🧪 EXPERIMENTAL / ALPHA — this is an independent prototype, not an official record. Data may be incomplete or wrong - always check the linked Hansard source before relying on it.
Hot Air

Tuesday, 25 September 2018

Amended Answers to Oral Questions — Question No. 10 to Minister, 19 September

HansardID: 36c6f58a-43ad-4683-89f7-5566b5451e67
Back to debates
🗣️ Speech Hon Grant Robertson (New Zealand Labour Party — Member for Wellington Central)
Time unknown

I seek leave of the House to correct an answer given to an oral question.

💬 DEPUTY SPEAKER: Is there any objection to that? No, there isn’t.

On 19 September, in my answer to question No. 10, I inadvertently left out three emails from the first exchange between Clare Curran and Derek Handley that began on 11 August. I was unaware at the time of giving the answer that there were two further emails on 11 August from Clare Curran in response to Mr Handley’s original email and an email from Mr Handley on 13 August to begin the process for setting up a phone call. I apologise to the House for that.

🗣️ Speech Hon Dr Nick Smith (New Zealand National Party — Member for Nelson)
Time unknown

I raise a point of order, Madam Speaker. You’ll be aware that the Opposition has been asking questions about the very issue of these Gmails for four weeks. The previous Speaker at the time asked the Minister to, in fact, bring them to the House and make them available to the House. My request, for the Minister to consider, is whether he will table the emails that he inadvertently did not disclose in my questions last Thursday.

🗣️ Speech Hon Anne Tolley (New Zealand National Party — Member for East Coast)
Time unknown

I’m just going to seek a bit of advice. Thank you.

🗣️ Speech Hon Grant Robertson (New Zealand Labour Party — Member for Wellington Central)
Time unknown

That material is now in the public arena—all of it—and, actually, I’d be denied leave to table it in the House under the current Speakers’ rulings. But it is available to the member.

🗣️ Speech Hon Dr Nick Smith (New Zealand National Party — Member for Nelson)
Time unknown

Madam Deputy Speaker. To be helpful—

💬 DEPUTY SPEAKER: Are you speaking to the same point of order?

Yes, I am. My understanding, from the Minister, is that the additional emails that he was referring to in his answer were those that had been publicly made available by Mr Derek Handley this morning. If that is the fact, as he assures, then it is not relevant for my request. At the time I made the request I wasn’t aware that he was referring to those particular emails.

🗣️ Speech Hon Anne Tolley (New Zealand National Party — Member for East Coast)
Time unknown

OK. That settles it. The difficulty I had, of course, was the question at question time. But everyone’s happy. We will continue.

🗣️ Spoke in this debate (3)