Credit Contracts and Consumer Finance Amendment Bill
I move, That Credit Contracts and Consumer Finance Amendment Bill be now read a third time.
The bill continues this Governmentâs focus on reducing excessive regulatory burden that has accumulated over successive reforms to the Credit Contracts and Consumer Finance Act (CCCFA). This bill is about ensuring consumer credit is regulated in a way that is effective, proportionate, and that makes sense within the wider regulatory landscape.
The Financial Markets Authority (FMA) is the conduct regulator for the financial markets. It doesnât make a lot of sense to have a different regulator responsible for consumer credit. This bill simplifies the regulatory landscape by transferring functions under the CCCFA from the Commerce Commission to the FMA. This puts the FMA in a position to regulate consumer credit consistent with its approach to other financial markets.
When the FMA takes over from the Commerce Commission on 1 July this year, this bill will give it the regulatory tools to effectively protect the interests of consumers. This includes, among other things, improved oversight of lenders through the FMAâs licensing regime, and other administrative powers such as direction orders that enable the FMA to respond swiftly to breaches of the CCCFA.
It is also important that liability settings in the CCCFA are proportionate. This bill does this in three ways. It removes a due diligence duty and intendent personal liability for directors and for senior managers. The changes Iâve just outlined make this form of liability unnecessary. The bill also addresses two issues with how the CCCFA assigns liability for the costs of borrowing, in the event a lender has breached certain disclosure requirements.
The first issue, as this House well knows, is a historical one. The bill backdates reforms made in 2019 to protect the market from redress that the courts consider unjust. This has no impact on the class litigation against ANZ and ASB.
The second issue is an ongoing issue. To say that lenders are liable for the full costs of borrowing until they have fixed the disclosure breach is the wrong starting point when the breach was trivial or otherwise harmless. The bill addresses this for new loan agreements without removing this form of redress for borrowers.
The bill has its origin in policies announced over two years ago. I want to conclude by thanking everyone who has contributed to its development and evolution. I want to thank the Hon Andrew Bayly, I want to thank the Hon Scott Simpsonâmy predecessors. I want to thank officials and the many individuals and organisations who took time to make submissions on the CCCFA amendment bill, both during policy development and at select committee.
Just on the select committeeâthe hard-working Finance and Expenditure Committee (FEC), now chaired by Ryan Hamilton and deputy chaired by Dan Bidoisâthe FEC studied these reforms, worked through submissions, and developed some very sensible changes. The net result of all this thought and effort is a bill that I am confident will improve how effectively and efficiently consumer credit is regulated in New Zealand. I commend the bill to the House.
đŹ DEPUTY SPEAKER: The question is that the motion be agreed to.
Thank you, Madam Speaker. It is relevant, what the Minister has said, in his legislative statement to the House: that this bill gives effect to policy decisions that were made two years ago and built on the work of the Labour Government in reforming consumer credit access to make sure that the rules were proportionate to the risk and to ensure that our financial systemâthat level of controls within organisations is robust.
That is why it may surprise some of the members sitting around the House to be sitting here in what is, technically, Thursday of a Budget week, in this period that is well understood to be a free hit for the Government, where it is encouraged, even, that the Government would pass legislation that is to do with the Budget and to give effect to their financial decisions which are empowered by the Budget in a period of urgency, which is well understood and largely well-supported by major parties within the House. It is important that the Government would be able to give effect to those things which relate to Budget documents and Budget policy decisions as soon as possible when theyâve been announced and they affect ordinary peopleâs lives.
But this is a piece of legislation which was first mooted in May 2025. Why was it delayed, you might ask. Well, it went swiftly to select committee, which the Minister has alluded to; he was the chair of it at the time. And we embarked swiftly on a programme of work to hear from submitters.
It was important for submitters to be able to have their say, because it emerged, in the course of submissions, that thousands of New Zealanders were owed debts by two banks that posted a total profit of about $6 billion in that financial year, and the Government was seeking to forgive those debts at the point they crystalised, which was in a class action litigation before the courts at the time the committee considered it.
So the delay, from the Labour Governmentâs introduction of laws to tidy up this process of credit contracts and then for the bill that was seeking to change the way that consumers were able to bring claims against their banks, not only from the date of the legislation but before the legislation was enactedâthat delay happened because there was pushback from those people who would have lost hundreds, if not thousands, of dollars that they were owed, that accrued during the period of 2015 to 2019.
I want to read you the sort of correspondence that was received by those people when one of the banks let them know after the select committee made what was a sensible changeâthousands of people around New Zealand, mums and dads who had mortgages on their homes, received a letter that said something like âDear Tom, on 5 October 2025, ASB agreed to settle the representative proceeding commonly referred to as a class action that related to ASB customers who held a home or personal loan.â Those customers then duly went and checked their bank accounts and found that they had between $300 to thousands of dollars that had turned up overnight.
