Patents Amendment Bill
I move, That the Patents Amendment Bill be now read a third time.
I’ve already thanked the Economic Development, Science and Innovation Committee—EDSI as it’s affectionately known as—for their work on the bill today, this evening, and in previous weeks and months; and to many others involved in this for a number of years, as committee of the whole House revealed. I also want to acknowledge those who submitted on the bill, and those who have an interest in patents, in science, and in inventions; all great stuff that improves our lives.
Patents are important for innovation because they incentivise inventors to develop new technologies and solutions while protecting their intellectual property. However, some patents, the pending patents that I mentioned earlier, can create barriers to entry for competition and limit consumers choice, especially when the invention is undeserved. This bill will allow inventions without merit to be refused more quickly at the examination stage. I’ll give that to you again: this bill—because this is the crux of it—will allow inventions without merit to be refused more quickly at the examination stage rather than third parties having to expend unnecessary time and resources to oppose those patents for such inventions being granted.
By ensuring that undeserving inventions are not patented, local businesses will have the freedom to manufacture and sell products without legal risk of infringement, and, in turn, this will contribute to economic growth. This is a small but important change for New Zealand. I commend this bill to the House.
💬 DEPUTY SPEAKER: The question is that the motion be agreed to.
Thank you, Madam Speaker. Look there is a mischief here and I thank the officials, who are here on a Saturday night, for nodding their heads vigorously and providing the Minister with some examples—the example of the feather duster. The point there is that the 1953 Act is very loose. It’s very easy to get something protected under the 1953 Act, and the 2013 Act is more appropriate. It has, what would be regarded internationally, the appropriate standards for that intellectual property protection, that comes in the form of a patent. We know that because this 1953 test is so loose, the problem has been that not only does it apply to old things, old inventions that would have been done before 2013 when the new Act came in, but also there’s a route to get in there—if it’s related in some way, if it’s a divisional application, you can have this lower test, and that ends up with problems because people can patent something which shouldn’t be patented.
What that means in the real world is that we have New Zealand companies where they have Australian competitors and they seek out these divisional applications under that 1953 test, and then, there are some ways to get around it, but my understanding is that the New Zealand companies have to then take them to court. And that’s a very expensive and inefficient process. And hat this legislation—that has being talked about by both Governments for some time—is going to fix that problem, so that only things that deserve to be patented are patented, and there’s not this sort of back-door route in through a connection to an old patient named under the 1953 Act.
That’s good that we’re passing this law. We’ve supported the law. It would have been useful to have some more helpful explanations from the Minister in the committee stage, but I’m very respectful of the advisers who were providing some notes to him. I thank everybody who’s worked on this bill, and we commend it to the House.
💬 DEPUTY SPEAKER: The question is that the motion be agreed to. All those in favour say aye—
💬 Hon Dr Duncan Webb: Madam Speaker! Madam Speaker.
💬 DEPUTY SPEAKER: No one took a call.
💬 Hon Dr Duncan Webb: Mr Willis was on his feet—
💬 DEPUTY SPEAKER: He stood up after I started voting.
💬 Hon Dr DUNCAN WEBB: I’ve got to take objection to that, Madam Speaker. He was clearly seeking the call. You have in front of you—
💬 DEPUTY SPEAKER: He didn’t seek the call!
💬 Hon Dr Duncan Webb: You have in front of you a speaking order. You know which party is next most likely to take the call.
💬 DEPUTY SPEAKER: And I was watching.
💬 Hon Dr Duncan Webb: He took his feet and with it—he’s not expected to be Usain Bolt, Madam Speaker.
💬 DEPUTY SPEAKER: Dr Webb—Hon Dr Duncan Webb. It’s not actually rocket science, in this House, that people need to stand up and call.
💬 Hon Dr Duncan Webb: Well, quite frankly, you didn’t give him a chance, and you leaped to the vote.
💬 DEPUTY SPEAKER: He wasn’t on his feet when we started voting. He was not on his feet when I started voting. I looked round the House—
💬 Hon Dr Duncan Webb: The pause between the last speaker and you going to the vote was infinitesimal.
💬 DEPUTY SPEAKER: Nobody was on their feet when I started voting.
💬 Scott Willis: Point of order, Madam Speaker.
💬 DEPUTY SPEAKER: Well, I’ve made my point very clear. So I don’t want anyone trifling with the House. I’ll take a call from Scott Willis.
💬 Scott Willis: Thank you, Madam Speaker.
💬 DEPUTY SPEAKER: No, I’m not saying that. You said, “point of order”; I’m taking your point of order.
💬 Scott Willis: Madam Speaker, you asserted that I was not on my feet when you started the vote.
💬 DEPUTY SPEAKER: Yes, I am. And I’m going to—
💬 Scott Willis: I was on my feet when you started the vote.
💬 DEPUTY SPEAKER: No, you weren’t. I started taking the vote, and I’m going to continue taking the vote.
The question is that the motion be agreed to.
Motion agreed to.
Bill read a third time.
💬 DEPUTY SPEAKER: Members, the House is adjourned and it will resume on Tuesday, 23 June 2026. Thank you.
The House adjourned at 9.20 p.m. (Saturday)
This early draft is automatically published - it is not yet complete and reviewed.
🗣️ Spoke in this debate (2)
- Cameron Brewer (New Zealand National Party — Member for Upper Harbour)
- Rachel Brooking (New Zealand Labour Party — Member for Dunedin)