πŸ§ͺ EXPERIMENTAL / ALPHA β€” this is an independent prototype, not an official record. Data may be incomplete or wrong - always check the linked Hansard source before relying on it.
Hot Air

Wednesday, 11 September 2019

End of Life Choice Bill

Part 2 Assisted dying (continued)
HansardID: c02c7bfa-9dcf-4f98-90f6-30ce65ddea6d
πŸ—³οΈ 6 votes β€” jump to votes section
Back to debates
πŸ“œ Official Hansard transcript
← General Debate End of Life Choice Bill β†’
πŸ—£οΈ Speech Hon Anne Tolley (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for East Coast)
Time unknown

Kia ora tātou, colleagues. Members, when we were last considering the bill we were part way through the voting on the amendments to Part 2. The committee had just completed the vote on David Seymour’s amendments to Part 2 set out on Supplementary Order Paper (SOP) 259, which were agreed to. We now come to the remaining amendments to Part 2.

For the convenience of members, all Supplementary Order Papers on the End of Life Choice Bill that are fewer than five pages long have been collated into sets on the Table. Supplementary Order Papers longer than five pages are on the Table individually.

So we come to Part 2β€”clauses 6 to 18. Louisa Wall’s amendment replacing clauses 6 to 18 with new Parts 2 and 3 set out on SOP No 235 is out of order as being inconsistent with a previous decision of the committee on David Seymour’s SOP No 259.

The question was put that the amendment set out on Supplementary Order Paper 209 in the name of Simon O’Connor be agreed to.

πŸ—£οΈ Speech Hon Anne Tolley (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for East Coast)
Time unknown

Simeon Brown’s amendment replacing clause 8(2) set out on Supplementary Order Paper (SOP) 300 is out of order as being inconsistent with a previous decision of the committee on David Seymour’s SOP 259. Simeon Brown’s amendment replacing clause 8(2) set out on SOP 301 is out of order as being inconsistent with a previous decision of the committee on David Seymour’s SOP 259.

The question was put that the amendment set out on Supplementary Order Paper 308 in the name of the Hon Maggie Barry be agreed to.

πŸ—£οΈ Speech Hon Anne Tolley (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for East Coast)
Time unknown

Agnes Loheni’s amendment to clause 9(2), set out on Supplementary Order Paper (SOP) 317 is out of order as being inconsistent with a previous decision of the committee on David Seymour’s SOP 259.

The question was put that the amendment set out on Supplementary Order Paper 305 in the name of Simeon Brown be agreed to.

πŸ—£οΈ Speech Ruth Dyson (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Port Hills)
Time unknown

Kanwaljit Singh Bakshi’s amendment set out on Supplementary Order Paper (SOP) 309 is out of order as being inconsistent with a previous decision of the committee on David Seymour’s SOP 259.

The question was put that the amendment set out on Supplementary Order Paper 319 in the name of the Hon Maggie Barry be agreed to.

Amendment not agreed to.

Part 2 as amended agreed to.

Part 3 Accountability

πŸ—£οΈ Spoke in this debate (2)

  • Ruth Dyson (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Port Hills)
  • Hon Anne Tolley (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for East Coast)

πŸ—³οΈ Votes in this debate (6)