That is more than any tax cut would have netted them. That is more than what the Government have offered them in things like childcare subsidies. These are people who are struggling with rising costs of groceries, of electricity bills, and of their personal banking services. For that to happen at that time was incredibly important to them, and that was through a series of really great submissions by ordinary people who came along to the committee and told the committee exactly how this would affect them. Parties around the House all accept the National Party, at that time, began to agree that it was unfair for consumers to have to shoulder that burden.
That reason why we are here in Budget urgency debating this bill is because it has been an embarrassing attempt at a law change which would have required the Government to run roughshod over the rights of thousands of ordinary New Zealanders, and then an embarrassing backdown, because minor parties and opposite partiesâLabour and the Greens includedâadvocated consistently for the Government to change their minds, and they eventually did.
The delay, and the reason why it has taken two years to get to this policy point, is important to understand. What does it truly say about how we make law in this country? One, that we simply donât have the appropriate safeguards for this kind of decision making. At all stages, Ministers and officials were contacted by the New Zealand Banking Association, by banks themselves, and by corporate lawyers who did not have to disclose that they were acting in the interests of the banks, to advocate for a policy change which would have created this debt forgiveness regime.
It was unfair when they asked Labour for it in 2017. It was unfair when they asked John Key for it and Jacqui Dean for it in 2016. It was unfair when they asked Kris Faafoi for it in 2019. But this Government relied on not only the official advice, where the New Zealand Banking Association also had access to officials, but on their own decisions also based on the advice of the Reserve Bank that accepted the New Zealand Banking Associationâs number of $12 billion worth of financial risk to the New Zealand financial system. That number was unreasonable; officials should not have relied on it, and it continues to be an example of where going back through the timeline shows that we are not getting the right kind of information about these kinds of risks before they come to light.
And yet, the Finance and Expenditure Committee did make the right decision. The committee made the right decision to leave, essentially, those two cases to work their way through the courts. One of those banks saw the writing on the wall and made the refunds that it needed to make to its customers, and so we have thousands of happy customers, who are happy that National changed their mind on this. But there are still thousands of customers out there who are owed money by ANZ, and it would be unusual in this House to name one corporate entity, but it is directly relevant to this legislation. Because now that Parliament has given a clear indication of whether the law should or should not apply, that is a corporate organisation that owes money at this point in time, and a court has decided that it owes money at this point in time. It owes debts, and every day that passes is a debt that it has not repaid to consumers. New Zealanders who are owed money by ANZ should rightly be assured that this Parliament stands behind that debt because of this decision. That is still working its way through the courts, and they are entitled to do that, but it is important that this decision stands as a decision that was unanimously supported at the committee stage.
Even if youâre not an ASB or ANZ customer, decisions like this matterâthe implications matter. Consumer law is tough for a reason. Weâve had a National Minister in the last three weeks stand on the stage in front of a competition conference and up penalties for corporates who make mistakes in things that they do with consumers. Why? Because consumers canât negotiate every contract that they enter into with their grocer, with their bank, with their energy company. The disparate power between those two entities is huge, so itâs important that the penalties for getting something wrong if you are the larger entity are fair and appropriate and large. But this kind of lawmaking says very clearly two things: (1) if you are a corporate entity and you muck up, you can wait for a Government like this to fix it for you, and we are seeing more and more of that, not only with this case but with the Uber decision and with Fonterraâs climate litigation. That is a problem. The law should be known and knowable at the time. It should be enforced by the courts and by Parliament alike.
The second thing is that it tells the incumbents and challenger banks something important about the way the banking system works in New Zealand. There are countries that we sometimes compare ourselves to that will tell banks what Government thinks they should do, and banks will act on that under the proviso that they will be protected by their Governments. Jurisdictions that have that kind of arrangement between banks and Governments rely on a flow of information between banks and information that is not like our open economy has. Our open economy relies on incumbents and challenger banks being treated in the same way. But, if I was Revolut, looking to open cheaper banking services in New Zealand, I would back off fast, because what this decision shows is that a National Government has the interests of incumbent banks top and centre when it is considering legislation that will affect competition in this market. It is important that Governments are open to challenges, especially when they are telling the public that we need more competition in a sector like banking.
Finally, it also is a bill that should have improved the settings around buy now, pay later. Because of this Governmentâs change to the settings, which was advocated by one minor party that got less than the constituency vote of New Zealand First, it was a decision that meant that Zip can charge $40 every purchase for young people who use it as a credit product, Afterpay can charge $68, and financial hardship cases that financial mentors are seeing have gone up by 700 in the year since that was introduced. There is more hardship because of the lack of change in these rules. This is a bill that should have sorted out buy now, pay later as a proper credit consumer contract; it did not, and therefore this is a failure of a bill. We thought we might be able to support it at this stage; we cannot. It does not improve things for consumers, it sends all the wrong signals, and this Government should hang its head in shame.
Thank you, Madam Speaker. I also want to reflect on the fact that weâre having this third reading under urgency. It is deeply puzzling that on a week thatâs supposed to be about the Government advancing its priorities in relation to the Budget, we are rushing a third reading of a bill that, in my view, has had a shambolic process and has actually, in my view, required countless ordinary people having their voices made loud and clear for the Government to concede that what they were about to do was to make laws that were taking the side of huge banks as opposed to everyday people exercising their power to take on big corporates through the judicial system.
