Patents Amendment Bill
Mr Chair, thank you. This is a very short part. Again, Iām interested in the Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs explaining the legal mechanismāwhat these words in the bill are doing. Iām going to page 3 of the explanatory note, itās talking about transitional provisions for these divisional applications that will be filed after this bill comes into force but are dated before 13Ā SeptemberĀ 2014. These divisional applications continue to be treated as patent applications made under that old 1953 Act, with some exceptions; you can see what the exceptions are in the drafting. The grounds for opposing the grant of a patent and the procedure the commissioner must follow if a grant is opposed to itāso my question here is: what is the point, here, of allowing these to still be treated as if they were under the 1953 Act? Are all the bits and pieces that follow, that are in the drafting, strong enough to make it a legal fiction that it is under the 1953 Act, really itās being treated as if itās under the 2013, Actāand is that the mechanism here; is that whatās happening?
Thank you, Mr Chair, and tÄnei anÅ te mihi ki te Minita e noho ana i tÄnei pÅ [I acknowledge once again the Minister, here in this session tonight].
In my contribution earlier, I talked about mÄtauranga MÄori. I want to ask how in these transitions, applications which include mÄtauranga MÄori, MÄori intellectual property, will be managedāthe transition of these? Has the Ministry of Business, Innovation and Employment, or anyone, consulted with iwi or MÄori business or MÄori research institutes about how the impacts of these transitional changes will be managed; if so, who, and what concerns were raised, and how will those be managed?
I will talk to my officials about the level of consultation that the member raises. This Part 2 is very much the operative part of the bill.
The Hon Rachel Brooking was asking these as she read them out: āAre they strong enough?ā The short answer is yes. The explanatory note, as she alluded to for Part 2, page 3, takes the reader through the new transitional provisions for divisional applications filed after commencement. The advice that I have here for the new transitional provisions for the 1953 divisional applications after commencement are replicated in the official advice I have. What she has, I have.
Exactly. Iāve asked a very specific question. MÄtauranga MÄori is going to be a major implication in this. We know that, for example, commercially, itās quite difficult sometimes to quantify the commercial value, but itās definitely going to be an issue when weāre considering patents. Iāve asked very specifically how that will be managed in this transition phase.
š¬ Carl Bates: Mr Chair.
š¬ Hon Member: Mr Chair.
CHAIRPERSON (Greg O'Connor): Cushla Tangaere-Manuel.
Mr Chair, I would like an answer to that question, and I donāt either member standing up opposite can answer it.
Oh, Iād back both of them, but I am seeking some advice to the member. If itās not given within this time, the officials will no doubt be available for a few minutes at the conclusion of this to give that advice, but we are seeking it.
The place for advice to be put on the record, on Hansard, is here, and so if the officials have advice around Cushla Tangaere-Manuelās question around mÄtauranga MÄori, this is the place to do it. Itās a really important question and one that hasnāt come up a lot in this debate. Now, I can accept, and certainly for me, itās not a question that Iād be able to answer off the cuff, and I appreciate the Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs needs to take advice on this, but in this situation, Iām very happy to pause for officials to provide that adviceābutās itās not appropriate for us to conclude this debate whilst officials are preparing advice to give to the Minister so that he can stand up in the House of Representatives and give an appropriate and fulsome answer on an important question. If he didnāt understand that question, or if officials need further detail of that question, Iām sure my colleague will be more than happy to assist.
CHAIRPERSON (Greg O'Connor): Likewise, if the Minister did want to take advice, we canāor they can give an answer to satisfy the committee.
I can sense weāre drawing to an end here, possibly, on Part 2, because it is the operative part of the bill, and the advice that the members have sought is the advice that I have and that they have in the five-page bill, and so thatās what itās worth. But I suppose Iād ask the member to just reiterate the advice sheās seeking and then letās get the official response and then letās get it on the record.
Happily, Mr Chair. As the Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs has acknowledged, this is the operational part of the bill. Iām asking specifically: mÄtauranga MÄori, when it comes to patents, especially as we encourage innovation and the commercialisation and the risks around that of mÄtauranga MÄori and protecting that, is going to be a key part of operationalising this bill. What Iām seeking to understand is: what advice have they got about managing that? Who have they spoken to? What, if any concernsā
š¬ Carl Bates: Out of scope.
š¬ Dr Hamish Campbell: This is closing a loophole.
I love how you guys are interjecting when the Ministerās still seeking advice on this. You guys are not helping. The Ministerās paying respect to this very important issue and so interjections are not appropriate because otherwise youād be in that seat. What Iām asking is what advice has been sought, from whom, what solutions or issues have they raised, and how will mÄtauranga MÄori be protected as we transition into operationalising this bill?
CHAIRPERSON (Greg O'Connor): As a way through this impasse, Minister, if you would like to seek advice, or if there is none available, state that for the record now. I think that will be quite important given this is what will allow us to move on from here.
Thank you, Mr Chair. Iāll answer the question as best as officials can give it to me. I was not part of the Economic Development, Science and Innovation Committee process, but that may have been canvassed in the process. It may have been canvassed by the Labour Government in Cabinet committee in 2020, so Iām sure that itās been traversed even in the broader sense, but let me see if weāve got some advice ready to go. Iāll make sure I can read it first and then hopefully we can move on.
[Confers with officials] Itās not patentable? OK. MÄtauranga is not patentable, but the direct consultation has not happened in the scope of this bill.
CHAIRPERSON (Greg O'Connor): Sorry, I heard thatāsorry, weāll need toā
Sorry, wasnāt I microphoned? What the member was asking forāand apologies for my pronunciationāmÄtauranga MÄori is not patentable is the advice Iām getting. It is not an invention. It would be good to be able to read this writing, but the advice is that itās well outside the scope, and the consultation that she is asking for has not happened at the level that she has requested.
I move, That debate on this question now close.
Motion agreed to.
CHAIRPERSON (Greg O'Connor): Arena Williamsā tabled amendment to clauseĀ 7, new section 258A(1)(a), inserting āas applicableā, is out of order as being of no legislative effect.
The question is that Arena Williamsā tabled amendment to clause 7, new section 258A(1)(b), replacing āon or afterā with āafterā, be agreed to.
Amendment not agreed to.
CHAIRPERSON (Greg O'Connor): The question is that Arena Williamsā tabled amendment to clause 7, new section 258A(1)(c), replacing ābefore 13 September 2014ā with ābefore the commencement of the Patents Act 2013ā, be agreed to.
Amendment not agreed to.
CHAIRPERSON (Greg O'Connor): The question is that Arena Williamsā tabled amendment to clause 7, inserting new section 258A(1)(d) reading āThe parent application remains pending.ā be agreed to.
Amendment not agreed to.
CHAIRPERSON (Greg O'Connor): Arena Williamsā five tabled amendments to clause 7, new section 258A(4) are out of order as not being in the correct form of legislation.
Part 2 agreed to.
Committee of the whole House
Clauses 1 to 3
CHAIRPERSON (Greg O'Connor): Members, we come to our final debate, clauses 1 to 3āāTitleā, āCommencementā, and āPrincipal Actā.
š£ļø Spoke in this debate (5)
- Miles Anderson (New Zealand National Party ā Member for Waitaki)
- Cameron Brewer (New Zealand National Party ā Member for Upper Harbour)
- Rachel Brooking (New Zealand Labour Party ā Member for Dunedin)
- Cushla Tangaere-Manuel (New Zealand Labour Party ā Member for Ikaroa-RÄwhiti)
- Dr Duncan Webb (New Zealand Labour Party ā Member for Christchurch Central)