really did. I think it misunderstood that phrase deeply.

Now, I want to talk about what’s in the bill, and it will be—and I did say, I don’t want to derogate from some of the things that this will affect, so I want to start with the very sensible suggestion that our local electoral officers will be able to take an oath or a declaration. What a sensible thing to do, and it is something that I’d like to see a lot more of: that kind of dissemination of that kind of power to people, that makes it really accessible and that honours the people who do those jobs and often do them with little recompense, but are really important in our community. It’s really nice to see that.

I was very interested to see the changes to the Births, Deaths, Marriages, and Relationships Registration Act. I hadn’t really understood that there was a problem with the kind of information that was published there but it clearly has been problematic, and I can see the utter sense in the Registrar-General looking at whether the disclosure of information is prejudicial to the personal safety and wellbeing of people named in the certificate or their family. That’s the kind of thing that I think we’re going to have to do more of. I think we’re seeing a lot of little indications in the law before us that privacy settings have to be revisited in a modern world where a lot of the information that used to be something somebody went and dug out and often had a search clerk involved in getting that information, is now online, it’s now available, and it is being misused quite a lot. There needs to be a rethinking about that balance.

So I do think that little change is an indicator that there’s a bigger, more joined up vision of that balance to be talked about. We’ve talked about it in other areas of the law recently, one being the issue over the Companies Act and the registration of directors with their addresses on those Companies Act registers. I do think we need to have a good look at that because access to information has become quite weaponised in this country. I was interested in that one.

I was also interested in the boxing and wrestling, which is actually a removal of the law, as I understand it, and a refresh, ready for a regulation and an Act that might cover a whole lot of different combat sports. Again, that’s an area—I’ve had the privilege in my work in Mt Albert to realise how important boxing has become in my community and how wonderful that can be as an opportunity, particularly for young men. But I’ve seen a lot of young women getting involved, too, in that sport. I’ve also seen it being used in the family violence space where little children are actually getting involved in something that is an outlet for some of their energy, but it’s a positive team-based, connective outlet.

I think boxing is a really interesting area, and what has been pointed out to me by people working in those areas is that there are some hidden issues around being able to box at an international level, and it does need a real look at it to encourage that sport to flourish well, but also that there is very little funding for the sport—no Government funding at all for a sport like that. I think the issue of these sports and their place in terms of wellbeing, I think that’s a big one where we probably don’t have a handle on the benefit that it brings to our communities.

When I’ve looked at cost-benefit in that area, it’s been underwhelming in comparison to what I think the reality is—that it does offer huge advantage. Recently, I got taken by a wonderful man who had the tragedy of his daughter dying by way of domestic violence—a guy called David White. His daughter had been killed, and he showed me this beautiful little boxing ring in the middle of nowhere where those children were being engaged in that way. He definitely sold me on the idea that it’s things like boxing that may well bring a lot of value to our community in terms of getting kids out of cycles where they are seeing violence and they haven’t got the community around them to support them in a healthy way beyond that problem.

I also just want to talk about the issue over the Human Assisted Reproductive Technology Act. Look, this is huge. We’re going to have to look at this again. It was good to see the work that was done. The issues are obviously being balanced by a very conscientious committee—issues around holding and storing embryos, etc. Also issues that have been flagged and that are hard ones to solve around donors who donate a lot, and then you may have a myriad of children who don’t know each other, and then they may form relationships because, in fact, they’ve got the same father. It is something that we’re going to have to look at in a much more comprehensive way. Those kinds of changes, they’re a big deal, and this is a good start, but it’s by no means the end.

Finally, I did want to just spend my last few seconds talking about the gambling issues. We have a huge issue coming in this country with youth gambling. We’ve got people online looking at youth gambling. This fixes a little, tiny thing—the lottery tickets—but there’s a bigger problem we’re going to have to face head-on. It’s a huge one, and it’s doing huge damage in our communities.

šŸ—£ļø Speech Katie Nimon (New Zealand National Party — Member for Napier)
Time unknown

Look, we’ve heard that this is a very detailed and helpful bill, and so, with that, I think it’s very important that I commend this bill to the House.

ASSISTANT SPEAKER (Greg O'Connor): Tangi Utikere, taking the five-minute Te Pāti Māori call.

šŸ—£ļø Speech Tangi Utikere (New Zealand Labour Party — Member for Palmerston North)
Time unknown

Meitaki maata, thank you, Mr Speaker. It’s a pleasure to rise and take a call on this Regulatory Systems (Internal Affairs) Amendment Bill. The regulatory systems bills are always actually quite interesting ones. They often don’t gather a huge number of submissions, but they do have quite broad impacts.