I want to reflect that this follows on from a really, really concerning pattern of legislative behaviour and actions from this Government. The previous speaker commented on how the Government also overrode the case that people took against Uber, for example. Yes, this is such a prime example of the Government once again taking the side of big corporatesâthe same thing with Fonterra. I want to acknowledge first of all the people who took these proceedings to court, because that would not have been easy. Itâs not easy to take on big banks at the court, let alone win.
I think what is particularly concerning in the case of this legislation, if we look at the journey of the legislation, is that previous Governments had actually held their ground against lobbying from banks that sought to allow them to effectively have this debt forgiveness regime. Itâs really clear that thereâs been a shift of attitude and behaviour from this Government towards that kind of approach from big banks.
After the select committee stage, we had huge concerns at that point that the retrospectivity component was not yet addressed. Iâm glad that at least the National Party saw the lightâand potentially, I guess, the electoral consequencesâof going ahead with the bill as it was during the select committee. I think they realised that voters were likely about to punish them if they continued keeping the retrospectivity and allowed to override the proceeds of Simons and Others v ANZ Bank New Zealand Limited and ASB Bank Limited. I think that the amendments that were put forward later on were an acknowledgment that you cannot just trample on peopleâs dignity and contributions when they are telling the Government crystal-clear that their decisions are about to take the side of huge corporates.
While we are glad that the Government and particularly the National Party took this approach to back down from some of the retrospectivity components, I think that the changes to ensure consequences for disclosure failures are still, in my view, problematic. I want to make it clear that the Green Party does not support this bill. I think, as the previous speaker noted, this bill, if anything, had an opportunity to actually strengthen consumer protections and simplify enforcements under the Credit Contracts and Consumer Finance Act, but weâre not actually making the most of the opportunity to actually look at this wholesomely. In fact, what I think was also a shame, if I reflect back on the select committee sessions that I had a privilege to sub in onâand I want to acknowledge my colleagues Francisco Hernandez and ChlĂśe Swarbrick, who have been, during this term, permanent members, as well as the other members who have been permanent members of that select committee, and I do want to give a shout out to Arena Williams, who I know has been very diligent in the scrutiny of this bill.
Those members ended up taking, in my view, the majority of the time for the scrutiny of this bill to address the component of the retrospectivity. In my view, thatâs a shame, because I think this bill in and of itself actually presented an opportunity to look at a range of broader issues. Buy now, pay later is another issue that I think the member Arena Williams described had merit being addressed in this bill but wasnât. I do think this is a shame, because youâre not looking at the equity components of what bills like this one could genuinely address.
If you look at, again, the process that we undertook for this bill, now that weâre finally at the third reading, I think it cannot be said in the context of the fact that, at every stage, when we have other procedures such as inquiries into banking competition and we have the Government talking about wanting to enhance competition within the banking sector but then sends signals, through bills like this one, that, actually, big banks will continue being favoured, basically, when it comes to competition laws. Or even legislation here versus, say, for example, outcomes of consumers. I think this sends a chilling effect to any potential competitor that wants to take on the likes of ASB and ANZ.
Now, these two players are not small, family-owned businesses that deserve attention from, or any pandering from, any Government, any political party, as it has been noted they have made humongous profits while ordinary people are literally having to take on debt simply to make ends meet. This is why I think this bill attracted a big amount of public and media attentionâbecause, again, it was people who were being generous enough to share during the select committee period the outcomes that this bill would have had if the retrospectivity component was not addressed.
I know that we heard not just from clients and people who may have been taking part of the class action, we heard from legal experts and consumer advocates. When weâve got experts that continuously get dismissed and ignored, brushed off, when weâve got experts who questioned, for example, the numbers that were presented by officials in terms of the financial risk, I am concerned that this goes back to a pattern of behaviour where people who actually hold expertiseâand I want to acknowledge that, across the whole of Parliament, no one is an expert in every portfolio and, therefore, we rely on people who actually have trained, have spent their lives being experts in subject areas to actually contribute to bills like this one. When we see that expertise being brushed aside and perhaps only listened to for matters of electoral convenience, I worry that people are going to start wondering, âWell, what is the point?â
I want to reassure members of the public that this bill is also a great example that in numbers, there can be strength. When peopleâparticularly people who voted for political parties that are in Governmentâshow up and make it clear that support for Government parties is at risk due to decisions, that political parties can actually cave in to that pressure. This is why I want to, once again, commend that throughout this process people have made their voices loud and clear. They do not want a Government that takes sides with ANZ and ASB over everyday people.
I want to commend, or I want to at least acknowledge, the coalition parties in the Government, outside of National, who I know actually understood what was wrong with this bill. I can tell that they did. I want to particularly acknowledge that as a constructive element in an MMP environment, where, sometimes, those other political parties can actually play a decent role in actually putting pressure on the larger party to do the right thing and address some of the most problematic components of this bill.