βœ• Failed
Question: That the amendment be agreed to
βœ“ Ayes (43)
Kanwaljit Singh Bakshi (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Joanne Hayes (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Chris Penk (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Helensville) Hon Nicky Wagner (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Andrew Bayly (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Hunua) Harete Hipango (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Whanganui) Maureen Pugh (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hamish Walker (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Clutha-Southland) Hon David Bennett (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Hamilton East) Anahila Kanongata'A-Suisuiki (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Dr Shane Reti (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Whangārei) Hon Meka Whaitiri (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Ikaroa-Rāwhiti) Hon Simon Bridges (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Tauranga) Melissa Lee (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Adrian Rurawhe (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Te Tai Hauāuru) Hon Poto Williams (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Christchurch East) Simeon Brown (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Pakuranga) Agnes Loheni (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Jenny Salesa (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Manukau East) Hon Michael Woodhouse (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Gerry Brownlee (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Ilam) Hon Tim Macindoe (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Hamilton West) Alastair Scott (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Wairarapa) Jonathan Young (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for New Plymouth) David Carter (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Todd McClay (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Rotorua) Hon Dr Nick Smith (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Nelson) Hon Dr David Clark (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Dunedin North) Ian McKelvie (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for RangitΔ«kei) Jamie Strange (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Hon Jacqui Dean (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Waitaki) Todd Muller (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Bay of Plenty) Rino Tirikatene (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Te Tai Tonga) Sarah Dowie (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Invercargill) Hon Alfred Ngaro (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Anne Tolley (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for East Coast) Paulo Garcia (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Simon O'Connor (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Tāmaki) Hon Phil Twyford (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Te AtatΕ«) Hon Nathan Guy (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Ōtaki) Parmjeet Parmar (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Louise Upston (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Taupō) Hon Maggie Barry (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for North Shore)
βœ• Noes (73)
Hon Kiritapu Allan (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Golriz Ghahraman (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand β€” List Member) Sir Rt Hon Trevor Mallard (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) David Seymour (ACT New Zealand β€” Member for Epsom) Ginny Andersen (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Hon Paul Goldsmith (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Jenny Marcroft (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Hon James Shaw (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand β€” List Member) Dame Rt Hon Jacinda Ardern (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Mount Albert) Hon Peeni Henare (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Tāmaki Makaurau) Hon Ron Mark (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Hon Scott Simpson (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Coromandel) Darroch Ball (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Hon Chris Hipkins (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Rimutaka) Hon Tracey Martin (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Hon Aupito William Sio (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Māngere) Hon Paula Bennett (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Upper Harbour) Brett Hudson (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Kieran McAnulty (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Stuart Smith (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Kaikōura) Dan Bidois (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Northcote) Gareth Hughes (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand β€” List Member) Clayton Mitchell (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Erica Stanford (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for East Coast Bays) Chris Bishop (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Hutt South) Raymond Huo (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) ChlΓΆe Swarbrick (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand β€” List Member) Tamati Coffey (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Waiariki) Willie Jackson (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Hon Stuart Nash (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Napier) Fletcher Tabuteau (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Hon Judith Collins (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Papakura) Shane Jones (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Greg O'Connor (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Ōhāriu) Hon Jan Tinetti (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Dr Liz Craig (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Hon Nikki Kaye (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Auckland Central) Hon David Parker (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Tim Van De Molen (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Waikato) Hon Clare Curran (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Dunedin South) Matt King (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Northland) Mark William James Patterson (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Louisa Wall (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Manurewa) Hon Marama Davidson (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand β€” List Member) Barbara Kuriger (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Taranaki-King Country) Rt Hon Winston Peters (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Angie Warren-Clark (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Hon Kelvin Davis (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Te Tai Tokerau) Denise Lee (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Maungakiekie) Willow-Jean Prime (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Dr Duncan Webb (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Christchurch Central) Matt Doocey (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Waimakariri) Iain Lees-Galloway (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Palmerston North) Hon Priyanca Radhakrishnan (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Nicola Willis (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Ruth Dyson (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Port Hills) Hon Andrew Little (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Hon Grant Robertson (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Wellington Central) Hon Dr Megan Woods (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Wigram) Paul Eagle (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Rongotai) Jan Logie (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand β€” List Member) Jami-Lee Ross (Independent β€” Member for Botany) Jian Yang (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Kris Faafoi (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Mana) Marja Lubeck (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Dr Deborah Russell (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for New Lynn) Andrew Falloon (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Rangitata) Jo Luxton (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Hon Eugenie Sage (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand β€” List Member) Hon Julie Anne Genter (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand β€” List Member) Hon Nanaia Mahuta (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Hauraki-Waikato) Hon Carmel Sepuloni (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Kelston) Hon Amy Adams (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Selwyn)