It is interesting, however, that on the day after the Budget—the physical day after the Budget, not the date after the Budget, because we are in urgency. We are in Budget urgency, which is used as an opportunity for the Government to signal what is so urgent to set aside what would normally be happening on a Friday or a Saturday and to place the Parliament into urgency. To have this bill within the urgency motion, I tell you, is something of a surprise because what is contained in this bill, I think many people would agree, would not warrant bringing people back on a Friday—the fact that staff have to come here and staff the Parliament over the Friday and into the Saturday. This is a bill that would normally be part of the Order Paper and would not need to proceed under urgency. There is nothing in this bill that warrants the use of urgency by the Government. There are changes, no doubt, but it is intriguing to wonder why it is that the Government intends to place us into Budget urgency to consider these changes.

I will just touch on some of the changes. There are 23 Acts and associated regulations; I don’t intend to go through them all, but there are some that are worthy of mention. The first one is the Births, Deaths, Marriages, and Relationships Registration Act. The bill would change that so that it actually gives some power to the Registrar-General to ensure that if there is some information that might make its way on to a births or deaths certificate or a marriage or civil union certificate, the law currently does not give the Registrar-General to remove or not place on those records some information that might actually be prejudicial to safety or wellbeing—whether that’s around perhaps location, addresses, those sorts of things. This change will mean that the Registrar-General will have some flexibility in terms of them making that particular decision.

One of the other changes is to the Fire and Emergency New Zealand Act there. Now, wouldn’t it be great if we were actually using Budget urgency to discuss the suggestion of the Government making pumping more money and resourcing into Fire and Emergency New Zealand, given that in about 14 minutes, they will be going on strike to send a signal to this Government that they are doing nothing to support them in their current crisis and their dire emergency? Instead, the Government’s preference and priority is to spend Budget urgency debating and talking about clause 92, which is going to replace regulation 15(1) of the Fire and Emergency New Zealand (Levy) Regulations around the valuation of property that’s deemed to be less than 50 percent residential. This is the priority of this Government in terms of progressing this the day after the Budget when it comes to Fire and Emergency New Zealand. I want to acknowledge those who will go on strike in about 13 minutes’ time to continue to send a very strong signal to the Government that they are not supportive of the work that they do.

There is also the Gambling Act, which many members have already touched on around Lotto. I want to acknowledge the Governance and Administration Committee, which made one change around, OK, what about the circumstance where someone legitimately purchases one of those tickets, then this law change comes in, and then they can’t redeem that because they would be ineligible? The select committee has fallen on the side of, well, actually, let’s allow that a ticket that’s validly purchased prior to that can still be redeemed by someone who is able to do that.

The final one that I want to touch on, my colleague Helen White has already referenced. This is the Local Electoral Act changes. When there are local elections in communities, there are electoral officers, deputy electoral officers, and other officials who undertake work. At the moment, there is no clear steer or direction around who can actually witness those declarations that are taken; what this law change will do—one provision of the bill—will mean that’s actually specified so that those who hold or occupy those electoral officer or deputy electoral officer roles can undertake that work.

These are important pieces of work, but they certainly don’t justify the use of Budget urgency, in my mind, to progress these changes. We could have come back in June or July to progress this. There are no immediate changes—certainly in the local government space, that need to be given effect to right here, right now. So, yes, we will support this bill, but it is unfortunate that this a priority signal from the Government that this is where the House’s time should be spent, rather than on matters that really will make a huge difference.

Motion agreed to.

Bill read a third time.

Social Security (Modernisation) Amendment Bill

Legislative Statement

šŸ—£ļø Spoke in this debate (13)

  • Camilla Belich (New Zealand Labour Party — List Member)
  • Dr Hamish Campbell (New Zealand National Party — Member for Ilam)
  • Karen Chhour (ACT New Zealand — List Member)
  • Tim Costley (New Zealand National Party — Member for Ōtaki)
  • Mike Davidson (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand — List Member)
  • Andy Foster (New Zealand First Party — List Member)
  • Melissa Lee (New Zealand National Party — List Member)
  • Katie Nimon (New Zealand National Party — Member for Napier)
  • Dr Shane Reti (New Zealand National Party — Member for Whangārei)
  • Lemauga Lydia Sosene (New Zealand Labour Party — Member for Māngere)
  • Tangi Utikere (New Zealand Labour Party — Member for Palmerston North)
  • Celia Wade-Brown (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand — List Member)
  • Helen White (New Zealand Labour Party — Member for Mount Albert)