Again, the amendment that was put during the committee of the whole House stage does not go far enough. I once again want to go back to the issue that, you know, successive Governments led by Labour or National have pushed back against the lobbying from the banks to make changes to the relationships to the debt collection regime. I hope that this is the last caseâthe last time that the National Party caves in to this pressure. We deserve a Government that actuallyâ
đŹ Ryan Hamilton: Read the bill.
RICARDO MENĂNDEZ MARCH: âtakes the side of everyday people as opposed to the big banks.
When I hear members of the opposite side say, âRead the billâ, well, you know, I invite them to make contributions that are more than 10 seconds. Because as far as Iâm aware, I am none the wiser, throughout this bill or other bills in every other debate, that they have actually read the bill when their contributions are 10 seconds long. I appreciate that, perhaps, they want to scrutinise my knowledge on the bill, but I invite them to show their own expertise on the bill by actually outlining the back-down that they took in the committee of the whole House stage.
So, like I said, on the whole, we are disappointed that this bill didnât actually do what was right for consumers, and the Green Party will not be supporting it in the third reading and question the use of urgency to rush it through at this time.
Thank you, Madam Speaker. Look, I rise to on behalf of ACT to speak in support of the Credit Contracts and Consumer Finance Amendment Bill. Itâs actually entirely appropriate that weâre dealing with this in Budget week, under urgency. Not only did we have to clean up a massive economic mess left by the last Government; they also wasted six years to actually make regulatory changes in important areas to New Zealanders.
This bill is proportionate. Itâs effective. Itâs cleaning up some red tape and regulations, and itâs making sure that credit and consumers are looked after. Weâre modernising this area of law, and I want to say that the Finance and Expenditure Committee let me do an excellent job in listening to submitters on a whole range of issues, not just the ones around the banking cases. This is an excellent piece of law. It actually is going to continue to support this Governmentâs economic agenda, and I commend it to the House.
I rise in support of the Credit Contracts and Consumer Finance Amendment Bill. This was one of the first bills that was put in front of me when I arrived in Parliament. Thank you very much for thatâquite difficult to get through some of the issues, and I thank members from the other side basically saying that the select committee âgot there in the endâ, which, I agree, it did. Iâd like to just sort of have a shout-out to the then committee chair, the Hon Cameron Brewer, who is now the Minister.
The thing I think probably gives me the most confidence here is moving to the Financial Markets Authority oversight of this kind of activity, which I think will help in the future. Weâre streamlining credit laws and strengthening regulatory oversight. Therefore, we commend this bill to the House.
đŹ DEPUTY SPEAKER: The next call is a split call.
Madam Speaker, thank you. I want to address a couple of the broader, I think, comments around this bill that weâve heard in the House. Particularly, I want to address the comments my colleague Ricardo MenĂŠndez March made around why this bill needed to be under urgency. We heard from the Minister that part of the reason is because this bill needs to take effect on 1 July. Now, as weâve seen with any bills that come through the House, this commencement date itself has been amended from the original date because the original date was a date set by Order in Council, which means that the day could actually be further amended.
There is no reason for this bill to actually be coming into the House under urgency, for two additional reasons. I think this is partly an indication that this Government has, for lack of a better term, run out of gas when it comes to legislation. Because the committee stage of this took place on Wednesday morning, 27 May 2026, which is technically three days ago by calendar days, but one day ago by House days. This bill could have had its third reading Wednesday afternoon. It, again, does not need to be in the House right now. While I admit that if thereâs no reason that this billâs commencement date can be altered from 1 July 2026âbearing in mind that there is still another week and a half of sitting weeks before that dateâit does bring into question why this and the subsequent bills we will be reading are coming into the House under urgency.
Potentially, maybe that particular Minister, being one of the newest Ministers, is one of the few people whoâs actually left from the teamâso, maybe, because being one of the junior Ministers, you get the short end of the straw when it comes to the bills that go through the House.
đŹ DEPUTY SPEAKER: Mr Xu-Nan, the current Ministerâand, actually, we donât talk about Ministers, and Iâm not suggesting you did, who are and arenât hereâbut the actual current Minister is actually right there.
đŹ Hon Cameron Brewer: Thereâs no such thing as a junior Minister.
Oh, absolutely. Sorry. I apologise, Madam Speakerânot junior Minister; Minister outside of Cabinet.
I do want to say that one of the disappointments with the committee stage for this particular bill is the fact that we werenât given an opportunity to have a full engagement with the Minister. I do hope that for the some of the subsequent bills that the Minister is in charge of that weâre going to be discussing, we will get the opportunity. We could have asked a little bit more around the enforcement when it comes to the Financial Markets Authority (FMA). I think we could have asked a little bit more around what exactly happened and around the timeline, when weâre looking at the potential retrospectivity which happened during the select committee stage and was later on taken out, and what that would involve in terms of the kind of responses that the Minister, as well as the officials and as well as the Government parties, received as a result of the class action when it comes to Simons & Ors v ANZ Bank New Zealand Limited and ASB Bank Limited.