43 Ayes – 74 Noes
βœ• Failed
Question: That the amendment be agreed to
βœ“ Ayes (48)
Kanwaljit Singh Bakshi (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Nathan Guy (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Ōtaki) Simon O'Connor (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Tāmaki) Hon Louise Upston (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Taupō) Andrew Bayly (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Hunua) Joanne Hayes (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Parmjeet Parmar (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Nicky Wagner (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon David Bennett (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Hamilton East) Harete Hipango (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Whanganui) Chris Penk (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Helensville) Hamish Walker (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Clutha-Southland) Dan Bidois (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Northcote) Anahila Kanongata'A-Suisuiki (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Maureen Pugh (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Meka Whaitiri (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Ikaroa-Rāwhiti) Hon Simon Bridges (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Tauranga) Denise Lee (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Maungakiekie) Dr Shane Reti (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Whangārei) Hon Poto Williams (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Christchurch East) Simeon Brown (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Pakuranga) Melissa Lee (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Adrian Rurawhe (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Te Tai Hauāuru) Hon Michael Woodhouse (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Gerry Brownlee (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Ilam) Agnes Loheni (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Jenny Salesa (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Manukau East) Jonathan Young (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for New Plymouth) David Carter (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Tim Macindoe (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Hamilton West) Alastair Scott (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Wairarapa) Lawrence Yule (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Tukituki) Hon Dr David Clark (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Dunedin North) Hon Todd McClay (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Rotorua) Hon Dr Nick Smith (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Nelson) Hon Jacqui Dean (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Waitaki) Ian McKelvie (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for RangitΔ«kei) Jamie Strange (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Sarah Dowie (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Invercargill) Todd Muller (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Bay of Plenty) Rino Tirikatene (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Te Tai Tonga) Paulo Garcia (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Alfred Ngaro (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Anne Tolley (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for East Coast) Hon Paul Goldsmith (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Damien O'Connor (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for West Coast-Tasman) Hon Phil Twyford (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Te AtatΕ«) Hon Maggie Barry (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for North Shore)
βœ• Noes (71)
Hon Kiritapu Allan (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Hon Peeni Henare (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Tāmaki Makaurau) Hon Tracey Martin (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Hon Aupito William Sio (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Māngere) Ginny Andersen (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Hon Chris Hipkins (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Rimutaka) Kieran McAnulty (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Stuart Smith (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Kaikōura) Dame Rt Hon Jacinda Ardern (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Mount Albert) Brett Hudson (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Clayton Mitchell (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Erica Stanford (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for East Coast Bays) Darroch Ball (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Gareth Hughes (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand β€” List Member) Hon Mark Mitchell (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Rodney) ChlΓΆe Swarbrick (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand β€” List Member) Hon Paula Bennett (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Upper Harbour) Raymond Huo (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Hon Stuart Nash (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Napier) Fletcher Tabuteau (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Chris Bishop (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Hutt South) Willie Jackson (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Greg O'Connor (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Ōhāriu) Hon Jan Tinetti (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Tamati Coffey (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Waiariki) Shane Jones (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Hon David Parker (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Tim Van De Molen (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Waikato) Hon Judith Collins (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Papakura) Hon Nikki Kaye (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Auckland Central) Mark William James Patterson (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Louisa Wall (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Manurewa) Dr Liz Craig (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Matt King (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Northland) Rt Hon Winston Peters (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Angie Warren-Clark (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Hon Clare Curran (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Dunedin South) Barbara Kuriger (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Taranaki-King Country) Willow-Jean Prime (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Dr Duncan Webb (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Christchurch Central) Hon Marama Davidson (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand β€” List Member) Iain Lees-Galloway (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Palmerston North) Hon Priyanca Radhakrishnan (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Nicola Willis (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Kelvin Davis (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Te Tai Tokerau) Hon Andrew Little (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Hon Grant Robertson (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Wellington Central) Hon Dr Megan Woods (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Wigram) Matt Doocey (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Waimakariri) Jan Logie (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand β€” List Member) Jami-Lee Ross (Independent β€” Member for Botany) Jian Yang (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Ruth Dyson (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Port Hills) Marja Lubeck (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Dr Deborah Russell (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for New Lynn) Paul Eagle (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Rongotai) Jo Luxton (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Hon Eugenie Sage (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand β€” List Member) Hon Kris Faafoi (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Mana) Hon Nanaia Mahuta (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Hauraki-Waikato) Hon Carmel Sepuloni (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Kelston) Andrew Falloon (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Rangitata) Sir Rt Hon Trevor Mallard (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) David Seymour (ACT New Zealand β€” Member for Epsom) Hon Julie Anne Genter (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand β€” List Member) Jenny Marcroft (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Hon James Shaw (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand β€” List Member) Golriz Ghahraman (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand β€” List Member) Hon Ron Mark (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Hon Scott Simpson (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Coromandel) Hon Amy Adams (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Selwyn)
48 Ayes – 71 Noes
βœ• Failed
Question: That the amendment be agreed to
βœ“ Ayes (49)
Kanwaljit Singh Bakshi (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Nathan Guy (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Ōtaki) Simon O'Connor (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Tāmaki) Hon Louise Upston (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Taupō) Andrew Bayly (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Hunua) Joanne Hayes (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Parmjeet Parmar (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Nicky Wagner (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon David Bennett (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Hamilton East) Harete Hipango (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Whanganui) Chris Penk (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Helensville) Hamish Walker (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Clutha-Southland) Dan Bidois (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Northcote) Anahila Kanongata'A-Suisuiki (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Maureen Pugh (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Meka Whaitiri (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Ikaroa-Rāwhiti) Hon Simon Bridges (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Tauranga) Denise Lee (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Maungakiekie) Dr Shane Reti (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Whangārei) Hon Poto Williams (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Christchurch East) Simeon Brown (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Pakuranga) Melissa Lee (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Adrian Rurawhe (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Te Tai Hauāuru) Hon Michael Wood (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Mount Roskill) Hon Gerry Brownlee (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Ilam) Agnes Loheni (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Jenny Salesa (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Manukau East) Hon Michael Woodhouse (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) David Carter (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Tim Macindoe (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Hamilton West) Alastair Scott (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Wairarapa) Jonathan Young (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for New Plymouth) Hon Dr David Clark (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Dunedin North) Hon Todd McClay (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Rotorua) Hon Dr Nick Smith (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Nelson) Lawrence Yule (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Tukituki) Hon Jacqui Dean (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Waitaki) Ian McKelvie (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for RangitΔ«kei) Jamie Strange (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Sarah Dowie (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Invercargill) Todd Muller (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Bay of Plenty) Rino Tirikatene (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Te Tai Tonga) Paulo Garcia (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Alfred Ngaro (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Anne Tolley (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for East Coast) Hon Paul Goldsmith (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Damien O'Connor (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for West Coast-Tasman) Hon Phil Twyford (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Te AtatΕ«) Hon Maggie Barry (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for North Shore)
βœ• Noes (71)
Hon Kiritapu Allan (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Hon Peeni Henare (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Tāmaki Makaurau) Hon Tracey Martin (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Hon Aupito William Sio (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Māngere) Ginny Andersen (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Hon Chris Hipkins (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Rimutaka) Kieran McAnulty (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Stuart Smith (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Kaikōura) Dame Rt Hon Jacinda Ardern (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Mount Albert) Brett Hudson (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Clayton Mitchell (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Erica Stanford (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for East Coast Bays) Darroch Ball (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Gareth Hughes (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand β€” List Member) Hon Mark Mitchell (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Rodney) ChlΓΆe Swarbrick (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand β€” List Member) Hon Paula Bennett (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Upper Harbour) Raymond Huo (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Hon Stuart Nash (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Napier) Fletcher Tabuteau (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Chris Bishop (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Hutt South) Willie Jackson (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Greg