Financial Service Providers (Registration and Dispute Resolution) Amendment Bill
Madam Chair, thank you. I want to bring the Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs to a couple of questions about why this rules provision doesn’t include the changes that he intends to make.
This is a relatively unusual way of drafting a regulatory change: either you could leave the change in regulations to the regulation maker or you could complete the changes to regulations as you envision them to be and include that in the primary legislation set out to change the regulation. What this purports to do is to exclude the effect of two particular rules from any other rules, and then any consequential changes are also legal. That is an unusual way of doing it, because it means that anyone reading the provisions can’t tell what they will actually say when the rule changes have been made. We are Parliament are being asked to verify that without that happening. I want to ask the Minister whether he has in mind what the rules will look like when those changes are made. Has he seen that? Can we rest assured by him that he has considered how the rules will operate?
Secondly, I just want to ask him why the regulations weren’t able to be amended and included in this part in the normal way so that the primary legislation could have empowered that—just on the general principle that the regulations should be known and knowable. Even if they do apply only to these four schemes, these four schemes have thousands of people they represent.
Thank you, Madam Chair. I am just going to outline this once, because, as we know, this is the size of Part 2—exhibit A, Part 2. I think I only need to stand up once and then we rule a line under it.
This is a transitional provision. We’re looking at amending Schedule 1AA here. This is a limited transitional measure to enable schemes to move from scheme rules related to shifting to Minister directed independent review without necessary process or delay. This is an administrative tidy up to support the transition to the new review framework. It’s narrow. It’s time limited. Let’s get on with it.
Thank you, Madam Chair. I do appreciate the Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs’ response to this, but I also want to, I guess, remind him and also the committee that, when we debated the Therapeutic Products Act Repeal Bill, that was a one-page bill that repealed 300 pages of primary legislation. I guess, in this particular case, while this section is small, the repercussions could potentially be quite significant, which is what the previous speaker, Arena Williams, was referring to. In this case, we’re look at the Schedule, particularly Part 3, clause 5(a). This is to do with what has already been repealed: section 63(1)(q).
My understanding, when we were looking at sections 65 and 66 of the primary legislation, is around notifications when it comes to the change of rules, as well as the criteria for the change of rules itself. Would it be correct, then, to assume that, with the repeal of section 63(1)(q), it is exempted, if changes are made as a result of that, from both the reporting requirement and the changes requirement? If the Minister wouldn’t mind—again, I do not see this in the select committee report, as well, so I don’t know if this is something that officials provided as a part of that. How many rules will this potentially have the possibility of capturing, with the repeal of section 63(1)(q)?
CHAIRPERSON (Barbara Kuriger): I’m going to take one more question from Arena Williams, and it had better be a good one!
OK, Madam Chair. I just want to ask the Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs if this is the place for the insertion of a new part into the Schedule that would introduce a review from the Regulations Review Committee. The reason I ask that here is that there are rule changes here that are not specified in the primary legislation and are also rules that are anticipated. These are changes that anticipate a rule change that Parliament can’t see, so I am asking him to consider my amendment that would enable the Regulations Review Committee to review this—it’s well within its jurisdiction to review this; it is the correct committee to do so—and then to report to the House within a year.
There are other pieces of legislation that delegate that authority to the Regulations Review Committee. I am thinking here of the Severe Weather Emergency Recovery Legislation Act orders, which the Minister will be familiar with, but other legislation does that too. It’s not an unusual provision. The reason I ask it is because regulation should be explicitly empowered by primary legislation. This does it backwards: it explicitly empowers the change, but it doesn’t say what the change is. We should have something, either him or the Regulations Review Committee, to check that the actual changes in the regulations reflect the initial legislation This is a good place to put it. It is also a place where you could put it and apply it to Part 1, and he has considered my amendments around that topic.
I move, That debate on this question now close.
A party vote was called for on the question, That debate on this question now close.
Ayes 67
New Zealand National 48; ACT New Zealand 11; New Zealand First 8.
Noes 43
New Zealand Labour 28; Green Party of Aotearoa New Zealand 13; Ferris; Kapa-Kingi.
Motion agreed to.
Part 2 agreed to.
CHAIRPERSON (Barbara Kuriger): We’re now on to the Schedule, with no debate. The question is that Arena Williams’ tabled amendment to the Schedule, to new clause 5(a) of Schedule 1AA, to insert “and section 63(1)(h)” be agreed to.
A party vote was called for on the question, That the amendment be agreed to.
Ayes 43
New Zealand Labour 28; Green Party of Aotearoa New Zealand 13; Ferris; Kapa-Kingi.
Noes 67
New Zealand National 48; ACT New Zealand 11; New Zealand First 8.
Amendment not agreed to.
Schedule agreed to.
Committee of the whole House
Clauses 1 to 3
CHAIRPERSON (Barbara Kuriger): Members, we come now to our final debate, clauses 1 to 3, the debate on “Tile”, “Commencement”, and “Principal Act”.
🗣️ Spoke in this debate (4)
- Cameron Brewer (New Zealand National Party — Member for Upper Harbour)
- Ryan Hamilton (New Zealand National Party — Member for Hamilton East)
- Arena Williams (New Zealand Labour Party — Member for Manurewa)
- Dr Lawrence Xu-Nan (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand — List Member)