On that particular part, even the fact that the Government parties have entertained the retrospectivity signals the priority of the National Government, when youâre looking at further punching down on everyday New Zealanders, to pander to their big corporation overlords. Weâve seen that with ASB and ANZ, which by way, as the previous speaker Arena Williams mentioned, make $6Â billion. That money, considering successive Governments sold ASP and ANZ to Australia, isnât going to be coming to New Zealand and going to be supporting our economy in that sense. But not only that: weâve heard about Uber, weâve heard about Fonterra, and weâve heard about the other areas, as well, and I think this bill is, in essence, a good step. Itâs something that we wanted to perfect and wanted to improve in the first reading and during the select committee stage, but I was disappointed in subsequent stages because of the changes. It also means that we couldnât actually ask the Minister, in that sense, around the enforcement aspect and the actual penalties. If youâre going to be making $6Â billion, what is a proportional penalty? This is why the Green Party will not be supporting this bill. It is not good anymore.
Can I firstly just acknowledge the new Minister of Commerce and Consumer Affairs and this being the first bill to go through the full suite and come into law. Thereâs been great shepherding-through by several Ministers, but itâs a great finale for Minister Brewer. Secondly, when Labour passed this in 2019, we recognised that this retrospectivity clause was a bit untidy. It was a promise made, and, today, itâs a promise delivered.
Thank you, Madam Speaker. Look, itâs great to be able to take call on the Credit Contracts and Consumer Finance Amendment Billâa bill without brackets in its title, which is a nice change from what weâve been talking about this morning. The junior Minister opposite, I think, just said that that weâve run out of time, and the good news is that we definitely havenât, which is great, because we are in this third reading, which means itâs the final opportunity for us to talk about what it is that we are not happy about in this bill.
I think whatâs important is to come back to the essence of what this bill sets out to do and who it sets out to do it for. Itâs talking about streamlining compliance, so my question is: for who? What it talks aboutâor what it should be talking aboutâis strengthening consumer protections, because what weâre talking about here is an environment where you might have an individual up against an incredibly large company. Weâve heard the scale of some of those annual turnover figures of some of our biggest banks. If you think about taking on a bank with a $6Â billion turnover, I know who Iâd be thinking probably has the most firepower and the most legal representation should it come to that. My question really is: if the aim is to simplify regulation, reduce compliance costs, and improve consumer outcomes, is that really what this bill is going to achieve?
Now, when it was in front of select committeeâand itâs good that there are some bills in this term of Government from this coalition Government that actually get the proper scrutinyâ
đŹ Ryan Hamilton: Heaps! Heaps! Heaps do.
âthat a select committee should provide. Someone on the other side shouted out âHeaps!â. I think there are a number of examples of billsâvery important bills; some even just in the last week in this Budget urgencyâthat have progressed through all stages without even getting near a select committee. Thatâs not good governance. Itâs not responsible lawmaking, but it is a pattern of behaviour that we continue to see from this Government.
What Iâve done is gone back to look at some of the 1,500 submissions that came to the select committee specifically about this bill, and Iâm going to go through each one of those submissionsâbut Iâm not, because I donât have time.
đŹ DEPUTY SPEAKER: You definitely donât have time.
Iâm going to look at a number of those submissions, and, particularly, Iâm going to look at submissions that advocate on behalf of individuals as opposed to submissions that were made by large corporations or by people paid to act and represent those large corporations and their interests in that select committee environment.
Iâm going to start with the Citizens Advice Bureau, who do incredible work in our communities. Weâve got an amazing Citizens Advice Bureau located down in New Brighton, so I want to give a big shout-out to Stowe and the team at Citizens Advice Bureau for the amazing work that they do to advocate for and support individuals in our community. Now, they particularly call out clause 12 of the bill, and they say they are very concerned about the implications of clause 12 of the bill and recommend that it is removed.
The reasons for this that it removes the requirement for continuing disclosure if the creditor maintains a website where the debtor can access information about their unpaid balance after each transaction. What youâre talking about here is an assumption, in lawâand it is an assumptionâthat every New Zealander has easy and ready access to online websites, to the connectivity that they need, and to the data that they have to pay for to do that. You are assuming that every New Zealander can readily and easily access that information online and that if the lender, the big corporation, makes it available online, that person can come and find it. That would be a great assumption to make if you had also committed to resolving the issue that we have in New Zealand about digital equity and the huge gaps that we see for many New Zealanders who are unable to enjoy the access to services that they are increasingly needing to be able to operate in New Zealand currently.
Weâve also seen this in some of the bills that weâve discussed in Budget urgency this week about the interface with Government departments like the Ministry of Social Development and the increasing use of digital decision making, but, also, that digital interaction with those agencies. I think thatâs a very good point that the Citizens Advice Bureau make. They do an amazing job of representing. Iâm very grateful for their submission. Iâm disappointed to see that even with the strength of this submission at that select committee, it was still not listened to by the governing parties, who are instead pushing this bill through today.