O'Connor (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Ōhāriu) Hon Jan Tinetti (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Tamati Coffey (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Waiariki) Shane Jones (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Hon David Parker (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Tim Van De Molen (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Waikato) Hon Judith Collins (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Papakura) Hon Nikki Kaye (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Auckland Central) Mark William James Patterson (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Louisa Wall (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Manurewa) Dr Liz Craig (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Matt King (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Northland) Rt Hon Winston Peters (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Angie Warren-Clark (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Hon Clare Curran (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Dunedin South) Barbara Kuriger (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Taranaki-King Country) Willow-Jean Prime (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Dr Duncan Webb (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Christchurch Central) Hon Marama Davidson (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand β€” List Member) Iain Lees-Galloway (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Palmerston North) Hon Priyanca Radhakrishnan (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Nicola Willis (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Kelvin Davis (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Te Tai Tokerau) Hon Andrew Little (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Hon Grant Robertson (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Wellington Central) Hon Dr Megan Woods (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Wigram) Matt Doocey (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Waimakariri) Jan Logie (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand β€” List Member) Jami-Lee Ross (Independent β€” Member for Botany) Jian Yang (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Ruth Dyson (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Port Hills) Marja Lubeck (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Dr Deborah Russell (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for New Lynn) Paul Eagle (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Rongotai) Jo Luxton (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Hon Eugenie Sage (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand β€” List Member) Hon Kris Faafoi (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Mana) Hon Nanaia Mahuta (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Hauraki-Waikato) Hon Carmel Sepuloni (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Kelston) Andrew Falloon (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Rangitata) Sir Rt Hon Trevor Mallard (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) David Seymour (ACT New Zealand β€” Member for Epsom) Hon Julie Anne Genter (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand β€” List Member) Jenny Marcroft (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Hon James Shaw (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand β€” List Member) Golriz Ghahraman (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand β€” List Member) Hon Ron Mark (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Hon Scott Simpson (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Coromandel) Hon Amy Adams (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Selwyn)
49 Ayes – 71 Noes
βœ• Failed
Question: That the amendment be agreed to
βœ“ Ayes (49)
Kanwaljit Singh Bakshi (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Nathan Guy (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Ōtaki) Simon O'Connor (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Tāmaki) Hon Louise Upston (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Taupō) Andrew Bayly (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Hunua) Joanne Hayes (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Parmjeet Parmar (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Nicky Wagner (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon David Bennett (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Hamilton East) Harete Hipango (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Whanganui) Chris Penk (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Helensville) Hamish Walker (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Clutha-Southland) Dan Bidois (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Northcote) Anahila Kanongata'A-Suisuiki (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Maureen Pugh (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Meka Whaitiri (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Ikaroa-Rāwhiti) Hon Simon Bridges (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Tauranga) Denise Lee (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Maungakiekie) Dr Shane Reti (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Whangārei) Hon Poto Williams (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Christchurch East) Simeon Brown (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Pakuranga) Melissa Lee (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Adrian Rurawhe (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Te Tai Hauāuru) Hon Michael Wood (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Mount Roskill) Hon Gerry Brownlee (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Ilam) Agnes Loheni (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Jenny Salesa (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Manukau East) Hon Michael Woodhouse (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) David Carter (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Tim Macindoe (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Hamilton West) Alastair Scott (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Wairarapa) Jonathan Young (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for New Plymouth) Hon Dr David Clark (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Dunedin North) Hon Todd McClay (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Rotorua) Hon Dr Nick Smith (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Nelson) Lawrence Yule (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Tukituki) Hon Jacqui Dean (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Waitaki) Ian McKelvie (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for RangitΔ«kei) Jamie Strange (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Sarah Dowie (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Invercargill) Todd Muller (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Bay of Plenty) Rino Tirikatene (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Te Tai Tonga) Paulo Garcia (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Alfred Ngaro (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Anne Tolley (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for East Coast) Hon Paul Goldsmith (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Damien O'Connor (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for West Coast-Tasman) Hon Phil Twyford (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Te AtatΕ«) Hon Maggie Barry (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for North Shore)
βœ• Noes (71)
