Patents Amendment Bill
Thank you, Mr Speaker. Look, I think itās really important for me to point out that the Economic Development, Science and Innovation Committee is a split committee. Itās one of those committees where thereās equal voice. I think thatās really important to mention while we remind everyone that there were no amendments tabled at the time. With that, I commend the bill to the House.
Kia ora, Mr Speaker. I think it was Monday of Tuesday night last week, and I was ironing my shirt, as I do, and I had Checkpoint replaying in my earphonesāyouāre all gripped by the story already. But it was really fascinating, because there was a 17-year-old student from, I think, Lynfield College in AucklandāAucklanders might be able to correct me on thatātalking about something that she and, I think, three other students had designed. It was a Safe and Sound crocheted animal key chain. This was a little wee invention that theyād made as part of the Young Enterprise Scheme programme, or one of those sort of innovation business groups.
These young students didnāt want to have to create this, and the success of the product they have designed and will patent is something they want to go out of style, because it is actually a panic alarm. The fact that these 17-year-old school students in Aucklandāthe innovation they found because of the concerns theyāve had and some incidents theyāve experience was to create these little crocheted little keychains that look harmless and look like just cutesy-cutes, but, actually, when you hit the button, it sends off a huge alarm and it squeals, and everybody around knows. As they talked to the Checkpoint reporter, it was very much around the fact that thereās been several sad incidents where they did panic, but there was no support that came, in terms of just local people there at the time, because they didnāt realise what was going on. They have created and want to patent these little wee Safe and Sound crocheted animal key chains that they can sell, and, hopefully, one day, theyāll go out of style and out of fashion.
I guess that is part of the reason why weāre here this evening, having this discussion and talking about this legislation, because it is around how we make sureāas several colleagues have already said, to be able to patent something is about being able to be innovative. Having intellectual property (IP) is around the protection for a creator of what they have, and itās allowing them to earn the recognition but also, potentially, the money and the opportunities that come with that.
As we look at this billāand we do support itāI think of the many innovative companies throughout New Zealand that innovate every day. I thinkāI was at Fieldays last year, and Iāll be there again next monthāof Zespri, and the innovation and the IP that they have in terms of what theyāre doing to ensure the āNew Zealand Inc.ā story is sold to the world. I look at Fisher & Paykel Healthcare and the work that theyāre doing, and the innovation and the patents that are necessary for them not only to be able to take a product to the world but, obviously, to be able to create an income for their company and for their staff. Youāve got the Gallagher Group, youāve got Fonterra research and developmentāand, of course, then there was Halter, which I think is now on the global stock exchange. Itās one of those companies that, again, we need to make sure that we are getting our patents right and ensure that, basically, the legislation is fit for purpose.
Weāre happy to support this bill. Thereās a whole lot more I can say around the 1953 Act, but I think Iāll save that for some of the committee of the whole House stage, and maybe a bit more in the third reading.
Thanks, and itās a great honour to rise and speak in support of the Patents Amendment Bill in the second reading. This bill quite simply closes the loophole that allowed the continued use of outdated, low-quality patent standards. Therefore, I commend the bill to the House.
Kia orana, Mr Speaker, meitaki maata. Well, yesterday, it was the Regulatory Systems (Internal Affairs) Amendment Bill with a focus on Fire and Emergency New Zealand (FENZ) valuation of land, rather than the real issues that FENZ are facing right now, and today of course itās the Patents Amendment Bill. Here we are, at 8.05 p.m. on a Saturday night, debating what the Government considers to be of such significance for Budget urgency.
š¬ Katie Nimon: The whole agenda.
Oh, look, they chirp up over there, Katie Nimonāthatās right. Iād be worried if I was you, Katie Nimon, because while youāve been here, Dr Alex Hedley has been working hard in Napier.
š¬ Carl Bates: Who? Who?
Ohāoh, thereās Carl Bates. Yes, Angela Roberts, sheās been working hard in Whanganui, and Mr Costley, Sophie Handford, well, she spent half the day at the Paraparaumu market while youāve been stuck here today.