Now, the next one I want to look at is the Community Law Centres of Aotearoa submission. Itâs another amazing organisation that operates across Aotearoa, providing legal support and advice to New Zealanders. We refer a lot of people to community law. They do do great work. Now, the general comment that they start with is that the key concern is in relation to the suite of financial service legislative reforms; the adequate protection of financially or otherwise vulnerable customers. These are people who were given loans that were unaffordable from the start, and thereâs a lot of challenges with these loans in having robust enough enforcement of protections in law to stop that from happening. We see there are people out there who will prey on vulnerable people and who will put them into situations that actually push them further into debt. Theyâre not there to help them. They are there to make things harder for them. They, the people doing this, financially benefit from doing that. They put people in compromising positions in far worse positions, and it would be good for us to be able to provide better protections for those people in law. That is not what is happening with this bill in its current form.
The final submission that I wanted to get to was the submission here that came through from Salvation Army. Now, I donât need to introduce the Salvation Army. Everybody knows about the incredible work that they do in our community. One of their biggest concerns was add-on insurance. This is where people will make a purchase, and then there are other things that the person selling them the productâin this example, itâs a carâadds on top to increase the level of the debt, and often unknowingly people commit to far greater levels of debt than they can afford. The example they give here is a person they call Maria who purchased a car in 2022 for $16,450, but by the time her loan included all of the additional add-ons, that was nearly 30Â percent on topâmore than $5,000 on topâwhich took the total loan to $21,503. It makes what seems like a very manageable, sustainable level of debt all of a sudden spiral out of control, because all of these additional costs and charges have been added on top.
đŹ Sam Uffindell: You havenât added much value to this.
There is an opportunity in this piece of legislation to stop that kind of behaviour. The Minister across the other side says, âYou havenât added muchâ. Sorry, not the Minister but the member; sorry for my false advertisingâthe member on the other side who claims that I havenât added much should compare the contribution Iâve made in resharing three of the 1,500 submissions, the majority of which are opposed to this piece of legislation, to the contributions made by his colleagues in this House for this piece of legislation that they believe is so important that it has to be moved through in Budget urgency on a Saturday, and yet they will speak for five or eight or 12 seconds on the bill in order to move it through. Itâs an embarrassment. It discredits the work that youâre doing when you cannot even speakânot you, Madam Speaker, the member opposite; not a Minister, but the MP opposite. My question in closing for my contribution this afternoon, as it is now in the House, is, really: who are you doing this for? It isnât the people reflected in those submissions from those highly reputable organisations that do such good work in our community.
đŹ DEPUTY SPEAKER: This debate is interrupted. The House will resume at 2 p.m.
Sitting suspended from 1.03 p.m. to 2 p.m.
ASSISTANT SPEAKER (Teanau Tuiono): The House is resumed. Weâre on the third reading of the Credit Contracts and Consumer Finance Amendment Bill, and weâre on call 9, which is a National call.
This bill is about fixing the basics so that we can build our future. I commend it to the House.
TÄnÄ koe e te MÄngai o te Whare. Firstly, Iâd just like to say that I have just received a text from my mum to say that it was her birthday yesterday and I missed it, so a really big happy birthday to my wonderful mum.
đŹ Tom Rutherford: Whatâs her name?
Her nameâs Bridget, and she is the best mum.
But also thereâs been an argument that maybe I didnât miss her birthday, because itâs still the 28th. I think general consensus was that Iâm just a bad daughter, but Iâll go with the 28th! So very happy birthday to my mum, and sheâll be having a lovely day at the beach with her dog while weâre here.
Speaking of being here, Iâm here to take a call on the Credit Contracts and Consumer Finance Amendment Bill. I want to just acknowledge the Finance and Expenditure Committee, and I havenât had a chance to say congratulations to Ryan Hamilton, the new chair; so congratulations to Ryan Hamilton for being the new chair of that committee. I know that this committee have done a lot of work on this bill. Other speakers have spoken to that work, and I want to begin by acknowledging all of that work because I know that this has been a long process.
But, again, go back to being in urgency on a Saturday: I could be at the beach with my mum and her lovely dog, whose name is Casper, but Iâm not; Iâm here. And weâre not even debating a new bill. Weâre debating something that could have gone through Parliament on a different day not in urgency.
Itâs disappointing that weâve had the Budget on Thursday and all of the excitement around the Budget, but it was actually a complete flop because there was nothing in the Budgetânothing that helped people with the cost of living that our communities are really struggling with right now.
I think that this bill speaks to that value that it feels like the Government holds, where theyâre just not interested in helping people who really need it. And the way that that connects to this particular bill is that huge power imbalance that exists between large corporations and everyday people trying to live their lives. I feel like being a member here in Parliament, in this House, my main job in doing what I can to influence legislation is to balance things. Itâs to balance our country so that there isnât huge power imbalances sitting between different groups of people and so that we can all get what we need to achieve and do well.