Hon Kiritapu Allan (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Hon Peeni Henare (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Tāmaki Makaurau) Hon Tracey Martin (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Hon Aupito William Sio (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Māngere) Ginny Andersen (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Hon Chris Hipkins (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Rimutaka) Kieran McAnulty (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Stuart Smith (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Kaikōura) Dame Rt Hon Jacinda Ardern (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Mount Albert) Brett Hudson (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Clayton Mitchell (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Erica Stanford (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for East Coast Bays) Darroch Ball (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Gareth Hughes (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand β€” List Member) Hon Mark Mitchell (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Rodney) ChlΓΆe Swarbrick (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand β€” List Member) Hon Paula Bennett (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Upper Harbour) Raymond Huo (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Hon Stuart Nash (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Napier) Fletcher Tabuteau (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Chris Bishop (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Hutt South) Willie Jackson (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Greg O'Connor (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Ōhāriu) Hon Jan Tinetti (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Tamati Coffey (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Waiariki) Shane Jones (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Hon David Parker (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Tim Van De Molen (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Waikato) Hon Judith Collins (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Papakura) Hon Nikki Kaye (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Auckland Central) Mark William James Patterson (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Louisa Wall (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Manurewa) Dr Liz Craig (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Matt King (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Northland) Rt Hon Winston Peters (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Angie Warren-Clark (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Hon Clare Curran (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Dunedin South) Barbara Kuriger (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Taranaki-King Country) Willow-Jean Prime (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Dr Duncan Webb (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Christchurch Central) Hon Marama Davidson (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand β€” List Member) Iain Lees-Galloway (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Palmerston North) Hon Priyanca Radhakrishnan (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Nicola Willis (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Kelvin Davis (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Te Tai Tokerau) Hon Andrew Little (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Hon Grant Robertson (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Wellington Central) Hon Dr Megan Woods (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Wigram) Matt Doocey (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Waimakariri) Jan Logie (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand β€” List Member) Jami-Lee Ross (Independent β€” Member for Botany) Jian Yang (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Ruth Dyson (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Port Hills) Marja Lubeck (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Dr Deborah Russell (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for New Lynn) Paul Eagle (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Rongotai) Jo Luxton (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Hon Eugenie Sage (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand β€” List Member) Hon Kris Faafoi (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Mana) Hon Nanaia Mahuta (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Hauraki-Waikato) Hon Carmel Sepuloni (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Kelston) Andrew Falloon (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Rangitata) Sir Rt Hon Trevor Mallard (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) David Seymour (ACT New Zealand β€” Member for Epsom) Hon Julie Anne Genter (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand β€” List Member) Jenny Marcroft (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Hon James Shaw (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand β€” List Member) Golriz Ghahraman (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand β€” List Member) Hon Ron Mark (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Hon Scott Simpson (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Coromandel) Hon Amy Adams (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Selwyn)
49 Ayes – 71 Noes
βœ• Failed
Question: That the amendments be agreed to
βœ“ Ayes (49)
Kanwaljit Singh Bakshi (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Nathan Guy (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Ōtaki) Simon O'Connor (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Tāmaki) Hon Louise Upston (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Taupō) Andrew Bayly (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Hunua) Joanne Hayes (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Parmjeet Parmar (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Nicky Wagner (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon David Bennett (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Hamilton East) Harete Hipango (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Whanganui) Chris Penk (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Helensville) Hamish Walker (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Clutha-Southland) Dan Bidois (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Northcote) Anahila Kanongata'A-Suisuiki (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Maureen Pugh (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Meka Whaitiri (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Ikaroa-Rāwhiti) Hon Simon Bridges (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Tauranga) Denise Lee (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Maungakiekie) Dr Shane Reti (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Whangārei) Hon Poto Williams (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Christchurch East) Simeon Brown (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Pakuranga) Melissa Lee (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Adrian Rurawhe (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Te Tai Hauāuru) Hon Michael Wood (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Mount Roskill) Hon Gerry Brownlee (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Ilam) Agnes Loheni (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Jenny Salesa (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Manukau East) Hon Michael Woodhouse (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) David Carter (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Tim Macindoe (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Hamilton West) Alastair Scott (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Wairarapa) Jonathan Young (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for New Plymouth) Hon Dr David Clark (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Dunedin North) Hon Todd McClay (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Rotorua) Hon Dr Nick Smith (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Nelson) Lawrence Yule (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Tukituki) Hon Jacqui Dean (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Waitaki) Ian McKelvie (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for RangitΔ«kei) Jamie Strange (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Sarah Dowie (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Invercargill) Todd Muller (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Bay of Plenty) Rino Tirikatene (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Te Tai Tonga) Paulo Garcia (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Alfred Ngaro (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Anne Tolley (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for East Coast) Hon Paul Goldsmith (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Damien O'Connor (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for West Coast-Tasman) Hon Phil Twyford (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Te AtatΕ«) Hon Maggie Barry (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for North Shore)