I actually get it. It suddenly dawned on me as to why the Government has loaded this Budget urgency with bills that actually could be dealt with some other time. Itās because the Budget was so bad, they donāt actually want to go back into their electorates, because people in their electorates will tell them that the Budget has nothing to deal with the cost of living crisisāit has nothing to deal with jobs, health, homes, or the cost of living. Theyāre going to try and drag this out for as long as they can because they canāt face the reality that people are doing it tough and that their Budget has delivered no relief for them this year.
Here we are, on to the billāthe Patents Amendment Bill. This is interesting. The other thing someone said from the Government benches is, āOh, well, there were a whole pile of amendments tabledā, and they were surprised by that. Iāll tell you what I was surprised about: the Government introduced a gas bill that hadnāt even had its first reading, and they had to put a whole pile of Amendment Papersā
š¬ Glen Bennett: Whoopsie!
āon the Table. Whoopsie all rightāwhoopsie! There we go. In terms of the Patents Amendment Bill, this is quite a legal approach, and there are a number of aspects to itā1953 through to 2013, and we agreed to it in 2020, and now here we are in 2026 trying to make things work.
This is, again, something weāve heard from the Economic Development, Science and Innovation Committee. They reported this back to the House in November of last year. Itās a brief report; there were a number of submittersā14, I think, that submitted. Itās really interesting reading through the select committeeās report that touches on a few things. There are two sides of the coin: some submitters say that, actually, it might hinder things because theyāre going to keep applying in terms of applications continuously being pending, so thatās obviously an administrative hurdle; youāve got others on the other side of the coin who are saying, actually, no, the fact that the pending applications under the 1953 Act is unlimited, perhaps that might place a little bit of a limitation in that space.
Then of course, you have comment from the select committee that says thereās a role here for the Patents Commissioner, which, I must say, thatās news to me. The comment that they make in their report is that they understand the commissioner is experienced in examining patents under both the 1953 Act and the 2013 Act standards. That might be so in terms of the person who currently fulfils that role and responsibility, but there does need to be a legislatively clear provision in there, so that regardless of the level of experience someone might have around that, theyāre able to go ahead and do that.
As I understand it, this is a bill that will relate to intellectual propertyāor IPāand obviously what weāre talking about there are creations of the mind, inventions, whether artistic, literaryāall of those sorts of things. Iām sure weāll hear a little bit more about that as we quiz the Minister. Iām sure heās looking forward to that at the committee of the whole House stage. We do support this bill, but, yet again, itās a shame that the Government has had to utilise urgencyā
š¬ Hon Kieran McAnulty: They didnāt have to.
āin order toāand they didnāt have to do this. They didnāt have to do this. But we know, weāll keep on going because, as I say, they wonāt want to get back to their electorates because the Budget was crap.
Itās a pleasure to take my first call on this Budget motion. It was a great Budget, focused on fixing the basicsā
š¬ Katie Nimon: Reallyāfirst call?
āyeah, thatās right, Katie Nimonāand building the future. There are lots of things to be proud of in there. Weāve heard a lot of commentary about the Budget, like the three-day post-natal stays and the patents, because this is going to help that $2.5 billion commitment for defenceāand like Scion. I commend this bill to the House.
TÄnÄ koe e te MÄngai o te Whare. TÄnÄ koutou katoa. I am more than happy to be spending the evening here in PÅneke tonight because it keeps me so close to the southern end of my beautiful electorate Ikaroa-RÄwhiti, where tomorrow night the Hon Ginny Andersen and I will be attending the 80th jubilee of the WainuiÅmata Rugby Football Club, and we cannot wait. Because I know that you are all interested, I am proud to report that NgÄti Porou East Coast are, in fact, taking the Anaru āSkipā Paenga Memorial Trophy back up the coastābig mihi to the Poverty Bay Weka, as well.