And this just gets me, because last night we were sitting in this House and we were debating a bill that would put extra pressure on beneficiaries, the most vulnerable in this communityâa bill that would influence and disadvantage our disability community, our elderly, and those dealing with considerable medical issues. Those people from that bill are going to be disadvantaged. And this is just another exampleânot quite so big, I will say. That oneâs pretty significant; this oneâs way down the other end, not quite so much, but itâs the same concept. Itâs the same values from this Government, which is they just donât seem to care about the huge power imbalance that exists just from living in our society that we have today.
In conclusion of my introduction, Labour does not support this bill, because we believe this bill is taking us in the wrong direction, away from strong consumer protection and towards weaker accountability for lenders. A lot of the discussion has been about the retrospective clause. I acknowledge that that has been removed from the bill after a considerable amount of submissions in the select committee process. The 1,500 submissionsâmany of them spoke about the unfairness of this retrospective aspect.
I want to acknowledge the select committee again for pushing to get rid of that and for the Government to finallyâeven though it took them a really long timeâagree that that was not good lawmaking, that that did not support of the rule of law and it did not support the separation of powers within our society. This bill, as Iâve said, is going in the wrong direction, like so many of the bills we have from this Government. It is not giving people the power to stand up for themselves. When youâre going up against a huge corporation, an individual just is no match, and we in Parliament need to make sure that that power is balanced. I strongly oppose this bill.
Oh, Mr Speaker, itâs a great day. Weâre going to get this legislation passed. I commend it to the House.
TÄnÄ rawa atu koe, e te MÄngai o te Whare, otirÄ ko taku mihi tuatahi ki a rÄtou mÄ, ngÄ tini aituÄ o tÄnei wÄ. I tÄrÄ wiki ko tÄrÄ o ngÄ tipua arÄ a TÄ TÄmati Reedy. I tÄnei rÄ tonu ko Hirini Moko Mead. NÄ reira ki te tini me te mano kua wehe atu, ngÄ tipua o tÄnei wÄ kua ngaro atu, haere, haere, haere oti koutou ki te kÄinga tĹŤturu mĹ tÄtou te tangata.
Hoki mai rÄ ki a tÄtou te hunga ora. Kei te hoki aku mahara ki te wÄ kÄinga i tÄnei wÄ tonu, nÄ te mea i tÄnei wÄ kei te whakanuia te wharekai a TÄwhiwhirangi ki te marae o RÄhui i tana tau iwa tekau.
[My acknowledgements to you, Mr Speaker, and in particular I acknowledge, firstly, those who have recently passed on: last week, the great Sir TÄmati Reedy; today, Hirini Moko Mead. So, to the many who have passed on, go well, rest in the true resting place of mankind.
I return now to those here, to the living. I turn my thoughts to my home at this time, as at this time there are celebrations for the 90th anniversary of the dining hall, TÄwhiwhirangi, at RÄhui marae.]
Thank you for the indulgence of the House, Mr Speaker, as I acknowledge the great losses MÄoridom and Aotearoa are feeling at the moment and the many tangihanga across our country. I send aroha to all the grieving families, communities, and to our nation.
I also want to acknowledge a very special occasion at RÄhui Marae in Tikitiki, where we are celebrating 90 years of our wharekai Tawhiwhirangi.
Speaking of descendants who are celebrating today, thatâs who I am thinking of when I stand and speak on this bill, the Credit Contracts and Consumer Finance Amendment Billâthe impacts this will have on descendants across Ikaroa-RÄwhiti and across Aotearoa.
I will get to the bill. Itâs very rich when you hear members opposite heckling this side saying, âGet to the bill.â You guys get to the bill. How about you guys get to the bill, and then we can have a debate, because three seconds talking on the bill and then having the audacity to heckle such a great contribution about the real-life impacts this bill will have on consumers and voters is absolutely rich, and Aotearoa deserves better.
Heoi anĹ rÄ, this bill transfers responsibility for the Credit Contracts and Consumer Finance Amendment Bill (CCCFA) to the Financial Markets Authority, which we support. We also support stronger consumer protections and clearer enforcement under the CCCFA.
Until we can be guaranteed that clause 47 cannot be added back, we oppose this bill. Clause 47 changes how old lending mistakes are dealt with, giving lendersâlendersâa chance to avoid large penalties for âtechnical breachesâ even if those loans were made before the new law existed. Now, that is the risk for all everyday New Zealanders. The focus on Parliament must always be on the people we serveâthe consumer.
I did a quick ask around my whÄnau to see some real-life examples of how this would be affected. Didnât have to look far. My niece Kellyanneânot her real name; I told her she could remain anonymousâshe went and got a loan for a vehicle. Thatâs not unusual. Now, sheâs quite responsible. Sheâs got different spending habits to her auntie, and different financial management systems than her auntie. She thought, âI donât want to have this debt looming over me for too long. Iâm going to increase my paymentsââyou know, avoid paying less interestâso she did. She had in her mind the date. That was going to be the day she celebrated; that her vehicle was paid off, and that debt was gone. Because sheâs got very responsible financial habits, she studied her bank statement and realised the payments were still going out. How can that be? Then she received a statement saying not only had, in fact, she not paid off the debt; she owed $10,000âshe owed $10,000.