βœ• Noes (71)
Jian Yang (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Kiritapu Allan (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Hon Peeni Henare (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Tāmaki Makaurau) Hon Tracey Martin (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Hon Aupito William Sio (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Māngere) Ginny Andersen (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Hon Chris Hipkins (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Rimutaka) Kieran McAnulty (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Stuart Smith (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Kaikōura) Dame Rt Hon Jacinda Ardern (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Mount Albert) Brett Hudson (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Clayton Mitchell (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Erica Stanford (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for East Coast Bays) Darroch Ball (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Gareth Hughes (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand β€” List Member) Hon Mark Mitchell (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Rodney) ChlΓΆe Swarbrick (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand β€” List Member) Hon Paula Bennett (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Upper Harbour) Raymond Huo (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Hon Stuart Nash (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Napier) Fletcher Tabuteau (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Chris Bishop (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Hutt South) Willie Jackson (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Greg O'Connor (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Ōhāriu) Hon Jan Tinetti (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Tamati Coffey (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Waiariki) Shane Jones (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Hon David Parker (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Tim Van De Molen (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Waikato) Hon Judith Collins (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Papakura) Hon Nikki Kaye (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Auckland Central) Mark William James Patterson (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Louisa Wall (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Manurewa) Dr Liz Craig (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Matt King (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Northland) Rt Hon Winston Peters (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Angie Warren-Clark (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Hon Clare Curran (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Dunedin South) Barbara Kuriger (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Taranaki-King Country) Willow-Jean Prime (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Dr Duncan Webb (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Christchurch Central) Hon Marama Davidson (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand β€” List Member) Iain Lees-Galloway (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Palmerston North) Hon Priyanca Radhakrishnan (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Nicola Willis (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Kelvin Davis (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Te Tai Tokerau) Hon Andrew Little (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Hon Grant Robertson (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Wellington Central) Hon Dr Megan Woods (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Wigram) Matt Doocey (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Waimakariri) Jan Logie (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand β€” List Member) Jami-Lee Ross (Independent β€” Member for Botany) Ruth Dyson (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Port Hills) Marja Lubeck (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Dr Deborah Russell (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for New Lynn) Paul Eagle (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Rongotai) Jo Luxton (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Hon Eugenie Sage (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand β€” List Member) Hon Kris Faafoi (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Mana) Hon Nanaia Mahuta (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Hauraki-Waikato) Hon Carmel Sepuloni (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Kelston) Andrew Falloon (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Rangitata) Sir Rt Hon Trevor Mallard (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) David Seymour (ACT New Zealand β€” Member for Epsom) Hon Julie Anne Genter (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand β€” List Member) Jenny Marcroft (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Hon James Shaw (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand β€” List Member) Golriz Ghahraman (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand β€” List Member) Hon Ron Mark (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Hon Scott Simpson (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Coromandel) Hon Amy Adams (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Selwyn)
49 Ayes – 71 Noes
βœ• Failed
Question: That the amendment be agreed to
βœ“ Ayes (49)
Kanwaljit Singh Bakshi (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Nathan Guy (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Ōtaki) Simon O'Connor (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Tāmaki) Hon Louise Upston (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Taupō) Andrew Bayly (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Hunua) Joanne Hayes (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Parmjeet Parmar (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Nicky Wagner (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon David Bennett (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Hamilton East) Harete Hipango (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Whanganui) Chris Penk (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Helensville) Hamish Walker (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Clutha-Southland) Dan Bidois (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Northcote) Anahila Kanongata'A-Suisuiki (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Maureen Pugh (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Meka Whaitiri (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Ikaroa-Rāwhiti) Hon Simon Bridges (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Tauranga) Denise