Speaking of invention and innovation, thatās one of the proudest things in being from Aotearoa. When I was young, one of the worst jobs we hadābecause most people lived rurally or on farmsāwas opening the gates. One of the most common phrases that would come out of my and my siblingsā mouths was āBags not open the gate.ā, but my great-grandfather Papa had one those counterweight gates, and I thought that it was the best invention in the world. Did he invent it? No, but it just speaks to the innovation of New Zealanders, and that was the one gate I loved in my life. Thatās why you need to protect patentsābecause my Papa is going around making all these gates.
Heoi anÅ rÄ, as my esteemed colleagues have mentioned, across this side of the House we do support this bill. This is something that weāve been supporting since 2020 and mai rÄ anÅ. Why? Because we want to support and encourage innovation. We want to make sure our reputationāthe number eight wire Kiwi reputationāfor ingenuity and innovation is encouraged but also protected.
On the āoriginalā 28 May, Ikaroa-RÄwhiti was acknowledged for having some of the best produce in the country and probably in the world, and, as we know, some of our growers in the Hawkeās Bay, in particular, are facing tough times. They are not struggling to grow the best produce in the world, but at a time when theyāre struggling, we need to protect the growers as well as the workers so that any new innovations are, in fact, new and weāre not putting another layer of costs on people who are already struggling in Aotearoa by selling them some sort of new doodackie that actually isnāt, in fact, new. āDoodackieāāmy Papa probably invented that, too!
The other whakaaro, speaking with my MÄori economy hat on, is thinking, while we support this, about how we protect not just MÄori entrepreneurs and innovators but also truly protect mÄtauranga MÄori. Itās all the rage right now, and we know that weāve got some amazing gamers, gameāwhat do you call themāwhoā
š¬ Hon Ginny Andersen: They show games.
No, butā
š¬ Hon Ginny Andersen: They develop the model.
The game developers. Because the world is on to the value of our stories as MÄori and our culture, they love the warrior nature of our culture, and so thatās very appealing when youāre developing a game. Itās one thing to have the nous to understand the technology and develop a gameāwe want to protect thatābut also we want to protect those who truly understand the intellectual property that is mÄtauranga MÄori.
While we support this bill, and we have been criticised for putting amendments to itāthatās the point. Labour is a considered party. While we on this side of the House support things, we want to make sure that every angle of this bill is considered so that we donāt end up here, listening to pitiful, 10-second defences of legislation. When weāre in Government, we are only going to consider bills that value the people who put us here. Weāre not out. Given those whakaaro i tÄnei pÅ, I commend the bill to the House.
Thank you, Mr Speaker. Unlike the Opposition, we understand that details matter, and so this bill is going to reduce regulatory risks for businesses by improving patent quality and discouraging weak or vague patents. Itās part of fixing the basics and building the future. I commend it to the House.
I have great pleasure in commending this bill to the House. Thank you, Mr Speaker.
Motion agreed to.
Bill read a second time.
ASSISTANT SPEAKER (Teanau Tuiono): The Patents Amendment Bill is now set down for committee stage immediately. I declare the House in committee for consideration of the Patents Amendment Bill.
Committee of the whole House
Part 1 Amendments to existing provisions
CHAIRPERSON (Barbara Kuriger): Members, the House is in committee on the Patents Amendment Bill. We come first to the debate on Part 1. This is the debate on clauses 4 to 6, āAmendments to existing provisionsā. The question is that Part 1 stand part.
š£ļø Spoke in this debate (8)
- Carl Bates (New Zealand National Party ā Member for Whanganui)
- Glen Bennett (New Zealand Labour Party ā List Member)
- Dr Hamish Campbell (New Zealand National Party ā Member for Ilam)
- Tim Costley (New Zealand National Party ā Member for Åtaki)
- Katie Nimon (New Zealand National Party ā Member for Napier)
- Suze Redmayne (New Zealand National Party ā Member for RangitÄ«kei)
- Cushla Tangaere-Manuel (New Zealand Labour Party ā Member for Ikaroa-RÄwhiti)
- Tangi Utikere (New Zealand Labour Party ā Member for Palmerston North)