Now, as Iâve said, this niece is quite financially savvy. Sheâs got nous, sheâs got the inclination, and sheâs got the confidence to deal with lenders and banks. Many whÄnau do not. The power imbalance that Georgie Dansey just mentioned is absolutely real. People assume that the lenders and the banks have all the power and, somehow, they must be wrongâthey must have got their calculations wrong. Money is staying in the wrong pockets. In this case, in her case, it was $3,000 owed to her that otherwise may have just stayed in the lenderâs pocket instead of hers. WhÄnau in Ikaroa-RÄwhiti and around Aotearoa know exactly the value of each and every dollar right now. For her, that $3,000 will go a long way towards her $600 a week grocery bill. Thatâs just on the basic groceries to feed her family of fiveâ$600, not $60.
Thatâs why the 2015 disclosure regime was so important. It made sure that borrowers were made aware of the total amount being borrowed. Like I said, some people might just assume that everyone is savvy about these things, but not everyone is. Some people truly believe if theyâre borrowing $50,000, they will pay back $50,000. Thatâs why these consumer protections are so important. It requires any securityâpeople know the security taking over their propertiesâwhat their hardship rights are; information, importantly, about dispute resolution; and, of course, severe penalties for lenders were they to breach anything. Taking away those penalties is a major risk for consumers, and thatâs what we on this side of the House want to protect: the rights of our consumers.
There are many supporters of this bill who argue that it makes access to finance easier. On the face of it, most people would say thatâs a great thing. Of course we want to make it easier to get a mortgage or the latest Ford Ranger or whatever it is for you. Access to lending sounds like a really good thing. But what I know for a fact is what borrowing represents to a lot of whÄnau is hope. It represents security, the opportunity to put a roof over their whÄnauâs heads, the opportunity to provide what they believeâand itâs their right toâis the best outcome for their whÄnau. However, when those agreements are entered into without the full knowledge and the full protections of these consumers, that dream can quickly turn into a nightmare where whÄnau are not aware of the interest payments; do not have the capacity to fulfil the repayments; then not only are they left with dashed dreams but they are still left with the debt, with the shame and the heartache of houses being removed from their whenua, being removed from their communities; and they are still sat there with the debt further back than when they were when they started.
A few of my staff who serve Ikaroa-RÄwhiti in electorate and community offices around Aotearoa have been approached not just by families experiencing hardship but by the organisations who serve them; the organisations who come in in the aftermath who have to deal with the whÄnau who have not only found themselves with a mountain of debt, but, as I said, the disappointment of not even having the asset for which they borrowed.
While we are all about efficiencies, the main priority for us on this side of the House is to protect the rights of consumers so that whÄnau are not left overpaying by $10,000 or not actually having to navigate a system where people whose job it is to do thisâpeople have got to take time out of their day from their work to navigate these systems just to make sure theyâre not getting ripped off.
Hei whakakapi [in closing], it would be very remiss of me, as the spokesperson for sport and recreation for the Labour Party, not to acknowledge NgÄti Porou East Coast and Poverty Bay, who are about to take the field for the Kingâs Birthday local derby in TĹŤranga-nui-a-Kiwa. Go the coast; he wÄŤwÄŤ NÄti. KÄore rawa atu mÄtou e whakaae ki tÄnei pire.
[We absolutely do not agree with this bill.]
It is my privilege to speak to commend the third reading of this bill. But before I commend it to the House, I have to say happy birthday to Minister Mike Butterick. I commend the bill to the House in building the future.
I commend this bill to the House.
A party vote was called for on the question, That the Credit Contracts and Consumer Finance Amendment Bill be now read a third time.
Ayes 67
New Zealand National 48; ACT New Zealand 11; New Zealand First 8.
Noes 45
New Zealand Labour 29; Green Party of Aotearoa New Zealand 14; Ferris; Kapa-Kingi.
Motion agreed to.
Bill read a third time.
Financial Service Providers (Registration and Dispute Resolution) Amendment Bill
Legislative Statement
đŁď¸ Spoke in this debate (13)
- Dan Bidois (New Zealand National Party â Member for Northcote)
- Cameron Brewer (New Zealand National Party â Member for Upper Harbour)
- Dr Carlos Cheung (New Zealand National Party â Member for Mount Roskill)
- Reuben Davidson (New Zealand Labour Party â Member for Christchurch East)
- Ryan Hamilton (New Zealand National Party â Member for Hamilton East)
- Nancy Lu (New Zealand National Party â List Member)
- Ricardo MenĂŠndez March (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand â List Member)
- Tom Rutherford (New Zealand National Party â Member for Bay of Plenty)
- Todd Stephenson (ACT New Zealand â List Member)
- Cushla Tangaere-Manuel (New Zealand Labour Party â Member for Ikaroa-RÄwhiti)
- Arena Williams (New Zealand Labour Party â Member for Manurewa)
- Dr David Wilson (New Zealand First Party â List Member)
- Dr Lawrence Xu-Nan (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand â List Member)