Lee (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Maungakiekie) Dr Shane Reti (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Whangārei) Hon Poto Williams (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Christchurch East) Simeon Brown (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Pakuranga) Melissa Lee (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Adrian Rurawhe (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Te Tai Hauāuru) Hon Michael Wood (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Mount Roskill) Hon Gerry Brownlee (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Ilam) Agnes Loheni (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Jenny Salesa (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Manukau East) Hon Michael Woodhouse (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) David Carter (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Tim Macindoe (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Hamilton West) Alastair Scott (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Wairarapa) Jonathan Young (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for New Plymouth) Hon Dr David Clark (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Dunedin North) Hon Todd McClay (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Rotorua) Hon Dr Nick Smith (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Nelson) Lawrence Yule (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Tukituki) Hon Jacqui Dean (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Waitaki) Ian McKelvie (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for RangitΔ«kei) Jamie Strange (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Sarah Dowie (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Invercargill) Todd Muller (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Bay of Plenty) Rino Tirikatene (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Te Tai Tonga) Paulo Garcia (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Alfred Ngaro (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Anne Tolley (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for East Coast) Hon Paul Goldsmith (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Damien O'Connor (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for West Coast-Tasman) Hon Phil Twyford (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Te AtatΕ«) Hon Maggie Barry (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for North Shore)
βœ• Noes (71)
Hon Kiritapu Allan (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Hon Peeni Henare (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Tāmaki Makaurau) Hon Tracey Martin (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Hon Aupito William Sio (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Māngere) Ginny Andersen (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Hon Chris Hipkins (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Rimutaka) Kieran McAnulty (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Stuart Smith (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Kaikōura) Dame Rt Hon Jacinda Ardern (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Mount Albert) Brett Hudson (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Clayton Mitchell (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Erica Stanford (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for East Coast Bays) Darroch Ball (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Gareth Hughes (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand β€” List Member) Hon Mark Mitchell (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Rodney) ChlΓΆe Swarbrick (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand β€” List Member) Hon Paula Bennett (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Upper Harbour) Raymond Huo (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Hon Stuart Nash (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Napier) Fletcher Tabuteau (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Chris Bishop (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Hutt South) Willie Jackson (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Greg O'Connor (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Ōhāriu) Hon Jan Tinetti (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Tamati Coffey (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Waiariki) Shane Jones (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Hon David Parker (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Tim Van De Molen (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Waikato) Hon Judith Collins (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Papakura) Hon Nikki Kaye (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Auckland Central) Mark William James Patterson (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Louisa Wall (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Manurewa) Dr Liz Craig (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Matt King (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Northland) Rt Hon Winston Peters (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Angie Warren-Clark (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Hon Clare Curran (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Dunedin South) Barbara Kuriger (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Taranaki-King Country) Willow-Jean Prime (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Dr Duncan Webb (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Christchurch Central) Hon Marama Davidson (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand β€” List Member) Iain Lees-Galloway (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Palmerston North) Hon Priyanca Radhakrishnan (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Nicola Willis (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Hon Kelvin Davis (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Te Tai Tokerau) Hon Andrew Little (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Hon Grant Robertson (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Wellington Central) Hon Dr Megan Woods (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Wigram) Matt Doocey (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Waimakariri) Jan Logie (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand β€” List Member) Jami-Lee Ross (Independent β€” Member for Botany) Jian Yang (New Zealand National Party β€” List Member) Ruth Dyson (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Port Hills) Marja Lubeck (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Dr Deborah Russell (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for New Lynn) Paul Eagle (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Rongotai) Jo Luxton (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) Hon Eugenie Sage (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand β€” List Member) Hon Kris Faafoi (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Mana) Hon Nanaia Mahuta (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Hauraki-Waikato) Hon Carmel Sepuloni (New Zealand Labour Party β€” Member for Kelston) Andrew Falloon (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Rangitata) Sir Rt Hon Trevor Mallard (New Zealand Labour Party β€” List Member) David Seymour (ACT New Zealand β€” Member for Epsom) Hon Julie Anne Genter (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand β€” List Member) Jenny Marcroft (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Hon James Shaw (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand β€” List Member) Golriz Ghahraman (Green Party of Aotearoa / New Zealand β€” List Member) Hon Ron Mark (New Zealand First Party β€” List Member) Hon Scott Simpson (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Coromandel) Hon Amy Adams (New Zealand National Party β€” Member for Selwyn)
49 Ayes – 71 Noes